Re: Neural circuits regulating visceral pain - 과민성장증후군 복통...

[문형철]

1. nature  
2. communications biology  
3. review articles  
4. article

Neural circuits regulating visceral pain

Download PDF

• Review Article
• Open access
• Published: 13 April 2024

Neural circuits regulating visceral pain

• Xiaoli Chang, 
• Haiyan Zhang & 
• Shaozong Chen 

Communications Biology volume 7, Article number: 457 (2024) Cite this article

•  
•  
•  
•  

Abstract

Visceral hypersensitivity, a common clinical manifestation of irritable bowel syndrome, may contribute to the development of chronic visceral pain, which is a major challenge for both patients and health providers. Neural circuits in the brain encode, store, and transfer pain information across brain regions. In this review, we focus on the anterior cingulate cortex and paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus to highlight the progress in identifying the neural circuits involved in visceral pain. We also discuss several neural circuit mechanisms and emphasize the importance of cross-species, multiangle approaches and the identification of specific neurons in determining the neural circuits that control visceral pain.

초록

과민성 대장 증후군의 일반적인 임상 증상인 

내장 과민증 Visceral hypersensitivity 은 

만성 내장 통증의 발생에 기여할 수 있으며, 

이는 환자와 의료 서비스 제공자 모두에게 큰 도전 과제입니다. 

뇌의 신경 회로는 

통증 정보를 인코딩, 저장 및 뇌 영역 간에 전달합니다. 

이 리뷰에서는 

내장 통증과 관련된 신경 회로를 식별하는 과정의 진전을 강조하기 위해 

시상 하부의 전방 대상피질과 

뇌실 주위핵에 초점을 맞춥니다. 

anterior cingulate cortex and

paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus 

또한, 

여러 가지 신경 회로 메커니즘에 대해 논의하고, 

종간, 다각적 접근 방식과 

내장 통증을 조절하는 신경 회로를 결정하는 특정 뉴런의 식별의 중요성을 강조합니다.

Similar content being viewed by others

Common and distinct neural representations of aversive somatic and visceral stimulation in healthy individuals

Article Open access23 November 2020

The gut–brain axis and pain signalling mechanisms in the gastrointestinal tract

Article 22 November 2024

A neuroimaging biomarker for sustained experimental and clinical pain

Article 04 January 2021

Introduction

Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is the most preval‎ent disorder of brain–gut interactions and manifests with symptoms such as abdominal pain and a change in stool form or frequency1,2. The pathophysiology of visceral pain is incompletely understood, but it is well established that it involves disordered communication between the gut and the brain, leading to motility disturbances, visceral hypersensitivity, and altered central nervous system processing1,3. Pain is a complex experience that includes both sensory and emotional aspects4. Chronic pain interacts and worsens with the negative emotional reactions it causes. On the one hand, the negative emotional response caused by chronic pain can be used as an indicator of the degree of pain; on the other hand, negative emotions can further aggravate the patient’s pain perception, causing a vicious cycle of pain–negative emotion–pain, which affects the treatment and outcome of pain5,6. Interestingly, it has been reported that pain and anxiety processing networks share a subpopulation of lateral septum neurons7.

A growing body of research paired with clinical observations supports a critical role of the brain in the generation and maintenance of IBS symptoms. Regardless of the primary symptom triggers, the brain is ultimately responsible for constructing and generating conscious perceptions of abdominal pain, discomfort, and anxiety based on sensory input from the gut1,2,8. Specific brain functions, such as sensory processing and modulation, emotion regulation, and cognition, are the result of dynamic interactions between distributed brain areas operating in large-scale networks9,10. In recent years, the use of chemogenetic and optogenetic tools in neuroscience research has allowed continuous and reversible manipulation of neuron populations in combination with behavioral measurements, which provides powerful evidence for determining the causal relationship between specific neuronal activities and related behaviors11,12,13. As a result, studies are beginning to reveal the complex neural circuits involved in visceral pain and establish that the threshold and magnitude of pain can be readily modulated by interactions between memory, attention, and affective brain circuitry14,15,16. As researchers have focused on different research subjects individually, in this composite review, we aimed to synthesize our separate views on the neural circuit control of visceral pain into a cohesive picture.

Visceral pain is triggered by central targeted stimuli (neonatal stress and posttraumatic stress disorder) or peripherally targeted stimuli (infection and inflammation)17. In rodent models, neonatal maternal deprivation (NMD) and colonic anaphylaxis evoked by intraperitoneal injection of chicken egg albumin has been employed to investigate the neural circuits related to visceral pain in IBS14,16,18,19,20. The anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus (PVN) are widely connected with the relevant regions involved in ascending pain transmission and the descending pain inhibition modulation system21,22,23,24, making them key regions for transmitting and processing pain perception and emotions25,26. Therefore, we searched PubMed for available information describing issues related to brain circuits in animal models of visceral pain from database establishment to the present. Keywords included “irritable bowel syndrome” or “visceral pain” or “visceral hypersensitivity”, and “neural circuit” or “anterior cingulate cortex” or “paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus”. In this brief review, we focus on these two nuclei and review recent findings on the neural circuits regulating visceral pain in rodents. In addition, we discuss several neural circuit mechanisms that are believed to be the basis for affecting neuronal activities. We further explore the experience of visceral pain in animal studies and propose suggestions for future directions in the field of visceral pain research.

소개

과민성 대장 증후군(IBS)은

가장 널리 알려진 뇌-장 상호작용 장애로,

복통과 대변의 형태나 빈도의 변화와 같은 증상을 나타냅니다1,2.

내장 통증의 병태생리학은 아직 완전히 밝혀지지 않았지만,

장과 뇌 사이의 소통 장애가

운동성 장애,

내장 과민성,

중추신경계 처리의 변화를 유발한다는 것은 잘 알려져 있습니다1,3.

anterior cingulate cortex and paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus 

통증은

감각적 측면과 정서적 측면을 모두 포함하는 복잡한 경험입니다4.

만성 통증은

부정적인 정서적 반응과 상호 작용하고 악화됩니다.

한편으로

만성 통증으로 인한 부정적인 정서적 반응은

통증의 정도를 나타내는 지표로 사용될 수 있습니다.

다른 한편으로,

부정적인 감정은 환자의 통증 인식을 더욱 악화시켜

통증-부정적인 감정-통증의 악순환을 일으켜

통증의 치료와 결과에 영향을 미칩니다5,6.

흥미롭게도

통증과 불안 처리 네트워크는

측두엽 측두엽 신경세포의 하위 집단을 공유한다고 보고되었습니다7.

점점 더 많은 연구와 임상 관찰이

IBS 증상의 발생과 유지에 있어

뇌의 중요한 역할을 뒷받침하고 있습니다.

일차적 증상 유발 요인과 관계없이,

뇌는 궁극적으로 장의 감각적 입력에 기초하여

복통, 불편감, 불안에 대한 의식적 인식을 구성하고 생성하는 역할을 담당합니다1,2,8.

