<![CDATA[
<p>http://cafe.daum.net/kicha/ANo/20231<br></p><p><br></p><p><br></p><p><br></p><p><span class="b">서울 2기지하철이야 말로 가장 경제적건설을 이룬 지하철 사업</span><span class="bar2">|</span>
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/bbs_list?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo" class="txt_sub">③ 도시/광역철도</a>
<!-- end article_subject -->
</p><div class="article_writer">
<div class="subject">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="hideLayerAll('member'); showSideView(this, '6zkgkSgqXOE0', '',
'\uACE0\uC18D\uCCA0\uB3C4 \uC2DC\uC18D \uCC9C\uD0AC\uB85C'); return
false;" class="txt_point p11">고속철도 시속 천킬로</a>
<span class="p11">조회 1249</span>
<span class="bar2">|</span> <span class="p11 ls0">10.03.04 21:54</span>
<span class="txt_sub url"><a href="http://cafe.daum.net/kicha/ANo/20231" class="copyurl">http://cafe.daum.net/kicha/ANo/20231</a>
<embed class="op" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonmouseover="this.className=''" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonmouseout="this.className='op'" src="http://cafecj.daum-img.net/flash/copyClipboard.swf" flashvars="url=http://cafe.daum.net/kicha/ANo/20231&urlName=글" wmode="transparent" allowscriptaccess="always" pluginspage="http://www.macromedia.com/go/getflashplayer" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" style="vertical-align: middle;" width="22" height="13" allowNetworking='internal' allowScriptAccess='sameDomain'></span>
</div>
</div><!-- end article_writer -->
<xform name="bbsForm" method="get"><style type="text/css">.bbs_contents p{margin:0px;}</style>
<div id="bbs_contents" class="bbs_contents
"><div class="bbs_contents_inbox">
<div id="user_contents" name="user_contents" class="user_contents">
<table class="protectTable"><tbody><tr><td>
<!-- clix_content 이 안에 본문 내용 외에 다른 내용을 절대 넣지 말 것 -->
<xscript type="text/xxjavascript">//<![CDATA[
document.write(removeRestrictTag());
redefineLink();
//]]]]><![CDATA[></xscript> <p> 서울 1기 지하철인 2,3,4호선(1호선은 국철과 직결연결로 동시에 건설했스니
제외하고)에 대해서 당시 시대적 상황에 따라서 최대한 경제적인 측면에서 접근한 건설방식을 추구했다라고 하는데 계산을 해 보면
그것이 타당한 말인지 의문이 갑니다.</p>
<p> 2,3,4호선의 건설비가 킬로당 당시 경상가격으로 200~250억정도라고 합니다.</p>
<p> 그리고 이 노선들의 경우 한강을 모두 지상교량으로 하였고 여타 구간에서도 더러 지상구간이 존재한다는 것을 감안하면
경제건설을 추구한것으로 일단은 느껴지기는 합니다.</p>
<p> 그런데 2기 지하철과 비교할 경우 2기지하철의 건설비는 총 160여킬로연장구간에 약10조원정도 건설비를 들였스니 킬로당
600억이 조금 넘는 수준이 나오는데 문제는 1기와 2기의 건설시차간의 물가변동분을 감안해야 하고 노선의 구조적인 측면을 감안할
경우 1기 지하철이 과연 경제적 건설을 추구했다는 것이 타당한지가 의문시 됩니다.</p>
<p> 2기 지하철은 구조적으로 우선 평균적으로 1기보다 심도가 깊고 한강도 지하로 건너는 경우도 나타납니다.</p>
<p> 그리고 건설한 시차에 따른 물가차이를 고려할 경우 1기가 78~85년이고 2기가 90~2000년이니 대략 12~15년
시차이기는 한데 킬로당 건설비 기준 1기가 200~250억이고 2기가 약 620억 수준이면 대략 2.5~3배차이가 나기는
하지만 건설기간의 시차를 감안할 경우 그동안의 경제성장과 소득향상 여타 물가수준변동을 고려할 경우 결코 2기가 1기보다 비싼
건설비를 들인것이 아니라는 계산이 나옵니다.</p>
<p> 더우기 보다 심도깊은 구조등 고난도한 공법이 들어간 측면을 고려하면 오히려 2기가 더 경제적인 건설을 이루었다라고 보아야
할것입니다.</p>
<p> </p>
<p> 제 생각에 1기 지하철과 2기 지하철의 비용상 특성을 정리한다면 1기 지하철이 경제적 건설을 추구했다라는 것은 그 당시의
기술상황에서 최대한 그런 방향을 지향했다라는 의미일것이며 2기의 경우 일단 1기를 건설하면서 쌓은 노하우 및 기술향상이 밑바탕이
되다 보니 좀더 구조적으로 난공사형태를 띠게 되더라도 이를 보다 저렴하게 감당할수 있는 능력이 향상된 결과라고 봅니다.</p>
<p> </p>
<!-- -->
<!-- end clix_content -->
</td></tr></tbody></table>
<table class="clearTable"><tbody><tr><td> </td></tr></tbody></table>
</div>
</div></div><!-- end bbs_contents -->
<div>
</div>
<!-- 이전 첨부파일 영역 -->
<!-- 이전 첨부파일 영역 end -->
<!-- 새로운 첨부파일 영역 -->
<div id="AttachFileCCL" class="attachFile">
</div>
<div class="cclArea">
<a href="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/kr/" target="_new" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonmouseover="view_ccl(1);" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonmouseout="view_ccl(2);"><img class="icon_ccl01" alt="저작자 표시" src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/img_blank2.gif" width="14" height="14"><img class="icon_ccl02" alt="컨텐츠변경" src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/img_blank2.gif" width="14" height="14"><img class="icon_ccl03" alt="비영리" src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/img_blank2.gif" width="14" height="14"></a>
