Fuller Theological Seminary has fostered, nurtured, and promoted the apostasy globally. By devising and implementing "strategies" and "methodologies" that run the gamut from introducing heretical doctrine, to manipulation of spiritual forces through the bringing down of "fire" from heaven, virtually all pockets of resistance to this global movement have been overcome. The following are just a sampling of the men who have contributed to framing the heretical doctrine being taught at Fuller and spread throughout the world today. Literally thousands of church leaders have been trained and "deployed" into "power" positions from this seminary.
Donald McGavran- Founding professor of Fuller's School of Missions whose influence has reshaped globally the "mission" of the "church". McGavran taught that the job of the church is not to save individuals or disciple them. (In fact to save one person out of the "context" of his sociological 'unit' is a setback to global evangelization according to him - dubbing the traditional evangelism of one soul "extraction evangelism". His notion is that when Jesus said to make 'disciples of the nations', He meant literally, the NATIONS...i.e. governments were to be discipled. This is reconstruction theology. He developed a methodology of "people movements" that is taught in the 'Perspectives' program globally. He developed the idea that cultures were to be "redeemed" ....the gospel was to be "contextualized" for each culture and adapted by the use of "redemptive analogies" to be acceptable in each culture...syncretism to the utmost, this perverted the gospel into a 'culturally relevant' message that anyone could adapt to...anyone that is except a truly born again believer. The paganism so blatant in this movement is a direct result of this teaching. They boast in how they can incorporate pagan practices into Christianity. McGavran's book "The Bridges of God" originally titled, "How Peoples Become Christian" was published in the early 50's. (6)
Ralph Winter - Ralph changed the new covenant in Christ's precious blood back to the Abrahamic covenant...He states that there is really only one covenant in the bible, the Abrahamic covenant, which was 'to be a blessing' to ALL nations.....He calls it, the "secret mission" of the church. In his way of thinking the church is to take the biblical law and standard to all nations. The Jews according to him failed in their "mission", as did Jesus! He claims that Jesus came to re-iterate the Abrahamic covenant. The church has now been assigned the task according to his thinking. This is reconstructionist at the roots, and a brazen blasphemy. Winter is the founder of the US Center for World Mission, Pasadena CA, which was a direct result of strategies developed at Fuller.(7)
C. Peter Wagner - a missions strategist, a 'think-tankers' genius who has contrived methodologies and strategies for the re-introduction of the 'gifts' and the 'mission' to the church. He co-authored MC510 Signs and Wonders with John Wimber and took this course globally to every continent. He and John were the implementers of the 'restoration' of the missing "holy spirit" to the church... The Post-denominational Church Movement and AD2000 United Prayer Track Spiritual Warfare movement are spearheaded by C. Peter Wagner. Involved with him in that work are several dozen church leaders including Francis Frangipane (co-pastor with Reuven Doron - working under direct authority of Latter Rain leader, James Watt), Ed Silvoso, Ted Haggard, Cindy Jacobs, James Morroco, John Dawson, Esther Ilnisky, Larry Stockstill, Larry Lea et al. (8)
John Wimber - by utilizing methodologies from the Fuller think tank, John took seminars around the world to "reintroduce" the missing 'gifts and offices' to the church. He preached a blatant 'Kingdom Now' restoration and dominion theology complete with their expectation of a 'great end-time harvest and revival', a revival, remember that would involve mass numbers of people. Wimber was a premier student of Fuller's ilk. Traveling on their behalf for four years in the early 1970's, he successfully introduced Cho's cell church theory in his "Church Growth" seminars. After he left Fuller, he successfully took restoration theology to most of the major denominations of the world. His seminars included Healing (how to heal!), Davidic worship (how to get 'beyond the veil', and into the throne room!), Holiness (perfection in the physical body of the saints - manifested sons theology), and on and on his seminars go....signs and wonders, apostolic offices, etc....it is completely manifested sons, including their perverted eschatology. John is directly responsible for promoting, equipping, and developing methodologies that resulted in the aberrant "manifestations" called the "Toronto Blessing". The major players in this movement were all personally trained by Wimber, and had directly received their teaching of and entry into (by the laying on of hands) what they call the 'Holy Spirit' directly from Wimber. Pastors who promote and operate in this same "power" force, are the major "players" in the Promise Keepers Movement. This thinly veiled political constituency is operating behind the scenes to change our government using the massive numbers of their constituency as leverage to gain entry into the law-making process.
Richard Foster - Renovare' - a Fuller psychologist who has fine-tuned the encounter group methodology that has pervaded the church...the precursor to [Robert] Hicks, and the tie to Catholicism, by implementing the "contemplative" virtues back to the church, words cannot describe the impact his meditative techniques have had globally! The altered state of consciousness that is the merging of Hinduism with Christianity, has been very highly developed as a tool in this movement. (9)
G. Eldon Ladd - noted "Kingdom Now" theologian. John Wimber credits Ladd with his understanding of restoration theology.(10)
It is not a mistake that Fuller Seminary has three schools. Theology, Psychology, and Missions. Their theology is reconstruction and Manifested Sons of God. Their psychology is an altered state of consciousness and mind control techniques, their "mission" is to take over governments for Jesus!
And they are succeeding!
The Fuller "Think-tank" has spawned other notables as well.
Jay Grimstead - Coalition On Revival
Jay Gary--see Missions Frontiers Vol 1:5, Vol 4:1 page 18, Vol 6:4-5April-May 1984 page 13, Vol 7:8-9 Aug-Sept 1985 page 12, Vol 9:7 July 1987 page 6, Vol 10:4 April 1988 page 4, Vol 10:8 Aug 1988 page 4,
David Bryant, (See MF Vol 4:2 page 12, )
Dr. Arthur Glasser - who defined the technology of "progression of Integration theory". Basically this was the methodology employed for ecumenism. It is still successfully being used to integrate their doctrines with peoples globally. The four steps of integration are :
1) Communication (dialog and consensus) getting people together so they can "talk" and find areas of agreement..."consensus" The most successful strategy for implementing "communication" has been to hold ecumenical prayer meetings. This has been employed at the city level-regional level, national level, global level, and has been utilized in areas of interest (secretaries, etc), and among people groups as well...pastors prayer breakfasts, women’s prayer organizations (Aglow), Businessmen (FGBMI), denominations, etc. Concerts of Prayer, and Mission America are currently being employed.
2) Fellowship - Due to dialog and consensus, they now begin to like one another, have camaraderie.
3) Co-operation - get together around a common goal or project - March for Jesus is a good example or the Billy Graham Crusades, Spiritual Warfare conferences, General of Intercession, Post-denominational church seminars, at this level there are still denominational differences.
4) The fourth and final step of integration is "Association", this is creating a whole new organizational identity - non-denominational churches were an example, people left their denominations and re-grouped into a new "form", Promise Keepers appears to be a new form (even though they adamantly deny this, their small group structure promises to bind men together in groups that will find consensus etc), as well as Antioch Networks and Cell churches.. Where people leave their denominations and create all-new organizational structures.
Many, many more!
NOTE: ALL these men are from Fuller, and many, many more you would be horrified to find out. Billy Graham has been on the board of trustees of Fuller, and Bill Bright was there during the "think tank" years...... And all of these men work in conjunction with David (Paul) Yongi Cho, under the guidance of whom they have modeled their cell group church structure. This cell church structure (and software!) includes an integration technology that ties it to PK's database, Bethany World Prayer Center, Brigada, et al...a global database that soon will include every man, women and child on the earth: where they are, what they are doing, and what ETHNICITY they are! Ethnic cleansing is at the root of this monster, and is part of a highly kept secret doctrine to eradicate many of those they happily 'embrace' at the moment. Millions of Christian workers are being utilized to bring about their own destruction, all in the name of evangelizing the world... How diabolical...satanic!
- Two of our main concerns about Promise Keepers are the blatant promotion of psychoheresy on the part of most of Promise Keepers most popular authors and speakers and a rising tide of ecumenism that blurs doctrinal distinctives. (Two other concerns, discussed later, are PK's charismatic emphasis and its outright disdain for doctrine.) Indeed, Promise Keepers is both aggressively psychological and ecumenical:
"We believe that we have a God-given mission to unite men who are separated by race, geography, culture, denomination, and economics. ... (John 17: 20-23) We are dedicated, then, to addressing the division that has separated the body of Christ for too long. We are committed to call men to reconcile in Christ, to live as one. ... In the context of covenant relationships, a man willingly grants other men the right to inquire about his relationship to God, his commitment to his family, his sexuality, and his financial dealings. Together they form a team that is committed to advance God's kingdom. Coach McCartney's challenge to us at Promise Keepers '93 targeted two phases of man-to-man relationships. Phase one focuses on meeting with a squad of men 2-4 times a month. Phase two involves meeting once a month with men of different ethnic or denominational backgrounds. ... Coach challenged us to focus on the three P's: (1) the pages of Scripture, (2) prayer, and (3) understanding one another's pain. ... when we take the risk of becoming vulnerable and transparent, we more readily understand and share the pain of our brothers. This establishes trust" (Fall 1993, Men of Action). (Emphasis added.)
It could be argued that ecumenism is the very heart of Promise Keepers. This aggressive ecumenism (the attempt to break down the barriers that separate world religions so that cooperative efforts can be undertaken) can be further illustrated from the Promise Keepers 1994 Conferences brochure -- Seize the Moment,and from the Winter 1994 issue of Men of Action:
"Clearly, something unprecedented happens when men from all denominational, ethnic, and cultural backgrounds assemble in the name of Jesus Christ. ... invite and travel with not only your friends and family but with men from different ethnic and denominational heritages. ... Remember those who are outside your church, denomination, and ethnic group." (Emphasis added.)
