Abortion in S. Korea: neither illegal nor legal 불법도 합법도 아닌 한국에서의 낙태(落胎) - 2

[정승남세기영어교육연구회장]

Abortion in S. Korea: neither illegal nor legal

불법도 합법도 아닌 한국에서의 낙태(落胎)

2019년 헌법재판소 명령에도 불구하고, 낙태법 개정안은 국회 계류중

Despite 2019 Constitutional Court order, revision of abortion laws remains pending in National Assembly

By Lee Jaeeun

Published : March 7, 2024 - 19:03 The Korea Herald

Image from Abortion Korea

A 33-year-old woman surnamed Kim, living in Seoul, was taken by surprise when she found out she was pregnant late last year.

With no intention of getting married or having a child on her own, she began searching for hospitals that would terminate the pregnancy for her. While searching online, Kim encountered numerous advertisements and blogs listing prices for abortions by vacuum aspiration. The prices varied according to the stage of pregnancy: 600,000 won ($450) before week 7 and 900,000 won before week 10.

She knew that abortion was no longer a crime after the Constitutional Court ruled in 2019 that criminalizing abortion was unconstitutional. But chaos soon engulfed her mind after she learned that it still wasn't legal either.

Legal gray area

With France becoming the first country in the world to guarantee women the freedom to have an abortion in its constitution, the discussion on abortion in South Korea has resurfaced. However, with the status of abortion in South Korea still in a gray area, women like Kim remain legally and ethically insecure.

Korea's decades-old abortion ban, Act 269 of the Criminal Act, was ruled unconstitutional in April 2019. The Constitutional Court mandated that the National Assembly then revise the Criminal Act by Dec. 31, 2020.

However, the revision bills failed to pass before the deadline, technically only nullifying the notion of abortion as a criminal offense on Jan. 1, 2021. Despite 17 proposed bills in the National Assembly to allow safe abortions, discussions have stalled with no progress. Without new laws specifying the way forward, women cannot legally be provided with any abortion services, such as affordable procedures or safe abortion pills.

“It is expected that discussions on abortion in Korea will continue like this without further progress for the time being, since many politicians, including the Yoon Suk Yeol government and the ruling party, egg on anti-feminist sentiments as a strategy to win elections,” said Yoon Kim Ji-young, a philosophy professor at Changwon National University.

During his presidential campaign, Yoon had pledged to abolish the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family, arguing that its officials treat men like “potential sex criminals.” He also claimed feminism was to blame for the country’s low birth rate.

Other factors, such as the claims of conservative religious groups that do not want the legality of abortion to be acknowledged, have made it difficult for abortion rights to be fully granted, Yoon Kim said.

Some say that in Korea, gender inequality is increasing, as there are high rates of physical and digital crimes against women, with the anti-feminist movement largely driven by disgruntled young men anxious about losing ground to women and looking to blame them for it.

Some conservative Christian and Catholic groups oppose the legalization of abortion here.

“Legalizing abortion will cause disregard for life and deepen the problem of the low birth rate as well as destroy family and marital order. Abortion should not be performed except in cases where the fetus threatens the life of the mother,” Moon Ji-ho, vice director of the Seongsan Bioethics Research Institute, a Christian bioethics organization, was quoted in Christian local media outlet The Kukmin Daily, Wednesday.

Access to safe abortions restricted

Normally, residents of Korea can receive various medical procedures that are covered by the National Health Insurance Service at affordable, low prices. The Korean government covers most medical consultations, services and procedures when they are essential. Treatments covered by the NHIS have predefined prices, preventing doctors from altering them.

Since the medical procedures for abortion have not been covered by the national insurance, doctors are free to set prices based on market rates that have no ceiling. There is no official data on the average cost of an abortion, but a 2021 survey by the Korea Women's Development Institute said that half of the interviewees paid over 800,000 won for the procedure.

Other than surgical procedures, other safe ways to terminate pregnancy by taking medication have been gaining interest, but even these are technically not legal in Korea.

Hyundai Pharm, a local pharmaceutical company, requested approval for mifegymiso, the Canadian brand name for mifepristone, from the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety in 2021, but the drug has not yet been cleared. Neither mifepristone nor misoprostol, which work together and are on the World Health Organization's list of essential medicines, have been approved by the ministry either.

Another woman surnamed Ko wrote online that she had decided to obtain the abortion pill through Women on Web, a Canadian nonprofit organization running a global telemedicine service to providing access to safe abortion services and accessible in multiple countries.

However, she realized that she could not access Women on Web’s website since the Korea Communication Standards Commission issued a ruling to block Korea’s access to it in Dec. 2020, claiming that the website facilitates the sale of drugs that lack prescriptions by domestic pharmacists.

Ko wrote that she found out Women on Web had expanded access to their services through websites such as Abortion Korea, so eventually she was able to get the medicine after consultation with its medical team and donating some money.

According to international organization Human Rights Watch, the KCSC having blocked Woman on Web hinders the realization of the right to health information, not just about abortion but about sexual and reproductive health and rights in general.

The WHO's stance on the issue is that "Restricting access to abortion does not reduce the number of abortions. However, it dramatically affects whether abortions attained are safe."

It has also states that medical abortions can be safely managed by patients on their own at home up to the 12th week of pregnancy, when information and support from health care providers are available (including via telemedicine services), without specialized medical care or direct supervision. The WHO recommends the use of mifepristone followed by misoprostol.

21세기 영어교육연구회 / ㈜ 파우스트 칼리지

전 화 : (02)386-4802 / (02)384-3348

이메일 : faustcollege@naver.com / ceta211@naver.com

Blog : http://blog.naver.com/ceta211 21세기 영어교육연구회

Cafe : http://cafe.daum.net/21ceta 21세기 영어교육연구회

Web-site : www.faustcollege.com (주)파우스트 칼리지