<div id="cclArea_tooltip" class="cclArea_tooltip" style="display: none;"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/layer_ccl01.gif" id="cclImg" alt="" width="124" height="80"></div>
</div> <!-- end CCL area -->
<div class="comment_scrap" id="comment_wrap"><p class="comment_view">
<span class="comment_cnt" id="comment_cnt">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" id="member_cmt" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="commentViewBtn(this); return false;" class="comment_open txt_point">댓글 14</a>
</span>
<span class="fr">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/bbs_print?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&dataid=20231" target="_cafePrintWin" class="fl">인쇄</a>
<span class="bar2 fl">|</span>
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" id="btnScrapMenu" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick='hideLayerAll("scrap");
showScrapLayerMenu(this.id, "xxjavascript:goScrapCafe(\"cafe306\",
\"3LY\",\"ANo\", \"20231\")", "xxjavascript:goScrapBlog(\"cafe306\",
\"3LY\",\"ANo\", \"20231\")", "xxjavascript:goScrapHanmail(\"cafe306\",
\"3LY\",\"ANo\", \"20231\")"); return false;' class="scrap_close">스크랩(0)</a>
</span>
</p></div>
<!-- 댓글 -->
<div id="commentArea" class="commentBox" style="display: block;">
<iframe src="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20" id="cmtinfo" width="0" frameborder="0" height="0"></iframe>
<xscript type="text/xxjavascript">
// <![CDATA[
CAFEAPP.longtail = {
IS_POLL_BOARD : "",
POLL_URI : false,
POLL_active : "",
IS_BBS_SEARCH_READ : false,
CONTENTVAL : "005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz",
DATAID : "20231",
FOLDER_cmtTexticonyn : "N",
CMTTYPE : "member",
COMMENT_FLOODED : false, //"",
ESPAM : 'uQkojB1pySgJG.rXBwjO9CYmuH5rE8SGqv4rE7BKI-B_-5dkpOssyaUWPJoQOO5dpHwHXFlByU-htv-TlIQSnFOjiIlqtWgT',
CPAGE : ("1" == "") ? 1 : "1",
PAGE_COUNT : ("1" == "") ? 1 : "1",
F_CDEPTH : "0000100000",
L_CDEPTH : "0000E00000",
N_CDEPTH : "0000E00001",
RECENT_MYFLDDATASEQ : 0,
OPENED_SEQ : 0,
COMMENT_STORE : []
};
function delShrtCmtBatch() {
alert(‎"댓글 삭제 권한이 없습니다");
}
// ]]]]><![CDATA[>
</xscript>
<xscript type="text/xxjavascript" src="http://cafecj.daum-img.net/js/59/2009/_longtail.js"></xscript>
<div class="admin_boxT linebg"> </div>
<div id="commentDiv" class="commentDiv bg_sub">
<div id="commentPagingDiv" class="commentPagingDiv">
<input id="cmttype" name="cmttype" value="member" type="hidden">
<!-- 댓글 List -->
<input id="f_cdepth" name="f_cdepth" value="0000100000" type="hidden">
<input id="l_cdepth" name="l_cdepth" value="0000E00000" type="hidden">
<input id="n_cdepth" name="n_cdepth" value="0000E00001" type="hidden">
<div id="_cmt1" class="comment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head1" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span>
<img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/l_level_27.gif" width="13" height="13">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'mTU6B.xJrsE0', '', 'Tanah-Merah
Interchange'); return false;" class="txt_point ">Tanah-Merah In..</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper1" class="comment">
<span id="_cmt_contents1">아무래도 기존선의 전철화, 병행지상건설, 하지만 꼭 필요한 곳은 지하화한
1기 지하철/전철이 등이 일부를 빼고 거의 대부분을 앞뒤 상황 안가리고 지하로 밀어붙인 2기 지하철보다 경제성을 지향한 것은 말할
필요도 없지요.<br>당시의 물가수준 변화에 대해 더 조사해보심이.</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr1" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.05 00:45
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button1" class="txt_btn p11">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="xxjavascript:viewReply(1); return false;" class="p11">답글</a>
</div>
</div>
<div class="dotline line_sub" id="_cmt_line2"> </div>
