PEOPLE FEAR PERSONALITY TRANSPLANTS
Many people believe that when an organ transplant takes place, parts of the donor’s personality
travels with the organ. This is according to new research into people’s opinions of organ donation.
Professor Bruce Hood from the UK’s Bristol University told a neuro-science conference that most
people are strongly against receiving an organ from a killer. His test volunteers said they’d be very
happy to receive an organ from a “good” person. Professor Hood said some of his patients believed
they now had a part of the personality of their organ donors. He said this even included things like
the memories and experiences of the donor. Other research has found that one in three organ
transplant patients believe they have some aspects of their donor's personality.
Britons generally have a very positive attitude to organ donation. However, Professor Hood says his
findings show many people are superstitious about transplants. He said this is natural because even
the most logical people have many kinds of superstitions. He described a British teenager who was
given a heart transplant against her will. She was afraid that she would be "different with someone
else's heart". Professor Hood said: “Most people were repulsed by the thought of receiving a
transplant from a murderer.” He added: “Essentially they believe they will somehow take on the
characteristics of the donor.” Scientists say there is no proof that personality travels with a donated
organ.
STUDENT A’s QUESTIONS (Do not show these to student B)
a) What did you think when you read the headline?
b) What springs to mind when you hear the term ‘organ donation’?
c) Would you be willing to donate your organs after you die?
d) Do you carry an organ donor card?
e) Do you think parts of a donor’s personality is transplanted along with the organ?
f) Would you accept a killer’s heart if you needed a heart transplant?
g) Do you think people should be able to choose the donor if they need a transplant?
h) Do you think it’s possible for memories of the dead donor to be transferred to the new patient?
i) Do you think organ donation is a good thing?
j) What do you think of the idea of a brain transplant?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
STUDENT B’s QUESTIONS (Do not show these to student A)
a) Did you like reading this article?
b) Do people in your country have a positive attitude towards transplants?
c) Do you have any superstitions about transplants?
d) Are you superstitious?
e) What do you think of giving someone a transplant against their will?
f) Would you like a personality transplant?
g) Which person would you like a personality transplant from?
h) What would you worry about if you needed a heart transplant?
i) Would you have a transplanted animal organ if it saved your life?
j) What questions would you like to ask Professor Hood?