감각 처리 및 조절, 감정 조절, 인지 같은 특정 뇌 기능은

대규모 네트워크에서 작동하는 분산된 뇌 영역 간의 역동적인 상호 작용의 결과입니다9,10.

최근 몇 년 동안 신경과학 연구에서

화학유전자학 및 광유전자학 도구를 사용함으로써

행동 측정과 함께 뉴런 집단을 지속적이고 가역적으로 조작할 수 있게 되었고,

이로 인해 특정 신경 활동과 관련 행동 간의 인과 관계를 결정하는 강력한 증거가 제공되었습니다11,12,13.

그 결과,

내장 통증과 관련된 복잡한 신경 회로를 밝혀내고,

기억, 주의, 정서적 뇌 회로 간의 상호 작용을 통해

통증의 한계점과 크기를 쉽게 조절할 수 있다는 사실이 밝혀지기 시작했습니다14,15,16.

연구자들이 개별적으로 다양한 연구 주제에 집중해 왔기 때문에,

이 종합적인 리뷰에서는 내장 통증의 신경 회로 제어에 대한

개별적인 견해를 종합하여 일관된 그림을 그리는 것을 목표로 삼았습니다.

내장 통증은

중추 표적 자극(신생아 스트레스와 외상 후 스트레스 장애) 또는

말초 표적 자극(감염과 염증)에 의해 유발됩니다17.

설치류 모델에서, 신생아 모체 박탈(NMD)과 닭 알부민을 복강 내 주입하여 유발되는 대장 아나필락시스는 과민성 대장 증후군(IBS)의 내장 통증과 관련된 신경 회로를 조사하는 데 사용되었습니다14,16,18,19,20.

전두엽 피질(ACC)과 시상하부의 뇌실 주위핵(PVN)은

통증 전달의 상승 작용과 통증 억제 조절 시스템의 하강 작용에 관여하는

관련 영역과 광범위하게 연결되어21,22,23,24

통증 지각과 감정을 전달하고 처리하는 핵심 영역이 됩니다25,26.

따라서, 우리는 내장 통증의 동물 모델에서 데이터베이스 구축부터 현재에 이르기까지의 뇌 회로와 관련된 문제를 설명하는 이용 가능한 정보를 찾기 위해 PubMed를 검색했습니다. 키워드에는 “과민성 대장 증후군” 또는 “내장 통증” 또는 “내장 과민성”과 “신경 회로” 또는 “전두엽 피질” 또는 “시상하부의 뇌실 주위핵”이 포함되었습니다.

이 짧은 리뷰에서는

이 두 개의 핵에 초점을 맞추고

설치류에서 내장 통증을 조절하는 신경 회로에 대한 최근의 연구 결과를 검토합니다.

또한,

신경 활동에 영향을 미치는 기초가 되는 것으로 여겨지는

여러 가지 신경 회로 메커니즘에 대해 논의합니다.

동물 연구에서

내장 통증에 대한 경험을 더 탐구하고

내장 통증 연구 분야의 향후 방향에 대한 제안을 제안합니다.

ACC

The ACC is a core brain region that processes the sensory and emotional components of chronic pain in rodents and humans27,28. Functional magnetic resonance imaging studies have revealed that the ACC is activated in patients with IBS29,30. Similarly, animal studies have shown an enhanced response of the ACC to colorectal distension in visceral hypersensitive rats31. Further studies have shown that glutamatergic neurons in the ACC are directly involved in the regulation of visceral sensitivity32,33. The connectivity between the ACC and other brain regions as well as descending projections to the spinal cord establish a top–down corticospinal network involve in pain modulation and the integration of emotion with painful experiences21,34. Afferent sensory neurons carry information toward the dorsal root ganglion and the somatic and visceral nuclei in the dorsal horn. These sensory neurons project directly to the thalamus and indirectly to the ACC via the parabrachial nucleus (PBN) and amygdala35,36,37. Conversely, the ACC can modulate spinal dorsal horn neurons both directly and indirectly via the periaqueductal gray (PAG) and rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM)22,38,39. The ACC has extensive fiber connections with multiple brain regions, such as the amygdala, nucleus tractus solitarius (NTS), insular cortex, locus coeruleus (LC), substantia nigra, and hippocampus38,40,41,42. These complex neural circuit connections provide a fine anatomical basis for the ACC to regulate visceral hypersensitivity in patients with IBS (Fig. 1).

ACC

ACC는

설치류와 인간의 만성 통증의 감각적, 정서적 요소를 처리하는

핵심 뇌 영역입니다27,28.

기능적 자기공명영상 연구에 따르면,

IBS 환자에서 ACC가 활성화된다는 사실이 밝혀졌습니다29,30.

마찬가지로, 동물 연구에 따르면,

내장 과민증 쥐의 대장 팽창에 대한

ACC의 반응이 강화된다는 사실이 밝혀졌습니다31.

추가 연구에 따르면

ACC의 글루타메이트 신경세포가

내장 민감성 조절에 직접 관여한다는 사실이 밝혀졌습니다32,33.

ACC와 다른 뇌 영역 사이의 연결성,

그리고 척수로의 하향성 투영은

통증 조절과 감정-고통 경험의 통합에 관여하는

하향성 피질척수 네트워크를 구축합니다21,34.

top–down corticospinal network

구심성 감각 뉴런은

정보를 등쪽 뿌리 신경절과 등쪽 뿔의 체세포 및 내장 핵으로 전달합니다.

이 감각 신경 세포는

시상(thalamus)에 직접적으로,

그리고 후부뇌교핵(parabrachial nucleus, PBN)과 편도체를 통해

ACC에 간접적으로 연결됩니다35,36,37.

반대로,

ACC는

척수 후부각핵(spinal dorsal horn)의 뉴런을

수질하수질회백질(periaqueductal gray, PAG)과 뇌수질전방중배엽(rostral ventromedial medulla, RVM)을 통해

직접적으로 그리고 간접적으로 조절할 수 있습니다22,38,39.

ACC는

편도, 핵통로솔리타리우스(NTS), 섬피질, 청반(LC), 흑질, 해마 등

여러 뇌 영역과 광범위한 섬유 연결을 가지고 있습니다38,40,41,42.

이러한 복잡한 신경 회로 연결은

IBS 환자의 내장 과민증을 조절하는

ACC의 미세한 해부학적 기초를 제공합니다(그림 1).