<div id="_cmt2" class="comment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head2" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span>
<img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/l_level_27.gif" width="13" height="13">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'oZ-KNPic9sk0', '', '5\uD638\uC120
\uACE0\uB355\uC5ED'); return false;" class="txt_point ">5호선 고덕역</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper2" class="comment">
<span id="_cmt_contents2">2기노선은 급행 無, 굴곡 多, 역간거리 短, 고용창출 低 등등...
실패작이라고 봅니다.</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr2" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.05 01:14
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button2" class="txt_btn p11">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="xxjavascript:viewReply(2); return false;" class="p11">답글</a>
</div>
</div>
<div class="dotline line_sub" id="_cmt_line3"> </div>
<div id="_cmt3" class="comment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head3" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span>
<img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/l_level_25.gif" width="13" height="13">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'jmL625ZzAx50', '',
'\uB3C5\uBC14\uC704\uC5ED'); return false;" class="txt_point ">독바위역</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper3" class="comment">
<span id="_cmt_contents3">아닌것 같은데요. 5호선은 대표적 실패작이고, 환승도 제대로 안되교
(신답역) 실패작입니다. 역간거리도 너무 짧고요</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr3" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.05 07:34
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button3" class="txt_btn p11">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="xxjavascript:viewReply(3); return false;" class="p11">답글</a>
</div>
</div>
<div id="_cmt5" class="recomment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head5" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span class="re_icon">
<span class="txt_point">┗</span>
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'p.oL9j9dqzw0', '',
'\uC11C\uC6B8\uC2DC\uBBFC'); return false;" class="txt_point ">서울시민</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper5" class="recomment">
<span id="_cmt_contents5">시내를 기점으로 5호선 서부구간은 그래도 무난하다고 생각되네요.</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr5" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.05 20:32
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button5" class="txt_btn p11">
</div>
</div>
<div id="_cmt6" class="recomment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head6" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span class="re_icon">
<span class="txt_point">┗</span>
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, '24kNgqGI12c0', '', '\uC11C\uC6B8
\uAE09\uD589'); return false;" class="txt_point ">서울 급행</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper6" class="recomment">
<span id="_cmt_contents6">글쎄요. 강서, 양천, 여의도, 강동, 송파쪽에서 5호선 타보시면
실패작이라는 생각이 싹 사라질듯 싶은데요. 2기노선이 존재하는 이유중 하나가 1기노선을 보완하는 역할도 하는 만큼 역간거리 짧고
어느정도 굴곡이 뒤따르는건 당연하긴 합니다. 그리고 신답역과의 환승이 굳이 필요한건지는 모르겠습니다.</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr6" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.05 22:33
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button6" class="txt_btn p11">
</div>
</div>
<div id="_cmt10" class="recomment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head10" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span class="re_icon">
<span class="txt_point">┗</span>
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'OoD5Dux31JU0', '', 'K218
\uAD6C\uB8E1\uC5ED'); return false;" class="txt_point ">K218 구룡역</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper10" class="recomment">
<span id="_cmt_contents10">지금 2·8·9호선만 보고 배부른 소리를 하나 본데요. 5호선은 당시로서는