Notice in the above quotes the subtle line that is crossed as denominational barriers are placed in the same category as racism and social discrimination, as if they are equitable concepts. How are these barriers created? By doctrinal differences!! The implication, thus, is that doctrinal differences, like racial, ethnic, and socioeconomic differences, must be ignored if unity is to be achieved. Hence the slogan of all ecumenists -- "doctrine divides." Groups like Promise Keepers call upon Christians to disobey Christ by accepting and accommodating the presence of theological error in their midst (The Communications Digest, November-January 1996, Marc A. Graham, "Promise Keepers: Satan's Newest Ecumenical Strategy," pp. 5 & 9).
Billy Graham? In 1974, Dr. Graham convened the ecumenical Lausanne Consultation on World Evangelism. He is a former Board member of Fuller Theological Seminary and endorses Promise Keepers. At Dr. Graham's Amsterdam '83, two of the main speakers were Dr. Paul Yonggi Cho and Dr. Pat Robertson, both of whom are charismatics. Organizations include Billy Graham Center, Billy Graham Schools of Evangelism, Billy Graham Evangelistic Association. The Billy Graham Evangelistic Association also has a number of affiliated organizations including World Wide Pictures, World Wide Publications, Blue Ridge Broadcasting and the Christian Broadcasting Association, the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association of Canada, and the Graham Fund for Evangelism. Honorary Co-chair of the Lighthouse Movement, Billy Graham has placed his seal of approval on many ecumenical ventures.
Dr. Graham spoke at the 1949 Forest Homes Conference. Although claiming to know the Lord Jesus Christ, and an Evangelical evangelist, he prayed for the filling of the Holy Spirit there and from that time forward stayed in contact with Henrietta Mears, seeking her counsel. Billy Graham became an "accepted, anointed evangelist" along with Bill Bright and Richard Halverson, all members of the Fellowship of the Burning Heart.
Bill McCartney (1991-1999) -- Founder and board member of Promise Keepers, and head football coach at the University of Colorado until his January, 1995 resignation. A former Roman Catholic, McCartney's theology is now charismatic as evidenced by his membership in a local church affiliated with the Vineyard Christian Fellowship [the church has since changed its name to try to remove its Vineyard stigma] -- a denomination founded by hyper-charismatic, signs &wonders "healer" John Wimber. Promise Keepers also has McCartney's Vineyard pastor, James Ryle, on its Board of Directors, and Vineyard member Randy Phillips was its then president. (See later in this report for more on Ryle and McCartney.) [In his book From Ashes to Glory McCartney speaks glowingly of his Roman Catholic background, and asserts that he still believes much as a Roman Catholic. He states that he did not leave Roman Catholicism as much as he joined James Ryle's Vineyard Fellowship because it was "meeting his needs at the time."]
Another excerpt from "Extreme Privilege," the book now being published and distributed by Promise Keepers at their events. This segment was written by C. Peter Wagner. This is an excellent example in the field of what I've been calling "the assumption of a symmetrical universe," that is, of Christians who make up and repeat for their own purposes stories to support their inherent and false assumption that their "enemies" are doing exactly the reverse of what they do. Notice the insistence that such imaginary phenomena are real, and how these bogeymen are intentionally used to create fear and resentment against most non-Christian spiritual groups. This is not written and published by some fringe figure; this is from a book with the PK logo on its cover, to which Promise Keepers owns the copyright. (Mike Doughney, Soapbox co-host, Promise Keepers: More Book Excerpt: C. Peter Wagner: Satanic Covenant, http://soapbox.barf.org:8280/showthread.php?threadid=6348)
Below is discussed briefly some of the Vineyard teachings that are troubling in the light of Scripture:
1) Noncessationist -- One of the trademarks of the Vineyard movement is the belief that God is actively revealing His Word today through prophecies, words of knowledge, visions, etc. Of course, this opens the door to every kind of error and heresy imaginable. [In Power Evangelism,John Wimber says that the very basis for power evangelism is the belief that God directly reveals to us certain information. For example, on an airplane Wimber saw written clearly across a man's face, "in distinct letters," the word "adultery." As he witnessed to the man, the Spirit spoke directly to Wimber and said, "Tell him if he doesn't turn from his adultery, I'm going to take Him" (pp. 75-82).]
2) Sign gifts for today -- Until the late-1900s, orthodox Christianity believed that the sign gifts (prophecy, miracles, healing, tongues, interpretation of tongues) all had ceased with either the closing of the canon of Scripture or the death of the Apostles. Only heretical groups such as the Montanists, Shakers, and Mormons believed that such gifts were valid for today. Early Christians did not doubt that God could work miracles and heal people, but they believed that these gifts had ceased. The Pentecostals, then the charismatics, and now the Vineyard, all make the present day use of these sign gifts an important part of their system.
3) Spiritual Warfare ministry -- The Vineyard believes that Christians can be demon possessed, that those demons must be forcefully cast out, and that we are to aggressively attack Satan in order to defeat him.
4) "Power evangelism" vs. "program evangelism" -- Program evangelism is the presentation of the gospel message to a lost sinner. While not anti-program evangelism, the Vineyard believes that it is an anemic way of bringing people to Christ, especially people in the Third World. What is needed is power evangelism, that is, signs and wonders. If, in conjunction with presenting the gospel message, we also heal a person, raise the dead, cast out a demon, or speak a word of knowledge, our message will be with authority and power. The results of power evangelism, we are told, are far superior to program evangelism. It is interesting, however, to examine the Scriptural record of the results of signs and wonders. It would appear that miracles seldom produced any true faith or lasting fruit. Even with Christ, we find people following Him in order to be healed or fed, yet rejecting His message (e.g., John 6).
5) Ecumenical -- Just as with charismatics, it is experience rather than doctrine that draws people to the Vineyard. Therefore, the Vineyard people can apparently work with anyone who claims to be a Christian, no matter what they believe. The Vineyard actively encourages reunification with the Catholic church, and claims that the Pope is an evangelical Christian. We can see why the Promise Keepers, with its strong Vineyard leadership, is so ecumenical and encourages the participation of Roman Catholics, even in leadership positions.
6) Dominionist -- Dominion theology teaches that dominion over every area of life has been restored by the first coming of Christ. It is now the church's obligation to redeem not only individuals, but society as well, in order to usher in the kingdom of God. The Vineyard, following the teachings of George Ladd, believes that "the kingdom is, but not yet." That is, we are now in the kingdom of God. Wimber wrote, "The kingdom of God created the church at Pentecost through the outpouring of the Holy Spirit" (Power Evangelism, p. 34). As a result of this, Christians have "kingdom authority" (note the words to the popular Jack Hayford song "Majesty" with its charismatic teachings in this regard) that enables us to have power over sickness, demons, and nature. What the Vineyard does is to bring the characteristics of the Millennial reign of Christ to this present age. They reason that since we are in the kingdom now, we should manifest all the power that Christ had while on earth. (As Wimber was fond of saying, "I want to do the stuff Jesus did.")
This is the Vineyard's theological foundation for the belief in the validity of the sign gifts for today. The Vineyard also believes that there is yet to come a physical kingdom on earth over which Christ will rule. But they believe that the church will usher in the final aspect of the kingdom as it takes dominion over the earth. Part of this will come in the form of a great last day revival in which the world will turn to Christ. (The Bible teaches that there will be a great apostasy in the last days, not revival.) This is known as the "Latter Rain," and is taught nowhere in the Bible.
7) Eastern world view -- The Vineyard dismisses its critics by declaring that they have been blinded by their two-tier, Western world view. The Western mind-set has an "upper tier" that includes heaven, hell, God, and eternity. Westerners also have a "lower tier" of science, the empirical world of our senses -- those things that we see and experience in the natural, material order. In the Western world view, the Vineyard says there is no interaction between the two tiers. But in the Eastern world view, wrote Wimber, there is another tier -- the middle tier which, "includes the influence of angels and demons on everyday life, the Holy Spirit's intervention in divine healing, signs and wonders, and spiritual gifts. Non-Western world views make room for all kinds of supernatural intervention in everyday life, so the idea that a Christian God can heal is easy for them to accept. But we Western Christians, by excluding this middle zone, usually make little or no room for what in Scripture is normal -- the regular activity of both God and Satan in human life" (Power Evangelism, p. 138). (What we must develop is a Biblical world view. Where the Vineyard errs is failing to distinguish between the Scripture's approach to the supernatural and the superstitious, mystical approach of the Eastern mind-set.)
In the Vineyard system, all problems, including sins, can be traced back to the demonic. The secular, Westerner world view says that all of the above come from natural causes. The Biblical view is that God sovereignly controls all aspects of life. He uses angels, demons, germs, nature, and every other created thing for His purposes. We then must go back to the Scriptures to determine how God would have us handle these issues of life. And what do we find? The epistles, written to church age believers, advocate progressive sanctification, prayer, faith, feeding on the Word, and even the use of medicine for illnesses. But the epistles say virtually nothing about casting out demons (or any other signs and wonders) in order to live for God and to deal with the problems of living.
8) Baptism of the Spirit -- The Vineyard differs somewhat from Pentecostals and charismatics. One of the cardinal doctrines of the other two groups in their belief in the "baptism of the Holy Spirit" subsequent to conversion. They believe that this baptism is a second work of grace that enriches the life of the Christian and prepares him for ministry. The Vineyard, on the other hand, believes that this baptism takes place at the moment of conversion. However, they also teach that there can be multiple fillings of the Spirit after salvation.