Fig. 1: Top-down corticospinal pain and potential neural circuits underlying visceral pain associated with the ACC.

a Afferent sensory neurons carry information toward the dorsal root ganglion followed by the somatic and visceral nuclei in the dorsal horn. These sensory neurons project directly to the thalamus but also indirectly to the ACC via the PBN and amygdala. Conversely, the ACC can modulate spinal dorsal horn neurons both directly and indirectly via the PAG and RVM. In addition, the ACC also has extensive connections with other nuclei and is involved in regulating pain-related sensory and emotional information. The black arrows indicate ascending projections from the dorsal horn to higher brain structures. The red arrows indicate the indirect and direct descending pathways from the ACC to the dorsal horn.

 b The input brain regions connected to the ACC regulate visceral pain in rodents. The ACC receives inputs from BLA, MT, CL, LC, and NTS neurons and integrates pain perception, aversion, depression, attention, and other information to control visceral pain. Each oval represents a brain area. DRG: dorsal root ganglion; PBN parabrachial nucleus; PAG: periaqueductal gray; ACC: anterior cingulate cortex; RVM rostral ventromedial medulla; PFC prefrontal cortex; S1 somatosensory cortex 1; S2 somatosensory cortex 2; BLA basolateral nucleus of the amygdala; MT medial thalamus, CL claustrum; LC: locus coeruleus; NTS nucleus tractus solitarius (The illustration was created by Xiaoli Chang using BioRender.com under a publishing license).

a 구심성 감각 신경세포는 정보를 등쪽 뿌리 신경절로 전달한 다음, 등쪽 각막의 체세포핵과 내장핵으로 전달합니다. 이 감각 신경세포는 시상까지 직접 연결되어 있지만, PBN과 편도를 통해 ACC와도 간접적으로 연결되어 있습니다. 반대로, ACC는 PAG와 RVM을 통해 척추 등쪽 각막의 신경세포를 직접적으로나 간접적으로 조절할 수 있습니다. 또한, ACC는 다른 핵과도 광범위한 연결을 가지고 있으며, 통증과 관련된 감각 및 감정 정보를 조절하는 데 관여합니다. 검은색 화살표는 등쪽 각막에서 상위 뇌 구조로 올라가는 연결을 나타냅니다. 빨간색 화살표는 ACC에서 등쪽 각막으로 내려가는 간접적, 직접적 경로를 나타냅니다.

b ACC에 연결된 입력 뇌 영역은 설치류의 내장 통증을 조절합니다. ACC는 BLA, MT, CL, LC, NTS 뉴런으로부터 입력을 받아 통증 인식, 혐오, 우울, 주의력, 기타 정보를 통합하여 내장 통증을 조절합니다. 각 타원은 뇌 영역을 나타냅니다. DRG: 등쪽근신경절; PBN: 후두부근핵; PAG: 뇌수막하회백질; ACC: 전두엽변연계; RVM: 전뇌수막하중뇌피질; PFC: 전전두엽피질; S1: 체성감각피질1; S2: 체성감각피질2 감각 피질 2; BLA 편측변연핵; MT 내측시상; CL 밀실; LC: 청반; NTS 핵통로솔리타리우스(그림은 Xiaoli Chang이 BioRender.com의 출판 라이선스에 따라 제작한 것입니다).

Full size image

The basolateral nucleus of the amygdala (BLA) projecting to ACC neurons regulates visceral pain

The amygdala has been shown to exhibit altered activation in response to visceral stimulation in patients with IBS43. The BLA, the largest nucleus in the amygdala, is involved in receiving, integrating and encoding pain information and is the center of pain signal processing between the limbic system and the cortical area44,45,46. Many animal experiments have shown that the synaptic activity of BLA glutamatergic neurons is increased in IBS rats and mice47,48.

The anterior part of the BLA has dense, direct and reciprocal connections with areas of the ACC49,50. The induction of synaptic plasticity is favored by the coordinated timing of action potentials across populations of neurons with rising oscillations of different frequencies, recorded as local field potentials (LFPs)51. Considerable evidence suggests that theta rhythms (4-10 Hz) are involved in facilitating the transfer of information between brain regions and in pain perception52,53. Furthermore, human studies have shown that experimentally induced acute and chronic pain perceptions can be influenced by transcranial magnetic theta burst stimulation54,55. Multiple-electrode array recordings indicated a reduction in long-term potentiation (LTP) in BLA-ACC synapses and an impaired phase relationship between ACC spikes and BLA theta oscillations in rats with visceral hypersensitivity evoked by intraperitoneal injection of chicken egg albumin19. Cross-correlation analysis revealed that visceral hypersensitivity led to suppressed synchronization of theta oscillations between the BLA and ACC, suggesting that these regions loosely interact in dynamic information transfer, which may in turn disrupt neural network assemblies and affect synaptic plasticity19.

Notably, although these electrophysiological findings were obtained in rat models with visceral hypersensitivity, they were not directly related to visceral pain behavior, which was a potentially relevant confounding factor. Directly assessing visceral pain-related electrophysiological changes in animals will provide useful evidence in future studies. In addition, inhibition of BLA-ACC inputs elicited aversion in animals with neuropathic pain, while activation of BLA-ACC inputs alleviated this aversion56. The latest literature has shown that neuropathic pain-induced depression triggers hyperactivity in BLA neurons projecting to the ACC and increases functional connectivity between the ACC and BLA, which was necessary for the selective expression‎ of chronic neuropathic pain-induced depression-like behavior. Moreover, repeated activation of the BLA-ACC pathway was sufficient to activate the main neuronal cell types in the ACC and caused animals to gradually develop depression-like phenotypes57. However, in this model, the BLA-ACC pathway was not necessary for mechanical hypersensitivity or persistent pain-like behavior. The regulation of pain by the ACC may depend on brain regions other than the BLA57. We hypothesize that the BLA-ACC pathway may regulate emotional experiences that aggravate visceral pain. However, whether the BLA-ACC pathway is a neural circuit that is specific to or necessary for visceral pain requires additional research.

basolateral nucleus of the amygdala (BLA)  편도체의 배측핵(BLA)은 ACC 뉴런에 연결되어 내장 통증을 조절.

편도체는

과민성 대장 증후군 환자에서

내장 자극에 대한 반응으로 활성화가 변화하는 것으로 나타났습니다43.

편도체에서 가장 큰 핵인 BLA는

통증 정보를 수신, 통합 및 인코딩하는 데 관여하며,

변연계와 대뇌 피질 영역 사이의 통증 신호 처리의 중심입니다44,45,46.

많은 동물 실험에서 IBS 쥐와 생쥐의 BLA 글루타메이트 신경세포의 시냅스 활동이 증가한다는 사실이 밝혀졌습니다47,48.

BLA의 앞부분은

ACC 영역과 밀접하고 직접적이며 상호적인 연결을 가지고 있습니다49,50.

시냅스 가소성의 유도는 다양한 주파수의 진동으로 상승하는 뉴런 집단 전체에 걸친 활동 전위의 협응력 있는 타이밍에 의해 촉진됩니다. 이 현상은 국소 전위(LFP)로 기록됩니다51. 상당한 증거에 따르면 세타 리듬(4-10Hz)은 뇌 영역 간 정보 전달과 통증 지각을 촉진하는 데 관여합니다52,53. 또한, 인간 대상 연구에 따르면, 실험적으로 유발된 급성 및 만성 통증 지각은 경두개 자기 세타파 자극에 의해 영향을 받을 수 있는 것으로 나타났습니다54,55. 복수 전극 배열 기록에 따르면, 닭고기 달걀 알부민을 복강 내 주입하여 유발된 내장 과민증을 가진 쥐의 BLA-ACC 시냅스에서 장기 강화(LTP)가 감소하고 ACC 스파이크와 BLA 세타파 진동 사이의 위상 관계가 손상되는 것으로 나타났습니다19.