가장 필요한 노선이었습니다.</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr10" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.06 22:06
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button10" class="txt_btn p11">
</div>
</div>
<div class="dotline line_sub" id="_cmt_line4"> </div>
<div id="_cmt4" class="comment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head4" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span>
<img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/l_level_27.gif" width="13" height="13">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, '6zkgkSgqXOE0', '',
'\uACE0\uC18D\uCCA0\uB3C4 \uC2DC\uC18D \uCC9C\uD0AC\uB85C'); return
false;" class="txt_point ">고속철도 시속 ..</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper4" class="comment">
<span id="_cmt_contents4">일단은 단순히 건설비 수치를 시대적 물가와 재정규모상황에 비례해서 계산해
보니 그렇다라는 결론이죠.</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr4" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.05 08:07
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button4" class="txt_btn p11">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="xxjavascript:viewReply(4); return false;" class="p11">답글</a>
</div>
</div>
<div id="_cmt7" class="recomment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head7" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span class="re_icon">
<span class="txt_point">┗</span>
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'bgajPbbLi8o0', '', '\uBA54\uD2B8\uB85C
3\uD638\uC120'); return false;" class="txt_point ">메트로 3호선</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper7" class="recomment">
<span id="_cmt_contents7">시대에 따라 값이 덜 드는 건설공법도 생각해 보셔야죠,</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr7" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.05 23:45
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button7" class="txt_btn p11">
</div>
</div>
<div class="dotline line_sub" id="_cmt_line8"> </div>
<div id="_cmt8" class="comment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head8" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span>
<img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/l_level_25.gif" width="13" height="13">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'BTh8.kCdzFc0', '',
'\u2606\u91D1\u52DD\u9032\u2606'); return false;" class="txt_point ">☆金勝
進☆</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper8" class="comment">
<span id="_cmt_contents8">7호선이 가장 경제적이였습니다.</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr8" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.06 15:58
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button8" class="txt_btn p11">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="xxjavascript:viewReply(8); return false;" class="p11">답글</a>
</div>
</div>
<div class="dotline line_sub" id="_cmt_line9"> </div>
<div id="_cmt9" class="comment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head9" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span>
<img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/l_level_27.gif" width="13" height="13">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'bgajPbbLi8o0', '', '\uBA54\uD2B8\uB85C
3\uD638\uC120'); return false;" class="txt_point ">메트로 3호선</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper9" class="comment">
<span id="_cmt_contents9">대체 굴곡이 많으면 실패한 노선이라는 개념은 어디서 나오는건지... 수도권
전철을 무슨 GTX마냥 일자로 만드는 것도 아니고..</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr9" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.06 16:20
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button9" class="txt_btn p11">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="xxjavascript:viewReply(9); return false;" class="p11">답글</a>
</div>
</div>
<div class="dotline line_sub" id="_cmt_line11"> </div>
<div id="_cmt11" class="comment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head11" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span>