9) Tongues-speaking -- The Vineyard also differs with respect to tongues. Although it is practiced by many within the movement, its importance is down-played, and not all Christians are expected, or encouraged, to speak in tongues. On the other hand, some Pentecostals and charismatics believe that speaking in tongues is the evidence of conversion. Others would say that it is something necessary to a fulfilled Christian experience.
- The Vineyard's teachings on the person and work of Christ (Christology) are heretical at best and blasphemous at worst. They teach that though Jesus was fully divine, He set aside His divinity while on earth, and thereby, His miraculous ministry was accomplished solely as a human, but through the power of the Holy Spirit. Therefore, the Vineyard teaches that mortal man today can perform signs and wonders on the same basis Jesus did -- through the Holy Spirit's empowering alone, we can do the same miracles, works and knowledge as Jesus, and more! Peter Wagner, one of the central leaders of the Vineyard, states that, "Jesus exercised no power of and by Himself. We today can expect to do the same or greater things than Jesus did, because we have been given access to the same power source." (Emphasis added.)
4-1 프리메이슨 오랄 로버츠 대학 출신이며 은사주의자인 테드 해가드 NAE ( 미국 복음주의 협회 ) 의장이 되다. 테드 해가드는 WORLD PRAYER CENTER ( 세계 기도 쎈터 )의 회장이기도 하다. 피터 와그너, WORLD PRAYER CENTER에서 주요 사역을 하다.
HAGGARD IS NEW N.A.E. PRESIDENT?Ted Haggard, an Oral Roberts U. grad and a charismatic, was recently named president of the National Association of Evangelicals. He is pastor of New Life Church (largest in Colo.) and president of the World Prayer Center. C. Peter Wagner who taught church growth at Fuller is the “general” who leads Christians in spiritual warfare at the WPC (5/15/99 CC). One NAE speaker, Martin Marty, has been shown by Christian News articles for over 40 years to be a liberal who attacks the Bible, denies the physical resurrection of Christ, and supports abortion and homosexuality (4/02 CC). Other speakers included pro-Catholic Chuck Colson, Bethel College & Seminary president George Brushaber. Christianity Today editor David Neff, and Assemblies of God leader Thomas Trask. Marty also spoke at the 1992 NAE meeting and another liberal, Robert Schuller, is scheduled to speak at next year's NAE meeting. Ralph Colas attended this year's NAE, the Promise Keepers Pastors and Leadership, and NRB meetings. Reports are ready from ACCC (PO Box 5455, Bethlehem, PA 18015) on some of these and are forthcoming, as funds permit, on others. Further information is available from accc@juno.com.
LOS ANGELES - Two of the country's largest ecumenical organizations are considering a realignment that could bring liberal and conservative churches together.
Lines that divide the National Council of Churches and the National Association of Evangelicals already have started to dissolve, and further changes could change the ecumenical landscape.
The realignment would involve the National Council of Churches, which traditionally has included mainline Protestant, African-American and Orthodox groups, and the more conservative National Association of Evangelicals, which represents evangelical and Pentecostal churches.
4-3 피터 와그너와 테드 해가드, WORLD PRAYER CENTER ( 세계 기도 센터 )를 창설하다.
Ted Haggard, New Life Church, World Prayer Center
September 6, 2005 Last Revised February 8, 2006
General Information
Key Words: Ted Haggard, New Life Church, mega church, ecumenism, interfaith, Colorado Springs, C. Peter Wagner, World Prayer Center, prophet, Cindy Jacobs, Rick Joyner, spiritual warfare, territorial spirits, free-market economics.
Ted Haggard founded the World Prayer Center at Colorado Springs with C. Peter Wagner. In my opinion there is an overemphasis on Church Growth, apostolic church structure including the concepts of mentoring or shepherding and prophecy. I am not against prophecy in itself, but see his ministry and others that are similar actively and agressively promoting an undue emphasis on prophecy, accepting and promoting prophecies that do not come true 100% of the time - which is the requirement set by scripture to distinguish true from false prophets. They promote the ideas of collective prayer and Spiritual Warfare and Spiritual Mapping which I see as unscriptural. Pro and con sites are listed so that anyone reading here can inform himself. Looking into what Scripture really says and comparing one’s findings with it would not be a bad idea either. Don’t just accept anyone’s interpretation of it without doing a thorough study of it yourself.
4-4 프리메이슨 빌리 그래햄이 진행하는 에큐메니칼 운동 " 라이트 하우스 운동 "에 피터 와그너의 WORLD PRAYER CENTER ( 세계 기도 센터 )가 참여하다.
LIGHTHOUSE MOVEMENT IS HUGE!?Small prayer groups from over 200,000 local churches and 300 national ministries believe they can reach every person in America with prayer, friendship, and a video depicting Jesus' life by the end of December 2000. Ministries range from Jerry Falwell's, SBC, Moody Church, Ravi Zacharias, and Kay Arthur, to Crystal Cathedral, Willow Creek, and the Episcopal Church (10/4 CT). Mission America's Paul Cedar is chair. Other key organizers were Bill Bright and Billy Graham. The Lighthouse Movement is coordinated by AD2000's Mission America, Harvest Evangelism (Ed Silvoso), and the World Prayer Center (Peter Wagner and Chuck Pierce). This ecumenical coalition predicts 3 million lighthouses by the end of next year. Prayer is much needed today, but any attempt at common doctrine (which is vital?see Amos 3:3?for uniting in corporate prayer and fellowship) would split this conglomeration asunder. Ecumenical coalitions such as this could be laying the groundwork for the "evangelical" wing of the United Religions, the world church of the Antichrist.
4-5 NAE ( 미국 복음주의 협회)와 WORLD PRAYER CENTER ( 세계 기도 센터 )의 주역 테드 해가드는 주로 프리메이슨 종교 지도자들로 구성된 프리메이슨 단체 CNP ( 국가 정책 위원회 )의 일원이다. 문선명도 이 CNP의 멤버이다.
The CNP: manipulating religion to political ends
Many of the religious evangelical groups in America are coordinated top down by a secretive organization called the Committee on National Policy. Former close Bush adviser, Rev. Ted Haggard, was a member of the Committee on National Policy until a sex and drugs scandal forced him out in late 2006.
Haggard was Pastor of the New Life Church in Colorado Springs described as the ‘evangelical Vatican,’ and was head of the National Association of Evangelicals. Ted Haggard was also a member of a highly significant and little understood sect known as Joel’s Army or the Manifest Sons of God, the same circles which spawned Sarah Palin.
Another noteworthy member of the CNP as was Grover Norquist, the man once described as the ‘Field Marshall of the Bush Plan.’
CNP members have also included not only the Rev. Sun Myung Moon Unification Church, definitely a bizarre formation whose founder openly states that he is superior to Christ. The CNP as well reportedly includes the Church of Scientology.2
자료 5 피터 와그너는 에큐메니칼 운동인 AD 2000 MOVEMENT 와 AD 2000 PRAYER TRACK 주도하다.
5-1 피터 와그너는 릭조이너와 마이크 비클( IHOP : 국제 기도 하우스 회장 )와 함께 미국 선지자 학교와 AD 2000 기도 트랙 운동의 주역이다.
The AD2000 Movement
Rick Joyner (endtime restorationist) and Mike Bickle, (one of the "Kansas City Prophets") are featured at this National School of the Prophets conference, as well, and Peter Wagner is the convener of the conference. Peter Wagner is also director of the AD2000 Prayer Track under the AD2000 and Beyond Movement (mentioned above).
The AD 2000 Ecumenical Evangelism Program is receiving unprecedented favorable responses from those who fail to recognize the unscriptural principles upon which any such movement could possibly function. Thus, an ecumenical- evangelical steamroller is being created of unparalleled proportions. In the past, efforts by liberal ecumenical leaders to forge an unscriptural unity on the basis of "peace," "love," "social action," etc., have failed. However, it now appears that this newest tactic of Satan to produce an unscriptural, ecumenical unity through the use of "Evangelism" has a great potential for success unless God's people wake up to what is really happening in the name of Evangelism. This dangerous program should be exposed and rejected by all who truly love Jesus Christ and desire to obey and please Him.
5-3 AD 2000년 기도 운동은 기독교와 다른 종교들의 상호 이해와 에큐메니칼 정신을 고양한다는 취지로 발진되었으며 이것은 뉴에이지 시대의 하나의 종교를 향한 서곡이다.
The objectives of the A.D. 2000 prayer movements advocate the wisdom of man rather than biblical evangelism. A.D. 2000 leaders state that the goal of these marches is to remove obstacles to revival so they can share their faith. However, it seems necessary to inquire what is "their faith" and what they mean by "revival." A revival of human reconciliation and cooperation without reconciliation with God through Jesus Christ? Faith in "reasonable people" who will be able to bring heaven into the world? A revival of peace at the expense of innocent life, of the abolition of the right and responsibility of a government to declare a just war? A revival of ecumenical unity and mutual understanding between Christianity and other religions, which will not offend people by preaching the Gospel? Such a revival can hardly be considered a Christian revival, but is quite in harmony with the New Age/One World Religion agenda of global integration.
If it seems that modern prayer movements are adopting the goals of the New Age, it is certain that they are employing their methods. In 1989, an event celebrated as "Harmonic Convergence" assembled thousands of New Agers at sacred points or ‘energy points’ on the earth to pray and meditate. This occult concept is based upon the premise that large numbers of people acting together in harmony in a given location create a ‘collective consciousness.’ When a sufficient percentage of the world’s population is involved, "critical mass" is achieved, which will then generate enough spiritual power to ultimately cause "planetary transformation" and the dawn of a New Age. World Action for the Millennium (WAM), which is supported by a number of globalist organizations, has even announced the date for such an event to occur:
“The Alpha Course is a wonderful and proven tool for evangelism in the local church... I enthusiastically support and recommend Alpha.” -- Dr. C. Peter Wagner, cited page 2, Alpha News International Online, August-November 1999 (http://www.alpha.org.uk/news/99-08/page2.htm)
자료 7 에큐메니칼 운동과 은사주의 운동 단체 YWAM ( 예수 전도단 )과 같이 하는 피터 와그너
7-1 피터 와그너는 예수 전도단이 주최하는 30일 무슬림 기도 포커스와 30일 힌두 기도 포커스의 레퍼런스 이사로서 활동하였다.