교차 상관 분석 결과,

내장 과민증이

BLA와 ACC 사이의 세타 진동 동기화를 억제하는 것으로 나타났습니다.

이는 이 두 영역이 동적 정보 전달 과정에서

느슨하게 상호 작용하여

신경망 집합체를 방해하고

시냅스 가소성에 영향을 미칠 수 있음을 시사합니다19.

특히, 이러한 전기 생리학적 연구 결과는 내장 과민증이 있는 쥐 모델에서 얻어졌지만, 잠재적으로 관련이 있을 수 있는 혼란 요인인 내장 통증 행동과 직접적인 관련이 없었습니다. 동물에서 내장 통증과 관련된 전기 생리학적 변화를 직접 평가하는 것은 향후 연구에서 유용한 증거를 제공할 것입니다. 또한, BLA-ACC 입력의 억제는 신경병성 통증이 있는 동물에게 혐오감을 유발하는 반면, BLA-ACC 입력의 활성화는 이러한 혐오감을 완화합니다56.

최근의 문헌에 따르면,

신경병성 통증으로 인한 우울증은

ACC로 투영되는 BLA 뉴런의 과잉 활동을 유발하고,

만성 신경병성 통증으로 인한 우울증과 유사한 행동의 선택적 표현에 필요한

ACC와 BLA 사이의 기능적 연결성을 증가시킵니다.

또한, BLA-ACC 경로의 반복적인 활성화는

ACC의 주요 신경 세포 유형을 활성화하기에 충분했으며,

동물들이 점차적으로 우울증과 유사한 표현형을 발달하게 했습니다57.

그러나

이 모델에서 BLA-ACC 경로는 기계적 과민증이나 지속적인 통증과 같은 행동에 필요하지 않았습니다.

ACC에 의한 통증 조절은 BLA 이외의 뇌 영역에 의존할 수 있습니다57.

우리는 BLA-ACC 경로가 내장 통증을 악화시키는 정서적 경험을 조절할 수 있다고 가정합니다.

그러나

BLA-ACC 경로가 내장 통증에 특이적이거나 내장 통증에 필요한 신경 회로인지 여부는 추가 연구가 필요합니다.

Claustrum (CL) projection to ACC neurons regulates visceral pain

The CL, an enigmatic brain structure between the insular cortex and the striatum, is reciprocally connected with almost all cortical areas, including the motor, somatosensory, and prefrontal cortices58,59. CL neuronal activation strongly contributed to the discrimination of stressed brains after exposure to acute stressors. Chemogenetic activation of stress-responsive CL excitatory neurons mediates anxiety-related behaviors, whereas silencing of the stress-responsive CL neuronal ensemble partly protects against stress-related behaviors58. Moreover, colorectal distension stimulation induced a dramatic increase in c-Fos expression‎ in the CL and in synaptic transmission in NMD mice, a well-established mouse model of visceral hypersensitivity14. Optogenetic enhancement of CL activity produced visceral pain sensitization, while optogenetic suppression of CL activity attenuated visceral pain sensitization. CFA injection did not alter the excitability or synaptic transmission of CL neurons in mice with CFA-induced somatic pain14. These findings suggest that the CL may be a specific nucleus for regulating visceral pain.

There is a neural circuit relationship between the CL and ACC49,60. Using an integrative approach of viral tracing, optogenetics, chemogenetics and electrophysiology, Xu et al. eval‎uated the role of the CL-ACC neural circuit in visceral pain behavior14. The results showed that inhibition of CL glutamatergic activity inhibited ACC neural activity and visceral hypersensitivity in NMD mice, while activation of CL glutamatergic activity enhanced ACC neural activity and induced visceral pain in control mice. However, optogenetic regulation of CL-ACC glutamatergic neurons did not alter the inflammatory pain response in mice14. Although the ACC receives both somatic and visceral sensory information, the CL may receive visceral pain input, which helps the ACC perceive different information. Determining whether CL GABAergic neurons are activated by colorectal distension stimulation and how the CL identifies visceral pain and somatic pain are key research directions for the future.

Medial thalamus (MT) projection to ACC neurons regulates visceral pain

Microstimulation of the thalamus can evoke visceral pain, such as angina or labor pain, sometimes years after the original episode61. The MT serves as a major relay in the medial pain system and in the conveyance of nociceptive information to the ACC. The MT-ACC circuit has been demonstrated to be involved in pain processing, particularly affective pain perception62,63,64. Meda et al. reported that activation of the MT-ACC exacerbates neuropathic pain-related aversion but has no effect on animals without pain56. Recently, increasing research has shown that activation of the MT and ACC is related to visceral pain in IBS18,65.

IBS can affect the activation of the MT and ACC and induce corresponding synaptic signal transmission. Electrophysiological recording revealed long-lasting potentiation of the LFPs at MT-ACC synapses in rats with visceral hypersensitivity evoked by intraperitoneal injection of chicken egg albumin18 or repetitive distension of the colon and rectum66. Theta burst stimulation in the MT reliably induced LTP in the MT-ACC pathway in normal rats but was occluded in rats with visceral hypersensitivity. Furthermore, repeated tetanization of the MT increased ACC neuronal activity and visceral pain responses in normal rats, mimicking those of rats with visceral hypersensitivity18,66. Cross-correlation analysis revealed that augmented synchronization of the MT-ACC theta-band LFPs was consistent with increased neuronal communication between the two regions66. However, these findings lack direct links to visceral pain perception and emotional behavior.

In addition, acupuncture, a promising nonpharmacological treatment, significantly improved the pain threshold induced by rectal expansion and improved the related clinical symptoms of IBS67,68. Huangan Wu’s team observed that electroacupuncture at the Tianshu and Shangjuxu acupoints alleviated visceral hypersensitivity in rats with IBS induced by neonatal colorectal stimulation through the inhibition of astrocyte activation in the MT and ACC69. However, whether electroacupuncture improves visceral pain by regulating the activity of astrocytes in the MT-ACC pathway has not been determined. Based on the above results, we speculate that the MT-ACC pathway is involved in the regulation of visceral pain, but many questions still need additional detailed research.

LC projection to ACC neurons modulates visceral pain

The LC noradrenergic system is the main source of noradrenaline in the central nervous system and is involved intensively in modulating pain, attention, arousal, learning and memory70,71,72. Acute pain triggers a robust LC stress response, producing spinal cord-mediated endogenous analgesia while promoting aversion, vigilance, and threat detection through ascending efferents71. Activation of LC-spinal cord noradrenergic neurons reduced hind-limb sensitization and induces conditioned place preference72. In contrast, activation of LC-prefrontal cortex noradrenergic neurons exacerbated spontaneous pain, produced aversion and exacerbates anxiety-like behavior72,73. These results have shown that the regulation of pain in different neural regions is not homogeneous.

