[합격의 법학원] 전문법칙예외에 대한 개관

【도표】전문법칙의 예외에 대한 개관                                   ⇨§40. <A name=#1351320106></A> <TABLE style="BORDER-RIGHT: medium none; BORDER-TOP: medium none; BORDER-LEFT: medium none; BORDER-BOTTOM: medium none; BORDER-COLLAPSE: collapse" height=772 cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width=639 border=1> <TBODY> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.5mm double" vAlign=center width=160 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=5 height=17>  </TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.5mm double" vAlign=center width=281 bgColor=#f7f7f7 height=17> 취지 및 예외인정의 요건</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.5mm double" vAlign=center width=198 bgColor=#f7f7f7 height=17> 문제점</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=160 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=5 height=17> 전문법칙의 선언 (310의2)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=17> ․진술증거(언어적 행동, 사진․Tape 등) ․요증사실과의 관련(요․언․정․탄)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=17> ․직접주의와의 관련 ․적용이 없는 경우와 배제되는 경우</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=160 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=5 height=17> 법원․법관의 면전조서 (311)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=17> ․별도의 요건 없음 ➡ 절대적 ․공판조서 의미</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=17> ․피고인 아닌 자?(공동피고인) ․다른 피고사건?(311설과 315조 3호설)</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=72 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=3 height=31 rowSpan=2> 피의자 신문조서 (312)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=16> 검사 작성 (동조 ①)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․수사절차 규문적 성격, 참여권도 불보장 → 신용성 낮음 ․준사법기관인 검사의 객관의무 고려 ➡ 성립의 진정</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․공동피고인의 피신조서도(↓아래) ․피고인으로 된 피의자 ➡ 특신상태?</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=16> 사경 작성 (동조 ②)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․취지 - 범죄투쟁의 효율성(배) ➡ 내용</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․공동피고인도(↑위의 판례와 모순‼??) ․조사경찰관의 증언도</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=72 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=3 height=31 rowSpan=2> 참고인 등 진술조서</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=16> 검사 작성 (312① 본문)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=31 rowSpan=2> ․수사기관이 피의자 아닌 자의 진술을 기재(§221) ➡ 성립의 진정 ․ ․</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=31 rowSpan=2> ․피고인진술조서(∝ 기소후 수사) ․번복증인진술조서(大全 2000.6.15) ․재전문서류(피고인의 진술이 기재된  참고인진술조서-대판 2000.9.8. 등)</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=16> 사경 작성 (313① 본문)</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=160 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=5 height=21> 진술서 (313)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=21> ➡ 성립의 진정 ․성립의 진정 인정되는 이상 신용성이 높고 필요성 큼!</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=21> ․자필등 확인만 있으면 별도 문제 × ․피의자의 진술서(大全 ‘82-김시훈)</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=160 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=5 height=23> 증거능력에 대한 예외(314)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=23> ․312․313 요건 충족 못한 전문증거라도 보충적으로… ․① 신용성의 정황적 보장 ② 필요성</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=23> ․§312① 단서와의 관계, §312②도? ․立法論(이 규정만 두자‼ - 신양균)</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=72 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=3 height=47 rowSpan=3> 검증조서</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=16> 법관의 (311 1문 후단)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․검증당시 객관적 기재로 정확성 높고, 기술적 성격… ․참여권 보장 ➡ 절대적</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․참여한 자의 진술(현장지시․검증) ․첨부된 사진․도화</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=16> 수사기관의 (312① 후단)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․참여권이 불보장 ➡ 성립의 진정 </TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․참여한 자의 진술(현장지시․검증) ․첨부된 사진․도화</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=16> 실황조사서(規)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․사고현장에 대한 임의수사로서 실황조사서의 증거능력 ➡ (i) 위법설, (ii) §312①설(검증조서에 준…)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․～에 기재된 진술의 증거능력? ․</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=72 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=3 height=66 rowSpan=3> 감정서 (313②)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=16> 법관의 명에</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․§169, 신용성 담보(참여, 선서․제재) ➡ 진술서에 준</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=16> 감정인신문조서</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․§171①④,§48 ➡ 작성주체에 따라 §311～§313</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=88 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=34> 수사기관 위촉</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=34> ․§221, §313②이 작성주체를 구별하고 있지 않아… ➡ (i) §313①설(통), (ii) 증거동의 or §314설(신양균)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=34> ․ ․</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=160 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=5 height=17> 당연히 증거능력 있는 서류 (315)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=17> ․1호 공권적 증명문서 ․2호 업무상 작성된 통상문서 ․3호 기타 특히 신용할 만한 정황에 의하여 작성된 문서</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=17> ․ ․업무용수첩(大全 ‘96) ․다양한 형태의 진술증거 출현으로…</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=33 bgColor=#f2f2f2 height=47 rowSpan=3> 전문 진술 (316)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=127 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=4 height=16> 피고인의 진술 (동조①)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․원진술자가 피고인 자신, 실체해명의 필요 ➡ 신용성의 정황적 보장</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․직접주의 예외설(申) ․수사경찰관․제3자의 증언?</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=127 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=4 height=16> 피고인 아닌 타인의 (동조②)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․본래의 전문증거 ➡ 필요성 + 신용성의 정황적 보장 ․‘피고인 아닌 타인’ = 증인, 공범자, 공동피고인 포함‼</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․필요성(공범자인 공피 - 남흥장사건) ․위장수사관 경우․재전문진술</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=127 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=4 height=16> 피고인의 진술이 피고인 아닌 자의</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․규정 無‼ ➡ (i) §316②유추적용설(통), (ii) 이익 유무에 따라</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․ ․</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=35 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=137 rowSpan=8> 기타 (규정 無 ‼)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=42 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=47 rowSpan=3> 사진</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=83 bgColor=#f2f2f2 height=16> 사본인 사진</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> (i) 최량증거의 법칙상 필요성과 관련성 있으면(李) (ii) §315 3호설(申, 임동규)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․문서의 사본 ․범행에 사용된 흉기의 사진</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=83 bgColor=#f2f2f2 height=16> 진술의 일부인 사진</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> ․검증조서나 감정서와 일체적으로 판단 ➡ §312①의 검증에 준…</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․검증조서 등에 사진이 첨부된 경우 </TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=83 bgColor=#f2f2f2 height=16> 현장사진</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> (i) 비진술증거설 (ii) 진술증거설 - §312①의 검증조서유추설(통)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․범인의 범행상황과 그 전후의 사진 ․증거조사의 방법에 차이(제시 등)</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=42 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=31 rowSpan=2> 녹음 Tape</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=83 bgColor=#f2f2f2 height=16> 진술녹음</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> (i) §313설(자진녹음→진술자의 진술, 제3자→녹음자) (ii) 원진술의 성격에 따라 §311～§313설(多․判)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․비밀녹음(수사기관․사인-통비법§4, 14) ․서명날인 요부, 대판 ‘97-전교조사건</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=83 bgColor=#f2f2f2 height=16> 현장녹음</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> (i) 비진술증거설 (ii) 진술증거설 - §312①의 검증조서에 준…(통)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․증거조사의 방법 ↳ 녹음재생기로 재현 or 검증에 의해</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=42 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=2 height=35 rowSpan=2> 비디오 Tape</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=83 bgColor=#f2f2f2 height=16> 진술녹취</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=16> (i) §313설 (ii) §311～§315설(통)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=16> ․비디오Tape에 대한 검증조서 ↳ 피신조서에 준…(부산신20C파사건)</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=83 bgColor=#f2f2f2 height=20> 현장녹취</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=20> (i) 비진술증거설 (ii) 검증조서유추설(수사기관-§312①, 사인-§313)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=20> ․ ․증거조사방법 - 제시+재생 or 검증</TD></TR> <TR> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=125 bgColor=#f2f2f2 colSpan=3 height=23> 거짓말탐지기검사결과</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.5mm double; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=281 height=23> (i) 인권침해․신용성 결여를 이유로 증․능 부정설 (ii) 피검자의 동의 및 전제요건 충족을 조건(李, 判)</TD> <TD style="BORDER-RIGHT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-TOP: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-LEFT: #000000 0.12mm solid; BORDER-BOTTOM: #000000 0.12mm solid" vAlign=center width=198 height=23> ․진술거부권과의 관계 ․판례 → 정황증거가 될 수 있을 뿐‼</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE> ※ 전문법칙의 적용범위는 ⇒ ① 진술증거, ② 요증사실과의 관계를 이론적 근거와 관련하여 이해하여야‼ ※ §312①,§313 ⇒ 범죄투쟁의 효율성을 위….但, 전문법칙이 형해화 가능성‼(전문증거가 원본증거를 배척하는 결과…) ※ §312① 후단의 특신상태의 의미 ⇒ (① 신용성의 정황적 보장설, ② 절차의 적법성․객관성설, ③ 이원설→실익?) ※ 사진, 녹음․비디오Tape, Polygraph 등 ⇒ ꋎ 진술증거 여부 먼저 검토, ꋏ 진술증거라면 어느 규정 (유추)준용‼ ※ 전제적으로 ꊱ 진술의 임의성(자백→§309, 이외 진술→§317)과, ꊲ 수사절차의 적법성 요건을 구비하여야‼ 2005년 제공~