C. Peter Wagner was on the YWAM "Board Of Reference" for the 30 Days Muslim Prayer Focus and for the 30 Days Hindu Prayer Focus. (http://www.ywam.org/prayer/board.html)
1. Spiritual Warfare - A laity-driven attack on spiritual strongholds has been moving through the American church for over 20 years now. Spiritual/prayer warfare is sustained, offensive prayer aimed at repentance, restoration and reformation. The movement has recently matured and become better grounded. Key Leaders: Dr. C. Peter Wagner, Global Harvest Ministries; John Dawson, YWAM; Cindy Jacobs, Generals of Intercession; Francis Frangipane, River of Life. (The Big Picture, David Bradshaw, James A. Rutz, http://www.myideafactory.net/bigpict.html)
7-2 YWAM (예수 전도단)은 로마 카톨릭과 함께하는 에큐메니칼 운동을 적극적으로 전개한다.
YWAM's Ecumenical Error
(Increasing the font size will cause text overlapping with some browsers, such as Firefox)
Around February, 2006, I ran into a group of young people who had just completed a Discipleship Training School (DTS) with Youth With A Mission. They said that they were on a mission working with Roman Catholics at a conference in Brisbane City Hall. Not being able to understand how Protestant missionaries could get into a Catholic conference to evangelise, I questioned them to discover that they were practicing Catholics (not ex-Catholics) fully integrated with YWAM, and merely helping out at the conference. They vigorously defended Mariolatry, the Mass, Tradition and other errors of Roman Catholicism.
These kids had just been processed by a so called Protestant mission organisation. They had joined YWAM as Catholics and after their Discipleship Training School were still Catholics. It was most upsetting to see these kids on the Broad Road yet thinking they were serving our Lord.
I rang YWAM to be told, “Catholics are welcome, and the beauty of it all is that there is no conflict between denominations.” Since when has Roman Catholicism been a Christian denomination? In the following article, YWAM praises the Pope:
See: The Watershed Pope.
The following web site speaks of YWAM’s well established Catholic connection plus other highly unscriptural activities including the creation of 'Messianic Muslims', which I haven’t fully confirm!ed:
See: Youth With A Mission.
Rob Clarke, Leader of YWAM Ireland, is a Catholic. The following article makes this clear:
YWAM has been slipping into apostasy for years. I and many others have tried to help them back to orthodoxy, written letters to their leaders, all without success. It has been made plain to us and others that they have completely bought into every aspect of the New Apostolic Reformation and are now very visible and vocal proponents of the C. Peter Wagner "gospel".
자료 8 뉴에이지 운동과 에큐메니칼 운동하는 복음주의 단체 IHOP ( 국제 기도의 집 )를 지원하는 피터 와그너
8-1 국제 기도 하우스 운동 ( 의장 마이크 비클 )을 지지하는 인사들 : 잭 해이포드, 빌브라이트, 로렌 커닝햄, 존 도우슨, 피터 와그너, 더치 시트
Endorsements
“The Church today needs to be mobilized with continual prayer and fasting to release the harvest of souls waiting to be garnered from among the nations. Mike Bickle’s reliable ministry at his missions base in Kansas City is helping to answer a great need in this hour.”
?Jack W. Hayford, The Church On The Way
“The Great Commission needs to be fueled with fiery, continual prayer with fasting. Our greatest effectiveness in reaching millions of souls will be seen only as our work is bathed in prayer and fasting. Prayer ministries like Mike Bickle’s in Kansas City are important for the completion of the Great Harvest.”
?Bill Bright, Campus Crusade for Christ
“The Great Harvest needs to be supplied by continual prayer and fasting. Intercessory ministries like Mike Bickle’s in Kansas City are vital for the fulfillment of the Great Commission.”
?Loren Cunningham, Youth With A Mission (YWAM)
"Mike, you are helping fulfill a desire of God’s heart for His presence to be enthroned night and day upon a people that love Him. What you are pioneering at the IHOP?KC Missions Base has huge significance for all who labor to reach the nations. May your lamp of worship and prayer continue to shine!"
?John Dawson , Youth With A Mission (YWAM)
“As a lifelong missiologist, I cannot help but think that the landscape of humanity will drastically change when the body of Christ actually becomes a House of Prayer. Mike Bickle has risked it all to convince us of this fact. I heartily recommend this amazing work!”
?C. Peter Wagner, Wagner Leadership Institute
"Spiritual awakening in our nation and world cannot be sustained unless heaven's bowls stay continually filled through worship and intercession. Now, more than ever, we need night and day prayer to make a difference! Thanks to Mike Bickle for helping to lead the charge."
?Dutch Sheets
“Many pastors in the Kansas City area are grateful to God for raising up IHOP?KC in our city. The knowledge that hundreds of intercessors are crying out night and day with fasting for revival in our city strengthens our hearts in the battle. We thank Mike Bickle and the IHOP?KC leaders, and stand with them knowing that their labors are resulting in spiritual blessing and unity in the Church in our city.”
?Howard Cordell and leadership team, Midwest Ministers Fellowship (Network of over 200 pastors and ministries in the Kansas City region)
"I am very impressed with the focus on prayer and holiness as the foundation of world missions that I find with Mike Bickle's missions base in Kansas City. Would that the whole body of Christ had such zeal!"
Bickle's theology and methods have been challenged by many in the church who assert that he is in error in some of his practices and beliefs. Their criticism, warranted or not, focuses mainly on the basis of his theology, his allegorical interpretation of the Song of Songs
Song of songs
Song of Songs is a book of the Hebrew Bible or Old Testament. It may also refer to:In music:*Song of songs , the debut album by David and the Giants... , and the moral failings of some of the prophets that he has promoted, including Bob Jones and Paul Cain
Paul Cain
Paul Cain is a Pentecostal Christian minister involved with both neo-charismatic churches and the Charismatic Movement. As a young man he was one of the Voice of Healing revivalists of the 50s.... .
Criticism has spanned several decades, from contemporary critic Rev. Keith Gibson, director of the Kansas City office of the
Apologetics Resource Center to a Kansas City Pastor, Rev. Ernie Gruen, who authored a report entitled "Documentation of the Aberrant Practices and Teaching of the Kansas City Fellowship (Grace Ministries)" in 1990. It was around this time that Bickle and his church affiliated with John Wimber and the Association of Vineyard Churches (AVC) in part to address the issues raised by his critics. Regarding these issues, Bickle attempted to divert responsibility by saying "We were tempted to say that the attacks were all of the devil. In retrospect, we see that God’s hand in all of this - even using the things that came from Satan’s hand as well. Some of the criticisms were valid (especially concerning our pride) others were not."
Bickle's controversial end-times eschatology has aligned him with Latter Rain thinking, and especially the doctrine that emerged from it known as "Joel's Army." Bickle, in December 2008 was quoted as saying "We're not afraid of the great tribulation, the judgment of God, we're releasing it. We're not victims that are fearful and helpless, we're participants. We're agents in God's hands, loosing through prayers of faith supernatural provisions for the saints and heavenly arsenals striking the power bases - the political and military and economic power bases across the world, the Holy Spirit will release Heavenly arsenal and strike and literally and physically destroy them through the prayers of faith of the unified body of Christ.".
Mike Bickle, director of the International House of Prayer (IHOP) in Kansas City, and a well-known leader in the Prophetic Movement, claims that God is restoring contemplative prayer to the church. He goes on to claim that contemplative prayer is a God ordained means of entering into the fullness of God, and that the brightest lights in church history have been Roman Catholic mystics who lived during the dark ages. He went on to say the western church had much to learn from these mystics.
이상 올린 일부 자료만을 가지고도 신사도 운동은 개혁 교회들을 변혁시켜 그들을 세계적인 에큐메니칼의 구도하에 넣겠다는 의도하에 펼쳐지는 전략적 운동임을 알 수 있습니다. 이 운동은 복음을 전파하려는 운동이 아니라, 종교 개혁을 엎고 통치주의 신학에 의한 새로운 기독교 체제와 종교 체제를 목적으로 벌이는 운동입니다.
- 신사도들은 종교 개혁자들의 교리를 전적으로 무시합니다.
- 오순절 주의자와 같이 하며 오순절 주의 진영에 포진하여 있습니다.
- 번영신학과 궤를 같이 하고 있습니다.
- 순수한 복음주의적 색채로 가장하지만,
결국 프리메이슨들이 벌이는 뉴에이지 운동과 궤를 같이 하고 있습니다.
그들은 우리 교회들에 축사, 내적 치유, 예언, 방언강조, 임파테이션, 열광적 예배와 집회, 초자연적 기적 표적, 기적적 치유, 신비주의, 성경과 교리에 집착하지 않음, 은사주의와 실용주의에 의한 교회 성장등의 풍조를 안겨주고 있습니다. 우리 교회들 구석 구석에 손이 뻗쳐 있음을 쉽게 알 수 있습니다.
부기 : 게시자가 시간적인 여유가 없는 관계로 위 글들을 번역하여 올리지 못함을 죄송스럽게 생각합니다. 여유가 되는대로 번역할 예정입니다.