The ACC is an important brain region for negative emotional memory storage and receives extensive projections from the LC74,75. Aversion and distress can be measured via the two-chamber conditioned place avoidance assay (CPA) or poststimulation ultrasound vocalization recording. Combining colorectal distension with CPA directly reflects the affective component of pain evoked by visceral stimulation and leads to considerable aversion in associative learning and memory76,77. Selective ablation of LC noradrenergic neurons disrupted the formation of visceral noxious aversive memories. Further research has shown that optogenetic activation or silencing of LC neurons projecting to the ACC could enhance or reduce learning and memory formation, respectively, as well as the expression‎ of c-Fos in the LC and ACC, respectively16. These data indicate that norepinephrine derived from the bottom-up LC-to-ACC neuronal pathway is responsible for inducing aversive behavior. Moreover, alterations in LC-ACC connectivity were negatively correlated with depression severity78. The chemogenetic blockade of LC noradrenergic neurons projecting to the ACC completely reversed depressive-like behavior74.

Recent studies have demonstrated that LC-ACC noradrenergic neurons facilitate excitatory synaptic transmission to pyramidal cells in the ACC and enhance itch- and pain-like responses in animals75. Considering the crucial role of the LC in cognitive processes such as learning and memory and arousal79,80, we speculate that ascending projections in the LC-ACC may enhance behavioral responses to injury in animals or humans and alert them to dangerous situations. In addition, the circuit from the LC to the ACC played a crucial role in sustained attention and offspring interactions in mice81,82. In conclusion, LC-ACC noradrenergic neurons may improve visceral pain by regulating multiple behaviors, such as aversion, depression, attention and defense.

Ascending projections from the NTS to the ACC regulate visceral pain

Visceral information is transmitted to the NTS through the bilateral vagus nerves and subsequently relayed to higher brain centers, where it ultimately reaches the limbic system and cognitive brain centers, which are thought to mediate the emotional aspects of pain83,84,85. The caudal two-thirds of the NTS is a major hub for general visceral sensation86. Increasing evidence has demonstrated that noxious gastrointestinal and pancreatic stimuli induce the overexpression‎ of c-Fos in the NTS41,86,87. Our laboratory observed an abnormally elevated theta oscillation in the NTS of IBS rats during colorectal distension. After colorectal distension ended, the central post-response effect was longer (data not published). In rats with chronic pancreatitis induced by trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid, excitatory synaptic transmission within the NTS was potentiated. Inhibiting both the excitatory synaptic transmission and neural activity of NTS neurons alleviated visceral hypersensitivity in chronic pancreatitis rats86.

In chronic pancreatitis rats, some c-Fos-expressing neurons in the NTS projected to the ACC, which provides evidence that the cortical pain center could be directly activated by visceral afferents processed from the NTS. In addition, a larger portion of ascending fibers from the NTS innervated CaMKII-expressing neurons than GAD-67-expressing neurons in the ACC41,86. In summary, the NTS-ACC pathway may be an essential component of the ascending system involved in the transmission of abdominal hyperalgesia in chronic pancreatitis rats. However, whether this neural circuit is necessary for regulating visceral pain needs further study.

Possible mechanismsN-methyl-D-aspartate receptor (NMDAR) and plasticity

NMDAR is a major type of ionotropic glutamate receptor in the central nervous system that plays a fundamental role in both synaptic transmission and plasticity88. In the ACC, NMDAR-dependent LTP plays an important role in injury-triggered cortical excitation and plastic changes. There were significantly more NMDARs, especially the NR2B subtype, and CaMKIIa, a protein kinase critical for neuronal plasticity that is downstream of NMDAR, in the ACC postsynaptic density region in rodents with visceral hypersensitivity than in control rodents14,41,89. NMDARs mediate ACC synaptic responses after the induction of visceral hypersensitivity. The NMDAR antagonist AP5 or the CaMKII inhibitor KN-93 markedly inhibited ACC neuronal firing evoked by 50 mmHg colorectal distension and visceral pain responses in NMD mice14. When an external stimulus or experience activates an NMDAR, it can cause an influx of extracellular Ca2+ through the NMDAR, triggering a cascade of signaling molecules, including CaMKIIa, protein phosphatases, and enzymes that produce diffusible retrograde messengers90. Phosphorylated CaMKII binds to and stabilizes postsynaptic NR2B, mediating visceral pain in rats with visceral hypersensitivity induced by intraperitoneal injection of chicken egg albumin91. Further studies have confirmed that NMDARs are involved in the regulation of the CL-to-ACC circuit in visceral pain14. Taken together, these data suggest that excessive NMDAR subunits and overactive CaMKII in the ACC region are involved not only in the processes of modifying visceral pain and aversive responses to pain but also in the further processing of learning and memory in the chronic pain state.

Myelination and plasticity

Myelination accelerates nerve impulse propagation along the axon, facilitating long-range oscillations and synchronous spike-time arrivals between neurons in different brain regions and promoting plasticity51,92. Recent evidence suggested that myelin formation was impaired in human subjects and animal models of chronic visceral pain93,94. Repeated activation of the BLA-ACC pathway impaired myelination and triggered depressive-like behaviors in naive mice57. After demyelination, the differentiation of oligodendrocyte progenitor cells contributes to effective myelin regeneration, while mature oligodendrocytes may cause inefficient and mistargeted myelin regeneration to a lesser extent95. Chronic visceral hypersensitivity downregulated the MyRF gene, which encodes a transcription factor necessary for the differentiation of immature oligodendrocytes to mature oligodendrocytes, preventing oligodendrocyte maturation and myelination and ultimately resulting in the hypomyelination of the ACC in rats with visceral hypersensitivity evoked by intraperitoneal injection of chicken egg albumin94. Astrocytes promote myelin structure and conduction velocity by directly participating in the proliferation, differentiation and migration of oligodendrocytes93. Previous studies have shown that the development of reactive astrogliosis in rats with chronic visceral hypersensitivity is induced by the intraperitoneal injection of chicken egg albumin94,96. Astrocytic Gq pathway activation in the ACC induced oligodendrocyte progenitor cell proliferation and differentiation and enhanced oligodendrocyte regeneration, maturation, and myelination, which repaired visceral hypersensitivity-induced impairments in ACC–amygdala spike-field synchrony94. However, how these functions are related to specific oligodendrocyte states and how they are influenced by internal and/or external factors (such as peripheral inflammation, the gut microbiota and motility) are unclear.

Astrocytes and plasticity

Astrocytes are considered key cells that combine synaptic activity with energy metabolism and are the main contributors to aerobic glycolysis in the brain. Damage to aerobic glycolysis in astrocytes can lead to impaired synaptic plasticity97,98,99. Astrocytes have fine synaptic-perisynaptic processes that encapsulate synapses in a dynamic manner and form a “tripartite synapse” structure with presynaptic and postsynaptic neurons100,101. Adjacent astrocytes communicate through gap junction channels, delivering energy-supplying substances or neurotransmitters such as lactate to other astrocytes to exert a wider range of effects, effectively creating a distributed energy pool for sharing and delivering energy to active synapses as needed. The ideal location of astrocytes enables them to perceive weak changes in the surrounding environment in response to transiently elevated energy requirements associated with neuronal activation102,103.