<img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/l_level_25.gif" width="13" height="13">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'jmL625ZzAx50', '',
'\uB3C5\uBC14\uC704\uC5ED'); return false;" class="txt_point ">독바위역</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper11" class="comment">
<span id="_cmt_contents11">노선의 개형은 성공적이었으나, 정차역 선정이 실패작이었다고 봅니다. 2호선
강북구간과 만나며 이상한 굴곡도 문제죠. </span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr11" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.07 10:41
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button11" class="txt_btn p11">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="xxjavascript:viewReply(11); return false;" class="p11">답글</a>
</div>
</div>
<div id="_cmt12" class="recomment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head12" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span class="re_icon">
<span class="txt_point">┗</span>
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, '24kNgqGI12c0', '', '\uC11C\uC6B8
\uAE09\uD589'); return false;" class="txt_point ">서울 급행</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper12" class="recomment">
<span id="_cmt_contents12">그 구불구불하게 다니는게 위에서도 언급했듯이 1기노선의 보완 및 전철의
사각지대를 연결한다는 점도 있고, 2호선과 만나는건 2호선의 엄청난 과밀을 분산하려는 목적도 컸습니다.</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr12" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.07 10:49
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button12" class="txt_btn p11">
</div>
</div>
<div class="dotline line_sub" id="_cmt_line13"> </div>
<div id="_cmt13" class="comment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head13" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span>
<img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/l_level_27.gif" width="13" height="13">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'eCv.Y5rOQnE0', '', '\uC544\uD0A4\u3002');
return false;" class="txt_point ">아키。</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper13" class="comment">
<span id="_cmt_contents13">5호선이 비록 굴곡도 좀 있고..하긴 하지만, 그래도 5호선은 당시나
지금이나 매우 필요한 노선이지 않은가 싶어요.</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr13" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.07 11:59
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_button13" class="txt_btn p11">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="xxjavascript:viewReply(13); return false;" class="p11">답글</a>
</div>
</div>
<div class="dotline line_sub" id="_cmt_line14"> </div>
<div id="_cmt14" class="comment_pos">
<div id="_cmt_head14" class="id_admin ">
<span class="chk"></span>
<span>
<img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafe_image/cf_img2/bbs2/l_level_25.gif" width="13" height="13">
<a href="http://cafe306.daum.net/_c21_/cafe_nsread?grpid=3LY&mgrpid=&fldid=ANo&contentval=005GJzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz&datanum=20231&page=2&query=%B0%ED%BC%D3%C3%B6%B5%B5%20%BD%C3%BC%D3%20%C3%B5%C5%B3%B7%CE&item=writer&jobcode=3&dataidlist=19362,10202,19358,35750,2865,20242,20237,20236,20231,35689,20143,20136,20131,10190,35616,10188,25021,35559,2827,25008,&fldidlist=ANm,ANn,ANm,ANj,2oGq,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANj,ANo,ANo,ANo,ANn,ANj,ANn,ANl,ANj,2oGq,ANl,&cpage=0&totcnt=636&sorttype=&from=total&listnum=20#" [안내]태그제한으로등록되지않습니다-xxonclick="showSideView(this, 'aesG9ZHmVVE0', '', '\uBC00\uB9AC'); return
false;" class="txt_point ">밀리</a>
</span>
</div>
<div id="_cmt_wrapper14" class="comment">
<span id="_cmt_contents14">이런논리라면 대한민국 어느 전철역이고 합리적이며 경제적으로 건설되었으며
노선도 매우 합리적인 곳은<br>단 한곳도 없다고 봅니다만 -_-..</span>
<span id="_cmt_datestr14" class="txt_sub p11 ls0">
10.03.08 16:26
</span>
</div></div></div></div></div></xform><p></p>
<!-- -->
]]>
카페 게시글
③ 도시/광역철도
Re: 서울 2기지하철이야 말로 가장 경제적건설을 이룬 지하철 사업 by 고속철도 시속 천킬로
다음검색