Fuller Theological Seminary has fostered, nurtured, and promoted the apostasy globally. By devising and implementing "strategies" and "methodologies" that run the gamut from introducing heretical doctrine, to manipulation of spiritual forces through the bringing down of "fire" from heaven, virtually all pockets of resistance to this global movement have been overcome. The following are just a sampling of the men who have contributed to framing the heretical doctrine being taught at Fuller and spread throughout the world today. Literally thousands of church leaders have been trained and "deployed" into "power" positions from this seminary.
Donald McGavran- Founding professor of Fuller's School of Missions whose influence has reshaped globally the "mission" of the "church". McGavran taught that the job of the church is not to save individuals or disciple them. (In fact to save one person out of the "context" of his sociological 'unit' is a setback to global evangelization according to him - dubbing the traditional evangelism of one soul "extraction evangelism". His notion is that when Jesus said to make 'disciples of the nations', He meant literally, the NATIONS...i.e. governments were to be discipled. This is reconstruction theology. He developed a methodology of "people movements" that is taught in the 'Perspectives' program globally. He developed the idea that cultures were to be "redeemed" ....the gospel was to be "contextualized" for each culture and adapted by the use of "redemptive analogies" to be acceptable in each culture...syncretism to the utmost, this perverted the gospel into a 'culturally relevant' message that anyone could adapt to...anyone that is except a truly born again believer. The paganism so blatant in this movement is a direct result of this teaching. They boast in how they can incorporate pagan practices into Christianity. McGavran's book "The Bridges of God" originally titled, "How Peoples Become Christian" was published in the early 50's. (6)
Ralph Winter - Ralph changed the new covenant in Christ's precious blood back to the Abrahamic covenant...He states that there is really only one covenant in the bible, the Abrahamic covenant, which was 'to be a blessing' to ALL nations.....He calls it, the "secret mission" of the church. In his way of thinking the church is to take the biblical law and standard to all nations. The Jews according to him failed in their "mission", as did Jesus! He claims that Jesus came to re-iterate the Abrahamic covenant. The church has now been assigned the task according to his thinking. This is reconstructionist at the roots, and a brazen blasphemy. Winter is the founder of the US Center for World Mission, Pasadena CA, which was a direct result of strategies developed at Fuller.(7)
C. Peter Wagner - a missions strategist, a 'think-tankers' genius who has contrived methodologies and strategies for the re-introduction of the 'gifts' and the 'mission' to the church. He co-authored MC510 Signs and Wonders with John Wimber and took this course globally to every continent. He and John were the implementers of the 'restoration' of the missing "holy spirit" to the church... The Post-denominational Church Movement and AD2000 United Prayer Track Spiritual Warfare movement are spearheaded by C. Peter Wagner. Involved with him in that work are several dozen church leaders including Francis Frangipane (co-pastor with Reuven Doron - working under direct authority of Latter Rain leader, James Watt), Ed Silvoso, Ted Haggard, Cindy Jacobs, James Morroco, John Dawson, Esther Ilnisky, Larry Stockstill, Larry Lea et al. (8)
John Wimber - by utilizing methodologies from the Fuller think tank, John took seminars around the world to "reintroduce" the missing 'gifts and offices' to the church. He preached a blatant 'Kingdom Now' restoration and dominion theology complete with their expectation of a 'great end-time harvest and revival', a revival, remember that would involve mass numbers of people. Wimber was a premier student of Fuller's ilk. Traveling on their behalf for four years in the early 1970's, he successfully introduced Cho's cell church theory in his "Church Growth" seminars. After he left Fuller, he successfully took restoration theology to most of the major denominations of the world. His seminars included Healing (how to heal!), Davidic worship (how to get 'beyond the veil', and into the throne room!), Holiness (perfection in the physical body of the saints - manifested sons theology), and on and on his seminars go....signs and wonders, apostolic offices, etc....it is completely manifested sons, including their perverted eschatology. John is directly responsible for promoting, equipping, and developing methodologies that resulted in the aberrant "manifestations" called the "Toronto Blessing". The major players in this movement were all personally trained by Wimber, and had directly received their teaching of and entry into (by the laying on of hands) what they call the 'Holy Spirit' directly from Wimber. Pastors who promote and operate in this same "power" force, are the major "players" in the Promise Keepers Movement. This thinly veiled political constituency is operating behind the scenes to change our government using the massive numbers of their constituency as leverage to gain entry into the law-making process.
Richard Foster - Renovare' - a Fuller psychologist who has fine-tuned the encounter group methodology that has pervaded the church...the precursor to [Robert] Hicks, and the tie to Catholicism, by implementing the "contemplative" virtues back to the church, words cannot describe the impact his meditative techniques have had globally! The altered state of consciousness that is the merging of Hinduism with Christianity, has been very highly developed as a tool in this movement. (9)
G. Eldon Ladd - noted "Kingdom Now" theologian. John Wimber credits Ladd with his understanding of restoration theology.(10)
It is not a mistake that Fuller Seminary has three schools. Theology, Psychology, and Missions. Their theology is reconstruction and Manifested Sons of God. Their psychology is an altered state of consciousness and mind control techniques, their "mission" is to take over governments for Jesus!
And they are succeeding!
The Fuller "Think-tank" has spawned other notables as well.
Jay Grimstead - Coalition On Revival
Jay Gary--see Missions Frontiers Vol 1:5, Vol 4:1 page 18, Vol 6:4-5April-May 1984 page 13, Vol 7:8-9 Aug-Sept 1985 page 12, Vol 9:7 July 1987 page 6, Vol 10:4 April 1988 page 4, Vol 10:8 Aug 1988 page 4,
David Bryant, (See MF Vol 4:2 page 12, )
Dr. Arthur Glasser - who defined the technology of "progression of Integration theory". Basically this was the methodology employed for ecumenism. It is still successfully being used to integrate their doctrines with peoples globally. The four steps of integration are :
1) Communication (dialog and consensus) getting people together so they can "talk" and find areas of agreement..."consensus" The most successful strategy for implementing "communication" has been to hold ecumenical prayer meetings. This has been employed at the city level-regional level, national level, global level, and has been utilized in areas of interest (secretaries, etc), and among people groups as well...pastors prayer breakfasts, women’s prayer organizations (Aglow), Businessmen (FGBMI), denominations, etc. Concerts of Prayer, and Mission America are currently being employed.
2) Fellowship - Due to dialog and consensus, they now begin to like one another, have camaraderie.
3) Co-operation - get together around a common goal or project - March for Jesus is a good example or the Billy Graham Crusades, Spiritual Warfare conferences, General of Intercession, Post-denominational church seminars, at this level there are still denominational differences.
4) The fourth and final step of integration is "Association", this is creating a whole new organizational identity - non-denominational churches were an example, people left their denominations and re-grouped into a new "form", Promise Keepers appears to be a new form (even though they adamantly deny this, their small group structure promises to bind men together in groups that will find consensus etc), as well as Antioch Networks and Cell churches.. Where people leave their denominations and create all-new organizational structures.
Many, many more!
NOTE: ALL these men are from Fuller, and many, many more you would be horrified to find out. Billy Graham has been on the board of trustees of Fuller, and Bill Bright was there during the "think tank" years...... And all of these men work in conjunction with David (Paul) Yongi Cho, under the guidance of whom they have modeled their cell group church structure. This cell church structure (and software!) includes an integration technology that ties it to PK's database, Bethany World Prayer Center, Brigada, et al...a global database that soon will include every man, women and child on the earth: where they are, what they are doing, and what ETHNICITY they are! Ethnic cleansing is at the root of this monster, and is part of a highly kept secret doctrine to eradicate many of those they happily 'embrace' at the moment. Millions of Christian workers are being utilized to bring about their own destruction, all in the name of evangelizing the world... How diabolical...satanic!
- Two of our main concerns about Promise Keepers are the blatant promotion of psychoheresy on the part of most of Promise Keepers most popular authors and speakers and a rising tide of ecumenism that blurs doctrinal distinctives. (Two other concerns, discussed later, are PK's charismatic emphasis and its outright disdain for doctrine.) Indeed, Promise Keepers is both aggressively psychological and ecumenical:
"We believe that we have a God-given mission to unite men who are separated by race, geography, culture, denomination, and economics. ... (John 17: 20-23) We are dedicated, then, to addressing the division that has separated the body of Christ for too long. We are committed to call men to reconcile in Christ, to live as one. ... In the context of covenant relationships, a man willingly grants other men the right to inquire about his relationship to God, his commitment to his family, his sexuality, and his financial dealings. Together they form a team that is committed to advance God's kingdom. Coach McCartney's challenge to us at Promise Keepers '93 targeted two phases of man-to-man relationships. Phase one focuses on meeting with a squad of men 2-4 times a month. Phase two involves meeting once a month with men of different ethnic or denominational backgrounds. ... Coach challenged us to focus on the three P's: (1) the pages of Scripture, (2) prayer, and (3) understanding one another's pain. ... when we take the risk of becoming vulnerable and transparent, we more readily understand and share the pain of our brothers. This establishes trust" (Fall 1993, Men of Action). (Emphasis added.)
It could be argued that ecumenism is the very heart of Promise Keepers. This aggressive ecumenism (the attempt to break down the barriers that separate world religions so that cooperative efforts can be undertaken) can be further illustrated from the Promise Keepers 1994 Conferences brochure -- Seize the Moment,and from the Winter 1994 issue of Men of Action:
"Clearly, something unprecedented happens when men from all denominational, ethnic, and cultural backgrounds assemble in the name of Jesus Christ. ... invite and travel with not only your friends and family but with men from different ethnic and denominational heritages. ... Remember those who are outside your church, denomination, and ethnic group." (Emphasis added.)