Activation of astrocytes in the ACC elicits lactate release, improves decision-making in the physiological state, and rescues impaired decision-making and aversive memory formation and consolidation in rats with chronic visceral pain96. The activation of astrocytes rescues ACC synaptic LTP and repairs impaired spike phase locking in rats with chronic visceral pain96,104. Synaptic plasticity and synchronized brain network activity require additional energy support. Lactate released by astrocytes is used as an energy supply for synaptic activity in neurons to produce and store memory96,105. In addition, lactate can also act as a signaling molecule to affect the expression‎ of synaptic plasticity-related proteins, including pCREB, Erk, c-Fos, Zif268 and BDNF, in cortical neurons104,106. Activation of the norepinephrine β2 receptor, which is widely expressed in astrocytes, promoted glucose uptake and may regulate astrocyte glucose metabolism, such as lactate production or transduction107. In another study, knocking down astrocytic but not neuronal β2ARs in the ACC impaired CPA memory, indicating that β2ARs expressed by ACC astrocytes rather than neurons may be critical effectors of adrenergic-mediated effects on aversive memory formation16. In addition, astrocytes can modulate synaptic activity by the release of gliotransmitters such as glutamate, GABA, adenosine-5’-triphosphate and D-serine, which bind to an array of pre- and post-synaptic neuronal receptors and influence synaptic transmission and plasticity108,109. To learn more about how astrocytes can affect synaptic activity and plasticity through gliotransmission, the reader is referred to some excellent reviews109,110. Gliotransmission was enhanced in reactive astrocytes in chronic pain111. The role of glial transmission in chronic visceral pain in IBS needs further evidence. In conclusion, these data indicate that ACC astrocytes can produce specific effects on surrounding neurons by modulating neuronal activity and that astrocytic signaling in the ACC network is necessary for promoting synaptic plasticity and network communication.

PVN

In the central nervous system, the PVN contains a collection of neurosecretory and nonneurosecretory cells. Neuroendocrine cells include parvocellular and magnocellular neuroendocrine cells; the former type of cells are mainly responsible for the synthesis of corticotrophin-releasing hormone (CRH), and the latter type of cells are responsible for the secretion of vasopressin and oxytocin112,113. CRH neurons within the PVN play a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of visceral hypersensitivity induced by CRD26,114. Hypothalamic CRH neurons are involved in both basal and stress-induced hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal (HPA) axis activation. Exogenous administration of CRH exacerbates gastrointestinal responses in patients with IBS and rats, whereas CRH receptor antagonists reverse these responses115,116. Efferent connections to the spinal dorsal horn directly or indirectly through various relay nuclei in the brainstem, such as the PAG and RVM, provide a potential anatomical substrate for the descending antinociceptive action induced by the PVN24. In addition, PVN neurons are strongly connected to multiple nuclei, including the NTS, PBN, amygdala, bed nucleus of stria terminalis (BNST), nucleus accumbens, lateral sulcus, prefrontal cortex (PFC), arcuate nucleus, ventral tegmental area (VTA), and others15,117,118,119,120, providing an anatomical basis for the important role of the PVN in pain transmission. Recently, Liu et al. proposed that activation of oxytocinergic signaling in the PVN-PFC circuit reduces acute and chronic pain121. However, compared to the research on the regulation of visceral pain in PVN CRH neurons, the results of this study are insufficient. Therefore, in this review, we investigated the role of only PVN CRH neurons and their neural projections in visceral pain (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2: Typical neural circuits involved in visceral pain in rodents.

The PVN receives glutamatergic and GABAergic inputs from the BNST; provides inputs to the LSV and VTA; and integrates pain perception, stress and memory to regulate visceral pain. LC noradrenergic neurons can form complex neural circuits by projecting to multiple brain regions, such as the RVM, BLA, and ACC, to jointly regulate pain perception and emotion and thus play an important role in visceral pain. Insular cortex neurons expressing Fezf2 selectively control motivational vigor and invigorate need-seeking behavior through projections to the brainstem NTS, which may also be involved in the regulation of visceral pain. Each oval represents a brain region, and different line colors represent different projection types. PVN Paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus, BNST Bed nucleus of the stria terminalis, LSV Ventral of lateral septal, VTA Ventral tegmental area, LC Locus coeruleus, RVM Rostral ventromedial medulla, BLA Basolateral nucleus of the amygdala, ACC anterior cingulate cortex, NTS Nucleus tractus solitarius, IC Insular cortex (The illustration was created by Xiaoli Chang using BioRender.com under a publishing license).

Full size image

PVN input to the ventral of lateral septal (LSV) nucleus controls visceral pain

The lateral septal (LS) is implicated as a hub that regulates affective behaviors, such as feeding, reward, anxiety, fear, cognition and memory7,20,122. Recent studies have shown that the LS is also involved in the specific regulation of visceral pain20. Noxious stimulation of the viscera caused visceral pain and enhanced regional cerebral blood flow in the LS in rats123. Notably, visceral rather than somatic stimulation significantly enhanced c-Fos expression‎ and calcium activity in LSV CaMKIIa-positive neurons in NMD mice. Optosilencing of LSV CaMKIIa-positive neurons attenuated colorectal distention-evoked visceral pain in NMD mice, whereas optoactivation of these neurons promoted colorectal distention-evoked visceral pain behaviors in normal animals20.

The LSV receives projections from the PVN and regulates feeding and hypersomnia behaviors15,124,125. Further studies have indicated that the PVN exhibits anterograde projections of CaMKIIa-positive neurons to the LSV regions, which are specifically involved in the regulation of visceral pain induced by NMD20. Inhibition of the PVN-LSV pathway attenuated colorectal distention-evoked visceral pain responses, whereas activation of the PVN-LSV pathway contributed to adaptive colorectal distention-evoked visceral pain responses20. Taken together, these results demonstrate the critical role of CaMKIIa-positive neuronal connections between the PVN and LSV regions in visceral hyperalgesia. Targeting this unique pathway may provide a potentially powerful approach for the clinical treatment of visceral pain in patients with IBS.

The BNST-PVN circuit regulates visceral pain

The BNST, a key part of the extended amygdala, is a gray matter zone located inside the caudate nucleus that contains many subregions and specific nerve cells. The BNST has a significant effect on mood because it is associated with autonomic and neuroendocrine functions126. The BNST regulates physiological responses to stress not only via its own preautonomic projections but also through its direct connections to the PVN127. The neural circuit from the BNST to the hypothalamus region can promote eating and drinking behavior and ensure the maintenance of the body’s internal steady-state environment through connections with the brainstem128.

Accumulating evidence has confirmed that the PVN receives inhibitory neuronal projections from the BNST, especially the anteroventral BNST (avBNST)127,129. In rats with visceral hypersensitivity induced by neonatal colorectal distension or NMD, the excitability of GABA neurons in the avBNST projecting to the PVN was attenuated129,130. Furthermore, destruction of GABAergic avBNST-PVN neurons facilitated the activation of CRH neurons in the PVN and the development of visceral pain129,130, while activation of GABAergic avBNST-PVN neurons inhibited the activation of CRH neurons in the PVN and alleviated visceral pain130. These findings further authenticate the pivotal role of PVN-projecting GABAergic neurons in the avBNST in the modulation of visceral hypersensitivity. There is extensive evidence that glucocorticoid hormones enhance memory consolidation, helping to ensure that emotionally significant events are remembered. avBNST activity alters consolidation via the regulation of glucocorticoid secretion through GABAergic input to the HPA effector region of the PVN131. Decreased activity in this pathway may provide an endogenous mechanism for augmenting HPA output and memory consolidation following an emotionally arousing event.