Notice in the above quotes the subtle line that is crossed as denominational barriers are placed in the same category as racism and social discrimination, as if they are equitable concepts. How are these barriers created? By doctrinal differences!! The implication, thus, is that doctrinal differences, like racial, ethnic, and socioeconomic differences, must be ignored if unity is to be achieved. Hence the slogan of all ecumenists -- "doctrine divides." Groups like Promise Keepers call upon Christians to disobey Christ by accepting and accommodating the presence of theological error in their midst (The Communications Digest, November-January 1996, Marc A. Graham, "Promise Keepers: Satan's Newest Ecumenical Strategy," pp. 5 & 9).
Billy Graham? In 1974, Dr. Graham convened the ecumenical Lausanne Consultation on World Evangelism. He is a former Board member of Fuller Theological Seminary and endorses Promise Keepers. At Dr. Graham's Amsterdam '83, two of the main speakers were Dr. Paul Yonggi Cho and Dr. Pat Robertson, both of whom are charismatics. Organizations include Billy Graham Center, Billy Graham Schools of Evangelism, Billy Graham Evangelistic Association. The Billy Graham Evangelistic Association also has a number of affiliated organizations including World Wide Pictures, World Wide Publications, Blue Ridge Broadcasting and the Christian Broadcasting Association, the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association of Canada, and the Graham Fund for Evangelism. Honorary Co-chair of the Lighthouse Movement, Billy Graham has placed his seal of approval on many ecumenical ventures.
Dr. Graham spoke at the 1949 Forest Homes Conference. Although claiming to know the Lord Jesus Christ, and an Evangelical evangelist, he prayed for the filling of the Holy Spirit there and from that time forward stayed in contact with Henrietta Mears, seeking her counsel. Billy Graham became an "accepted, anointed evangelist" along with Bill Bright and Richard Halverson, all members of the Fellowship of the Burning Heart.
Bill McCartney (1991-1999) -- Founder and board member of Promise Keepers, and head football coach at the University of Colorado until his January, 1995 resignation. A former Roman Catholic, McCartney's theology is now charismatic as evidenced by his membership in a local church affiliated with the Vineyard Christian Fellowship [the church has since changed its name to try to remove its Vineyard stigma] -- a denomination founded by hyper-charismatic, signs &wonders "healer" John Wimber. Promise Keepers also has McCartney's Vineyard pastor, James Ryle, on its Board of Directors, and Vineyard member Randy Phillips was its then president. (See later in this report for more on Ryle and McCartney.) [In his book From Ashes to Glory McCartney speaks glowingly of his Roman Catholic background, and asserts that he still believes much as a Roman Catholic. He states that he did not leave Roman Catholicism as much as he joined James Ryle's Vineyard Fellowship because it was "meeting his needs at the time."]
Another excerpt from "Extreme Privilege," the book now being published and distributed by Promise Keepers at their events. This segment was written by C. Peter Wagner. This is an excellent example in the field of what I've been calling "the assumption of a symmetrical universe," that is, of Christians who make up and repeat for their own purposes stories to support their inherent and false assumption that their "enemies" are doing exactly the reverse of what they do. Notice the insistence that such imaginary phenomena are real, and how these bogeymen are intentionally used to create fear and resentment against most non-Christian spiritual groups. This is not written and published by some fringe figure; this is from a book with the PK logo on its cover, to which Promise Keepers owns the copyright. (Mike Doughney, Soapbox co-host, Promise Keepers: More Book Excerpt: C. Peter Wagner: Satanic Covenant, http://soapbox.barf.org:8280/showthread.php?threadid=6348)
Below is discussed briefly some of the Vineyard teachings that are troubling in the light of Scripture:
1) Noncessationist -- One of the trademarks of the Vineyard movement is the belief that God is actively revealing His Word today through prophecies, words of knowledge, visions, etc. Of course, this opens the door to every kind of error and heresy imaginable. [In Power Evangelism,John Wimber says that the very basis for power evangelism is the belief that God directly reveals to us certain information. For example, on an airplane Wimber saw written clearly across a man's face, "in distinct letters," the word "adultery." As he witnessed to the man, the Spirit spoke directly to Wimber and said, "Tell him if he doesn't turn from his adultery, I'm going to take Him" (pp. 75-82).]
2) Sign gifts for today -- Until the late-1900s, orthodox Christianity believed that the sign gifts (prophecy, miracles, healing, tongues, interpretation of tongues) all had ceased with either the closing of the canon of Scripture or the death of the Apostles. Only heretical groups such as the Montanists, Shakers, and Mormons believed that such gifts were valid for today. Early Christians did not doubt that God could work miracles and heal people, but they believed that these gifts had ceased. The Pentecostals, then the charismatics, and now the Vineyard, all make the present day use of these sign gifts an important part of their system.
3) Spiritual Warfare ministry -- The Vineyard believes that Christians can be demon possessed, that those demons must be forcefully cast out, and that we are to aggressively attack Satan in order to defeat him.
4) "Power evangelism" vs. "program evangelism" -- Program evangelism is the presentation of the gospel message to a lost sinner. While not anti-program evangelism, the Vineyard believes that it is an anemic way of bringing people to Christ, especially people in the Third World. What is needed is power evangelism, that is, signs and wonders. If, in conjunction with presenting the gospel message, we also heal a person, raise the dead, cast out a demon, or speak a word of knowledge, our message will be with authority and power. The results of power evangelism, we are told, are far superior to program evangelism. It is interesting, however, to examine the Scriptural record of the results of signs and wonders. It would appear that miracles seldom produced any true faith or lasting fruit. Even with Christ, we find people following Him in order to be healed or fed, yet rejecting His message (e.g., John 6).
5) Ecumenical -- Just as with charismatics, it is experience rather than doctrine that draws people to the Vineyard. Therefore, the Vineyard people can apparently work with anyone who claims to be a Christian, no matter what they believe. The Vineyard actively encourages reunification with the Catholic church, and claims that the Pope is an evangelical Christian. We can see why the Promise Keepers, with its strong Vineyard leadership, is so ecumenical and encourages the participation of Roman Catholics, even in leadership positions.
6) Dominionist -- Dominion theology teaches that dominion over every area of life has been restored by the first coming of Christ. It is now the church's obligation to redeem not only individuals, but society as well, in order to usher in the kingdom of God. The Vineyard, following the teachings of George Ladd, believes that "the kingdom is, but not yet." That is, we are now in the kingdom of God. Wimber wrote, "The kingdom of God created the church at Pentecost through the outpouring of the Holy Spirit" (Power Evangelism, p. 34). As a result of this, Christians have "kingdom authority" (note the words to the popular Jack Hayford song "Majesty" with its charismatic teachings in this regard) that enables us to have power over sickness, demons, and nature. What the Vineyard does is to bring the characteristics of the Millennial reign of Christ to this present age. They reason that since we are in the kingdom now, we should manifest all the power that Christ had while on earth. (As Wimber was fond of saying, "I want to do the stuff Jesus did.")
This is the Vineyard's theological foundation for the belief in the validity of the sign gifts for today. The Vineyard also believes that there is yet to come a physical kingdom on earth over which Christ will rule. But they believe that the church will usher in the final aspect of the kingdom as it takes dominion over the earth. Part of this will come in the form of a great last day revival in which the world will turn to Christ. (The Bible teaches that there will be a great apostasy in the last days, not revival.) This is known as the "Latter Rain," and is taught nowhere in the Bible.
7) Eastern world view -- The Vineyard dismisses its critics by declaring that they have been blinded by their two-tier, Western world view. The Western mind-set has an "upper tier" that includes heaven, hell, God, and eternity. Westerners also have a "lower tier" of science, the empirical world of our senses -- those things that we see and experience in the natural, material order. In the Western world view, the Vineyard says there is no interaction between the two tiers. But in the Eastern world view, wrote Wimber, there is another tier -- the middle tier which, "includes the influence of angels and demons on everyday life, the Holy Spirit's intervention in divine healing, signs and wonders, and spiritual gifts. Non-Western world views make room for all kinds of supernatural intervention in everyday life, so the idea that a Christian God can heal is easy for them to accept. But we Western Christians, by excluding this middle zone, usually make little or no room for what in Scripture is normal -- the regular activity of both God and Satan in human life" (Power Evangelism, p. 138). (What we must develop is a Biblical world view. Where the Vineyard errs is failing to distinguish between the Scripture's approach to the supernatural and the superstitious, mystical approach of the Eastern mind-set.)
In the Vineyard system, all problems, including sins, can be traced back to the demonic. The secular, Westerner world view says that all of the above come from natural causes. The Biblical view is that God sovereignly controls all aspects of life. He uses angels, demons, germs, nature, and every other created thing for His purposes. We then must go back to the Scriptures to determine how God would have us handle these issues of life. And what do we find? The epistles, written to church age believers, advocate progressive sanctification, prayer, faith, feeding on the Word, and even the use of medicine for illnesses. But the epistles say virtually nothing about casting out demons (or any other signs and wonders) in order to live for God and to deal with the problems of living.
8) Baptism of the Spirit -- The Vineyard differs somewhat from Pentecostals and charismatics. One of the cardinal doctrines of the other two groups in their belief in the "baptism of the Holy Spirit" subsequent to conversion. They believe that this baptism is a second work of grace that enriches the life of the Christian and prepares him for ministry. The Vineyard, on the other hand, believes that this baptism takes place at the moment of conversion. However, they also teach that there can be multiple fillings of the Spirit after salvation.
9) Tongues-speaking -- The Vineyard also differs with respect to tongues. Although it is practiced by many within the movement, its importance is down-played, and not all Christians are expected, or encouraged, to speak in tongues. On the other hand, some Pentecostals and charismatics believe that speaking in tongues is the evidence of conversion. Others would say that it is something necessary to a fulfilled Christian experience.
- The Vineyard's teachings on the person and work of Christ (Christology) are heretical at best and blasphemous at worst. They teach that though Jesus was fully divine, He set aside His divinity while on earth, and thereby, His miraculous ministry was accomplished solely as a human, but through the power of the Holy Spirit. Therefore, the Vineyard teaches that mortal man today can perform signs and wonders on the same basis Jesus did -- through the Holy Spirit's empowering alone, we can do the same miracles, works and knowledge as Jesus, and more! Peter Wagner, one of the central leaders of the Vineyard, states that, "Jesus exercised no power of and by Himself. We today can expect to do the same or greater things than Jesus did, because we have been given access to the same power source." (Emphasis added.)
4-1 프리메이슨 오랄 로버츠 대학 출신이며 은사주의자인 테드 해가드 NAE ( 미국 복음주의 협회 ) 의장이 되다. 테드 해가드는 WORLD PRAYER CENTER ( 세계 기도 쎈터 )의 회장이기도 하다. 피터 와그너, WORLD PRAYER CENTER에서 주요 사역을 하다.
HAGGARD IS NEW N.A.E. PRESIDENT?Ted Haggard, an Oral Roberts U. grad and a charismatic, was recently named president of the National Association of Evangelicals. He is pastor of New Life Church (largest in Colo.) and president of the World Prayer Center. C. Peter Wagner who taught church growth at Fuller is the “general” who leads Christians in spiritual warfare at the WPC (5/15/99 CC). One NAE speaker, Martin Marty, has been shown by Christian News articles for over 40 years to be a liberal who attacks the Bible, denies the physical resurrection of Christ, and supports abortion and homosexuality (4/02 CC). Other speakers included pro-Catholic Chuck Colson, Bethel College & Seminary president George Brushaber. Christianity Today editor David Neff, and Assemblies of God leader Thomas Trask. Marty also spoke at the 1992 NAE meeting and another liberal, Robert Schuller, is scheduled to speak at next year's NAE meeting. Ralph Colas attended this year's NAE, the Promise Keepers Pastors and Leadership, and NRB meetings. Reports are ready from ACCC (PO Box 5455, Bethlehem, PA 18015) on some of these and are forthcoming, as funds permit, on others. Further information is available from accc@juno.com.
LOS ANGELES - Two of the country's largest ecumenical organizations are considering a realignment that could bring liberal and conservative churches together.
Lines that divide the National Council of Churches and the National Association of Evangelicals already have started to dissolve, and further changes could change the ecumenical landscape.
The realignment would involve the National Council of Churches, which traditionally has included mainline Protestant, African-American and Orthodox groups, and the more conservative National Association of Evangelicals, which represents evangelical and Pentecostal churches.
4-3 피터 와그너와 테드 해가드, WORLD PRAYER CENTER ( 세계 기도 센터 )를 창설하다.
Ted Haggard, New Life Church, World Prayer Center
September 6, 2005 Last Revised February 8, 2006
General Information
Key Words: Ted Haggard, New Life Church, mega church, ecumenism, interfaith, Colorado Springs, C. Peter Wagner, World Prayer Center, prophet, Cindy Jacobs, Rick Joyner, spiritual warfare, territorial spirits, free-market economics.
Ted Haggard founded the World Prayer Center at Colorado Springs with C. Peter Wagner. In my opinion there is an overemphasis on Church Growth, apostolic church structure including the concepts of mentoring or shepherding and prophecy. I am not against prophecy in itself, but see his ministry and others that are similar actively and agressively promoting an undue emphasis on prophecy, accepting and promoting prophecies that do not come true 100% of the time - which is the requirement set by scripture to distinguish true from false prophets. They promote the ideas of collective prayer and Spiritual Warfare and Spiritual Mapping which I see as unscriptural. Pro and con sites are listed so that anyone reading here can inform himself. Looking into what Scripture really says and comparing one’s findings with it would not be a bad idea either. Don’t just accept anyone’s interpretation of it without doing a thorough study of it yourself.
4-4 프리메이슨 빌리 그래햄이 진행하는 에큐메니칼 운동 " 라이트 하우스 운동 "에 피터 와그너의 WORLD PRAYER CENTER ( 세계 기도 센터 )가 참여하다.
LIGHTHOUSE MOVEMENT IS HUGE!?Small prayer groups from over 200,000 local churches and 300 national ministries believe they can reach every person in America with prayer, friendship, and a video depicting Jesus' life by the end of December 2000. Ministries range from Jerry Falwell's, SBC, Moody Church, Ravi Zacharias, and Kay Arthur, to Crystal Cathedral, Willow Creek, and the Episcopal Church (10/4 CT). Mission America's Paul Cedar is chair. Other key organizers were Bill Bright and Billy Graham. The Lighthouse Movement is coordinated by AD2000's Mission America, Harvest Evangelism (Ed Silvoso), and the World Prayer Center (Peter Wagner and Chuck Pierce). This ecumenical coalition predicts 3 million lighthouses by the end of next year. Prayer is much needed today, but any attempt at common doctrine (which is vital?see Amos 3:3?for uniting in corporate prayer and fellowship) would split this conglomeration asunder. Ecumenical coalitions such as this could be laying the groundwork for the "evangelical" wing of the United Religions, the world church of the Antichrist.
4-5 NAE ( 미국 복음주의 협회)와 WORLD PRAYER CENTER ( 세계 기도 센터 )의 주역 테드 해가드는 주로 프리메이슨 종교 지도자들로 구성된 프리메이슨 단체 CNP ( 국가 정책 위원회 )의 일원이다. 문선명도 이 CNP의 멤버이다.
The CNP: manipulating religion to political ends
Many of the religious evangelical groups in America are coordinated top down by a secretive organization called the Committee on National Policy. Former close Bush adviser, Rev. Ted Haggard, was a member of the Committee on National Policy until a sex and drugs scandal forced him out in late 2006.
Haggard was Pastor of the New Life Church in Colorado Springs described as the ‘evangelical Vatican,’ and was head of the National Association of Evangelicals. Ted Haggard was also a member of a highly significant and little understood sect known as Joel’s Army or the Manifest Sons of God, the same circles which spawned Sarah Palin.
Another noteworthy member of the CNP as was Grover Norquist, the man once described as the ‘Field Marshall of the Bush Plan.’
CNP members have also included not only the Rev. Sun Myung Moon Unification Church, definitely a bizarre formation whose founder openly states that he is superior to Christ. The CNP as well reportedly includes the Church of Scientology.2
자료 5 피터 와그너는 에큐메니칼 운동인 AD 2000 MOVEMENT 와 AD 2000 PRAYER TRACK 주도하다.
5-1 피터 와그너는 릭조이너와 마이크 비클( IHOP : 국제 기도 하우스 회장 )와 함께 미국 선지자 학교와 AD 2000 기도 트랙 운동의 주역이다.
The AD2000 Movement
Rick Joyner (endtime restorationist) and Mike Bickle, (one of the "Kansas City Prophets") are featured at this National School of the Prophets conference, as well, and Peter Wagner is the convener of the conference. Peter Wagner is also director of the AD2000 Prayer Track under the AD2000 and Beyond Movement (mentioned above).
The AD 2000 Ecumenical Evangelism Program is receiving unprecedented favorable responses from those who fail to recognize the unscriptural principles upon which any such movement could possibly function. Thus, an ecumenical- evangelical steamroller is being created of unparalleled proportions. In the past, efforts by liberal ecumenical leaders to forge an unscriptural unity on the basis of "peace," "love," "social action," etc., have failed. However, it now appears that this newest tactic of Satan to produce an unscriptural, ecumenical unity through the use of "Evangelism" has a great potential for success unless God's people wake up to what is really happening in the name of Evangelism. This dangerous program should be exposed and rejected by all who truly love Jesus Christ and desire to obey and please Him.
5-3 AD 2000년 기도 운동은 기독교와 다른 종교들의 상호 이해와 에큐메니칼 정신을 고양한다는 취지로 발진되었으며 이것은 뉴에이지 시대의 하나의 종교를 향한 서곡이다.
The objectives of the A.D. 2000 prayer movements advocate the wisdom of man rather than biblical evangelism. A.D. 2000 leaders state that the goal of these marches is to remove obstacles to revival so they can share their faith. However, it seems necessary to inquire what is "their faith" and what they mean by "revival." A revival of human reconciliation and cooperation without reconciliation with God through Jesus Christ? Faith in "reasonable people" who will be able to bring heaven into the world? A revival of peace at the expense of innocent life, of the abolition of the right and responsibility of a government to declare a just war? A revival of ecumenical unity and mutual understanding between Christianity and other religions, which will not offend people by preaching the Gospel? Such a revival can hardly be considered a Christian revival, but is quite in harmony with the New Age/One World Religion agenda of global integration.
If it seems that modern prayer movements are adopting the goals of the New Age, it is certain that they are employing their methods. In 1989, an event celebrated as "Harmonic Convergence" assembled thousands of New Agers at sacred points or ‘energy points’ on the earth to pray and meditate. This occult concept is based upon the premise that large numbers of people acting together in harmony in a given location create a ‘collective consciousness.’ When a sufficient percentage of the world’s population is involved, "critical mass" is achieved, which will then generate enough spiritual power to ultimately cause "planetary transformation" and the dawn of a New Age. World Action for the Millennium (WAM), which is supported by a number of globalist organizations, has even announced the date for such an event to occur:
“The Alpha Course is a wonderful and proven tool for evangelism in the local church... I enthusiastically support and recommend Alpha.” -- Dr. C. Peter Wagner, cited page 2, Alpha News International Online, August-November 1999 (http://www.alpha.org.uk/news/99-08/page2.htm)
자료 7 에큐메니칼 운동과 은사주의 운동 단체 YWAM ( 예수 전도단 )과 같이 하는 피터 와그너
7-1 피터 와그너는 예수 전도단이 주최하는 30일 무슬림 기도 포커스와 30일 힌두 기도 포커스의 레퍼런스 이사로서 활동하였다.