Notably, glutamatergic neurons in the avBNST also input to PVN CRH neurons15. Recent results have indicated that the balance between excitatory and inhibitory synaptic inputs is altered in mice susceptible to visceral hypersensitivity, resulting in excitation of PVN CRH neurons. Chemogenetic activation of GABAergic neurons or inhibition of glutamatergic neurons in the avBNST-PVN circuit alleviated visceral hypersensitivity15. Interestingly, the study further revealed that inhibition of the ventromedial hypothalamus-PVN/nucleus accumbens-PVN circuit had no effect on visceral hypersensitivity in susceptible mice. Therefore, the unique avBNST-PVN neural circuit helps PVN CRH neurons modulate visceral pain.

Previous work has shown that early traumatic events are associated with lower BNST-PVN connectivity, which may indicate that the BNST has a diminished capacity to constrain the PVN and stressor-evoked HPA responses, perhaps yielding greater stress reactivity132. In addition, clinical diffusion tensor imaging data indicated stronger BNST-hypothalamus structural connectivity in women, which may underlie sex differences in symptoms related to abstinence from alcohol and risk of relapse133. We hypothesize that the BNST-PVN circuit plays a key role in sex differences in visceral pain in diseases such as IBS, but this requires further research. In brief, the avBNST-PVN circuit may play a crucial role in the regulation of visceral pain by participating in pathways related to memory, stress, and pain perception.

PVN input to the VTA regulates visceral pain

The VTA is one of the two main regions involved in dopamine synthesis and release in the central nervous system. It plays an important role in cognitive, emotional, learning and memory, reward and defensive behaviors134,135,136. Recent evidence suggests that the VTA is widely involved in the regulation of chronic pathological pain due to stress137,138. Chronic stress increased the mRNA and protein expression‎ of tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), a marker of dopamine neurons in the VTA139. Colorectal distension stimulation induced dramatic increases in c-Fos expression‎ and dopamine levels in the VTA140.

The VTA receives projections from the PVN that regulate prosocial behaviors and active paternal behaviors15,141,142. Inhibition of CRH in the PVN blocked TH production in the VTA in rats with repeated colorectal distension, but basal TH enzyme levels were not affected140. Dopaminergic neurons in the VTA constitute a major stimulatory pathway in the stress-induced activation of the HPA axis. The VTA was a probable site for synaptic interactions between CRH and dopaminergic neurons143. CRH mediates stress responses induced by colorectal distention in the PVN and activates the mesolimbic dopamine system and CRH-induced dopamine release in the VTA, which further evokes the development of visceral pain.

Possible mechanismsCRH neurons in the PVN and HPA axis

The abnormal bidirectional communication function between the brain and digestive tract is partly caused by the activation of the HPA axis in the neuroendocrine stress system144. Studies have shown that various stimuli can converge on the hypothalamus through the central and peripheral nervous systems, leading to the release of CRH from the PVN to the pituitary portal system, where it acts on the anterior pituitary gland. The pituitary gland releases adrenocorticotropin hormone (ACTH) into the systemic circulation, causing an increase in cortisol release. Under normal physiological conditions, an increase in cortisol can cause negative feedback in the HPA axis145,146,147. This negative feedback mechanism acts on the hypothalamus, pituitary, PVN, and limbic system, inhibiting CRH generation, ultimately closing the HPA axis and restoring the body to homeostasis. As an important neuroendocrine peptide, CRH not only can act on the pituitary gland but can also affect the motility and hormone secretion of the gastrointestinal tract, thereby regulating colon motility and improving visceral sensitivity148,149.

Previous evidence has shown that the expression‎ of PVN c-Fos, pituitary and plasma CRH, ACTH and cortisol increase in rodents with visceral hypersensitivity, indicating that the HPA axis is activated114,150,151,152,153. Additionally, stress-induced activation or enhancement of the CRH and HPA axis systems is associated with visceral hypersensitivity, which is an important feature of IBS. Similarly, patients with IBS exhibit greater reactivity to stress than healthy individuals, as manifested by a dysregulated HPA axis response and enhanced visceral perception and gut motility, among other findings154,155. Various stress stimuli can change the neural activity of the PVN, cause sustained high expression‎ and release of CRH, and disrupt the communication of circuits such as the BNST-PVN, PVN-LS, and PVN-VTA circuits, thus inducing anxiety, depression and visceral hypersensitivity.

CRH neurons in the PVN and neuroinflammation

Mast cells are recruited and degranulate in enteric disease-related visceral hypersensitivity156,157. There is a potential correlation between the activation of abundant mast cells and visceral pain156,158,159. Mast cells, which act as the “first responders” of the immune system, reside close to neurons in the central nervous system. The hypothalamus is rich in mast cells. A recent study revealed that NMD-induced visceral hypersensitivity and PVN mast cell activation occur in adulthood. Injection of cromolyn into the PVN to stabilize mast cells alleviated visceral hypersensitivity in a dose-dependent manner and reversed the mast cell activation induced by NMD160. In addition, mast cell-deficient KitW-sh/W-sh mice exhibited an increased pain threshold, suggesting that mast cells contribute to the development of visceral hypersensitivity160. Stabilization of mast cells by intra-PVN infusion of the mast cell stabilizer cromolyn not only suppressed visceral hypersensitivity induced by NMD and the mast cell degranulator C48/80 and the hyperactivity of CRH neurons but also attenuated the stimulation-induced activation of mast cells and increase in mast cell degranulation products in the PVN160. Taken together, these findings suggest that early-life stress in the form of NMD increases mast cell activation in the PVN and subsequently releases inflammatory mediators involved in CRH-related neuronal sensitization and chronic visceral pain in adulthood. In addition, studies have shown that CRH may also stimulate mast cell activation, leading to sensitization of nerve terminals and increased pain signaling161,162,163. However, further studies will be necessary to explore the mechanism of the interaction between PVN mast cells and CRH neurons in visceral hypersensitivity.

Microglia, immune cells of the central nervous system, play an initiating role in chronic visceral pain114,164,165,166. Studies have confirmed that information transmission and communication between neurons and microglia may regulate pathological pain and visceral pain26,167. Rats with visceral hypersensitivity exhibited significant increases in Iba-1 (a protein marker of microglial activation) immunofluorescence and protein expression‎ in the PVN, which could be prevented by intra-PVN infusion of minocycline, a nxxxxonselective inhibitor of microglia. Moreover, intra-PVN infusion of minocycline prevents colorectal distension-induced pain threshold reduction and CRH protein elevation114. Activated microglia can release many proinflammatory factors or chemokines, such as IL-1β, IL-6, and TNF-α, and promote the activation of PVN CRH neurons. Long-lasting activation of PVN CRH neurons may cause changes in neuronal plasticity, resulting in increased reactivity to pain stimulation26,114. These observations suggest that the activation of CRH neurons and microglia in the PVN is involved in the occurrence and development of visceral hypersensitivity.