C. Peter Wagner was on the YWAM "Board Of Reference" for the 30 Days Muslim Prayer Focus and for the 30 Days Hindu Prayer Focus. (http://www.ywam.org/prayer/board.html)
1. Spiritual Warfare - A laity-driven attack on spiritual strongholds has been moving through the American church for over 20 years now. Spiritual/prayer warfare is sustained, offensive prayer aimed at repentance, restoration and reformation. The movement has recently matured and become better grounded. Key Leaders: Dr. C. Peter Wagner, Global Harvest Ministries; John Dawson, YWAM; Cindy Jacobs, Generals of Intercession; Francis Frangipane, River of Life. (The Big Picture, David Bradshaw, James A. Rutz, http://www.myideafactory.net/bigpict.html)
7-2 YWAM (예수 전도단)은 로마 카톨릭과 함께하는 에큐메니칼 운동을 적극적으로 전개한다.
YWAM's Ecumenical Error
(Increasing the font size will cause text overlapping with some browsers, such as Firefox)
Around February, 2006, I ran into a group of young people who had just completed a Discipleship Training School (DTS) with Youth With A Mission. They said that they were on a mission working with Roman Catholics at a conference in Brisbane City Hall. Not being able to understand how Protestant missionaries could get into a Catholic conference to evangelise, I questioned them to discover that they were practicing Catholics (not ex-Catholics) fully integrated with YWAM, and merely helping out at the conference. They vigorously defended Mariolatry, the Mass, Tradition and other errors of Roman Catholicism.
These kids had just been processed by a so called Protestant mission organisation. They had joined YWAM as Catholics and after their Discipleship Training School were still Catholics. It was most upsetting to see these kids on the Broad Road yet thinking they were serving our Lord.
I rang YWAM to be told, “Catholics are welcome, and the beauty of it all is that there is no conflict between denominations.” Since when has Roman Catholicism been a Christian denomination? In the following article, YWAM praises the Pope:
See: The Watershed Pope.
The following web site speaks of YWAM’s well established Catholic connection plus other highly unscriptural activities including the creation of 'Messianic Muslims', which I haven’t fully confirm!ed:
See: Youth With A Mission.
Rob Clarke, Leader of YWAM Ireland, is a Catholic. The following article makes this clear:
YWAM has been slipping into apostasy for years. I and many others have tried to help them back to orthodoxy, written letters to their leaders, all without success. It has been made plain to us and others that they have completely bought into every aspect of the New Apostolic Reformation and are now very visible and vocal proponents of the C. Peter Wagner "gospel".
자료 8 뉴에이지 운동과 에큐메니칼 운동하는 복음주의 단체 IHOP ( 국제 기도의 집 )를 지원하는 피터 와그너
8-1 국제 기도 하우스 운동 ( 의장 마이크 비클 )을 지지하는 인사들 : 잭 해이포드, 빌브라이트, 로렌 커닝햄, 존 도우슨, 피터 와그너, 더치 시트
Endorsements
“The Church today needs to be mobilized with continual prayer and fasting to release the harvest of souls waiting to be garnered from among the nations. Mike Bickle’s reliable ministry at his missions base in Kansas City is helping to answer a great need in this hour.”
?Jack W. Hayford, The Church On The Way
“The Great Commission needs to be fueled with fiery, continual prayer with fasting. Our greatest effectiveness in reaching millions of souls will be seen only as our work is bathed in prayer and fasting. Prayer ministries like Mike Bickle’s in Kansas City are important for the completion of the Great Harvest.”
?Bill Bright, Campus Crusade for Christ
“The Great Harvest needs to be supplied by continual prayer and fasting. Intercessory ministries like Mike Bickle’s in Kansas City are vital for the fulfillment of the Great Commission.”
?Loren Cunningham, Youth With A Mission (YWAM)
"Mike, you are helping fulfill a desire of God’s heart for His presence to be enthroned night and day upon a people that love Him. What you are pioneering at the IHOP?KC Missions Base has huge significance for all who labor to reach the nations. May your lamp of worship and prayer continue to shine!"
?John Dawson , Youth With A Mission (YWAM)
“As a lifelong missiologist, I cannot help but think that the landscape of humanity will drastically change when the body of Christ actually becomes a House of Prayer. Mike Bickle has risked it all to convince us of this fact. I heartily recommend this amazing work!”
?C. Peter Wagner, Wagner Leadership Institute
"Spiritual awakening in our nation and world cannot be sustained unless heaven's bowls stay continually filled through worship and intercession. Now, more than ever, we need night and day prayer to make a difference! Thanks to Mike Bickle for helping to lead the charge."
?Dutch Sheets
“Many pastors in the Kansas City area are grateful to God for raising up IHOP?KC in our city. The knowledge that hundreds of intercessors are crying out night and day with fasting for revival in our city strengthens our hearts in the battle. We thank Mike Bickle and the IHOP?KC leaders, and stand with them knowing that their labors are resulting in spiritual blessing and unity in the Church in our city.”
?Howard Cordell and leadership team, Midwest Ministers Fellowship (Network of over 200 pastors and ministries in the Kansas City region)
"I am very impressed with the focus on prayer and holiness as the foundation of world missions that I find with Mike Bickle's missions base in Kansas City. Would that the whole body of Christ had such zeal!"
Bickle's theology and methods have been challenged by many in the church who assert that he is in error in some of his practices and beliefs. Their criticism, warranted or not, focuses mainly on the basis of his theology, his allegorical interpretation of the Song of Songs
Song of songs
Song of Songs is a book of the Hebrew Bible or Old Testament. It may also refer to:In music:*Song of songs , the debut album by David and the Giants... , and the moral failings of some of the prophets that he has promoted, including Bob Jones and Paul Cain
Paul Cain
Paul Cain is a Pentecostal Christian minister involved with both neo-charismatic churches and the Charismatic Movement. As a young man he was one of the Voice of Healing revivalists of the 50s.... .
Criticism has spanned several decades, from contemporary critic Rev. Keith Gibson, director of the Kansas City office of the
Apologetics Resource Center to a Kansas City Pastor, Rev. Ernie Gruen, who authored a report entitled "Documentation of the Aberrant Practices and Teaching of the Kansas City Fellowship (Grace Ministries)" in 1990. It was around this time that Bickle and his church affiliated with John Wimber and the Association of Vineyard Churches (AVC) in part to address the issues raised by his critics. Regarding these issues, Bickle attempted to divert responsibility by saying "We were tempted to say that the attacks were all of the devil. In retrospect, we see that God’s hand in all of this - even using the things that came from Satan’s hand as well. Some of the criticisms were valid (especially concerning our pride) others were not."
Bickle's controversial end-times eschatology has aligned him with Latter Rain thinking, and especially the doctrine that emerged from it known as "Joel's Army." Bickle, in December 2008 was quoted as saying "We're not afraid of the great tribulation, the judgment of God, we're releasing it. We're not victims that are fearful and helpless, we're participants. We're agents in God's hands, loosing through prayers of faith supernatural provisions for the saints and heavenly arsenals striking the power bases - the political and military and economic power bases across the world, the Holy Spirit will release Heavenly arsenal and strike and literally and physically destroy them through the prayers of faith of the unified body of Christ.".
Mike Bickle, director of the International House of Prayer (IHOP) in Kansas City, and a well-known leader in the Prophetic Movement, claims that God is restoring contemplative prayer to the church. He goes on to claim that contemplative prayer is a God ordained means of entering into the fullness of God, and that the brightest lights in church history have been Roman Catholic mystics who lived during the dark ages. He went on to say the western church had much to learn from these mystics.
이상 올린 일부 자료만을 가지고도 신사도 운동은 개혁 교회들을 변혁시켜 그들을 세계적인 에큐메니칼의 구도하에 넣겠다는 의도하에 펼쳐지는 전략적 운동임을 알 수 있습니다. 이 운동은 복음을 전파하려는 운동이 아니라, 종교 개혁을 엎고 통치주의 신학에 의한 새로운 기독교 체제와 종교 체제를 목적으로 벌이는 운동입니다.
- 신사도들은 종교 개혁자들의 교리를 전적으로 무시합니다.
- 오순절 주의자와 같이 하며 오순절 주의 진영에 포진하여 있습니다.
- 번영신학과 궤를 같이 하고 있습니다.
- 순수한 복음주의적 색채로 가장하지만,
결국 프리메이슨들이 벌이는 뉴에이지 운동과 궤를 같이 하고 있습니다.
그들은 우리 교회들에 축사, 내적 치유, 예언, 방언강조, 임파테이션, 열광적 예배와 집회, 초자연적 기적 표적, 기적적 치유, 신비주의, 성경과 교리에 집착하지 않음, 은사주의와 실용주의에 의한 교회 성장등의 풍조를 안겨주고 있습니다. 우리 교회들 구석 구석에 손이 뻗쳐 있음을 쉽게 알 수 있습니다.
부기 : 게시자가 시간적인 여유가 없는 관계로 위 글들을 번역하여 올리지 못함을 죄송스럽게 생각합니다. 여유가 되는대로 번역할 예정입니다.
첫댓글 온통 이것뿐이면 무엇이 진짜인가요 어디까지인가요/