Small-conductance Ca2+-activated K+2 (SK2) channels in PVN neurons

The excitability of neurons is regulated by ion channels, and abnormalities in these channels are important mechanisms of pain168. SK2 channels are voltage independent and can regulate the firing frequency of neurons by giving rise to afterhyperpolarization currents (IAHPs) carried by K+. Inhibition of SK2 channels increases neuronal excitability and enhances excitatory synaptic transmission, as indicated by an increased frequency of miniature excitatory postsynaptic currents and action potentials, leading to hyperexcitability and pain hypersensitivity169. Recent research has shown that visceral hypersensitivity is related to the downregulation of SK2 channel proteins as well as the inactivation of SK2 channels in PVN CRH neurons15,170,171. Injecting SK2 channel activators into the PVN can reverse visceral hypersensitivity. Further studies have shown that a decrease in the IAHPs of SK2 channels and the restoration of SK2 expression‎ and function rescue the inhibitory current of CRH neurons in the PVN of susceptible mice, which is crucial for the desensitization of PVN CRH neurons15. There are also many ion channels, such as Nav1.7, Kv1.1, HCN, and TRPV4, that play essential roles in neuropathic pain172,173,174. However, whether these ion channels are involved in the regulation of visceral pain in PVN CRH neurons still needs further study.

Other neural circuits involved in visceral pain

The insular cortex input to the NTS regulates visceral pain

The insular cortex is a highly polar center that integrates visceral autonomous activities and is known as the “visceral brain”. Imaging studies have shown that, compared with controls, patients with IBS exhibit decreased thickness and lower gray matter volume in the insula, which are associated with a longer disease duration and visceral hypersensitivity175,176. The insula is continuously activated during the resting state and during colorectal distension stimulation in patients or rodents with IBS176,177. In rats with chronic pancreatitis induced by trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid and NMD, increased c-Fos expression‎ and potentiated excitatory synaptic transmission within the insular cortex were observed. Specifically, inhibiting the excitability of insular pyramidal cells reduced both abdominal hyperalgesia and pain-related anxiety178,179. These studies have shown that the insular cortex can be targeted for the treatment of visceral pain.

Animal experiments have confirmed that the insular cortex and NTS have bidirectional projections180,181,182. Deng et al. showed that insular cortex neurons expressing Fezf2 selectively control motivational vigor and invigorate need-seeking behavior through projections to the brainstem NTS181. The inhibition or activation of neurons in the insular cortex via the Fezf2-NTS pathway potently suppressed or exacerbated, respectively, motivational vigor without influencing food or fluid consumption or affecting valence processing, indicating that the function of this circuit is remarkably specialized181. Recent research has shown that the insular cortex stores immune-related information. Chemogenetic reactivation of these neuronal ensembles was sufficient to broadly retrieve the inflammatory state under which these neurons were captured183. Furthermore, the insular cortex-NTS neural circuit is an important neural pathway for brain-gut communication. Through this pathway, the projection of the NTS to the insular cortex can transmit the discomfort of the gastrointestinal tract to the central cortex, thus affecting central sensitization; the projection of pyramidal neurons from the insular cortex regulates the activity of neurons in the medullary vagal complex, thereby regulating gastrointestinal function and affecting peripheral pain sensitization. The visceral sensory information and emotional responses transmitted by the NTS converge in the insular cortex, and mutual influence leads to central sensitization to pain regulation in the insular cortex. Oscillation synchronization activity and regulation of the insular cortex-NTS neural circuit have not been reported in visceral pain in IBS animals, which indicates that further research is necessary.

LC input to the RVM mediates visceral pain

The RVM is part of the descending pain modulation system, which exerts ‘top-down’ control on ascending nociceptive transmission and plays an important role in the initiation and maintenance of neuropathic pain184,185. Several studies have shown that the RVM plays a major role in the central processing of visceral pain, such as urinary bladder distention186, pancreatic pain187, colorectal distention and visceral hyperalgesia induced by chemical intracolonic irritants188,189. The number of neurons immunoreactive for the c-Fos protein and NR1 was significantly greater in the RVM in IBS rats than in control rats190,191.

Previous studies have shown a functional connection between the RVM and LC. The RVM and LC neurons were altered in response to stress stimulation or visceral noxious stimulation192,193. Recent studies have shown that LC noradrenergic neurons send monosynaptic projections to the RVM; these projections are predominantly located in the dorsal part of the LC189. Selective activation of the LC-RVM noradrenergic neuron circuit in naive mice instantly induced stress-related psychiatric disorders and subsequent visceral hyperalgesia. In contrast, selective inhibition of LC-RVM noradrenergic neurons attenuated psychological maladaptation and pathological visceral hyperalgesia induced by stress or inflammation without affecting physiological pain189. Research has shown that microinjection of α1 agonists into the RVM increased the nociceptive response, while microinjection of α2 agonists reduced the nociceptive response194. Therefore, the increased activation of α1-adrenoceptors from the LC on RVM neurons might lead to visceral hypersensitivity in mice with visceral pain. In addition, activation of LC noradrenergic neurons that project to the BLA evoked norepinephrine release in the BLA, altered BLA spike firing and condition aversion70, increased anxiety-like behavior70,195 and impaired extinction of fear memories196. Taken together, these findings suggest that LC-related noradrenergic neurons can form complex neural circuits by projecting to multiple brain regions, such as the RVM, BLA, and ACC, to jointly regulate pain perception and emotion and thus play important roles in visceral pain (Fig. 2).

Future research directions

Establishing a reliable and replicable animal model of visceral pain

In comparison to somatic pain, visceral pain can be slightly more difficult to measure and model. The existing animal models have certain drawbacks that limit their application in laboratory research and translational medicine. With the NMD model, there are many variations in separation duration in terms of hours/day and length of protocol across the neonatal period197,198. In addition, the development of NMD models can be costly in terms of animal housing for the duration of the study, which is a major consideration for budgetary resources. Therefore, it is necessary to design, summarize and demonstrate additional ideal animal models and further promote research in this field. In addition, there is currently no objectively recognized standard for eval‎uating visceral pain models. It is also worth noting that when different factors induce visceral pain in animal models, the neural circuits responsible for encoding pain signals may also be inconsistent.

A multi-sex, cross-species scientific study

Studies have shown that women are 1.5–3.0 times more likely to have IBS than men1,199. However, the current experimental results on the neural circuits involved in visceral pain were obtained from male rodents and may not be fully applicable to female rodents. It is possible that female animals were not used in these studies because of the effect of the menstrual cycle and estrogen on visceral pain200,201. It is worth exploring whether the neural circuits we reviewed above exhibit sex differences in the regulation of visceral pain in diseases such as IBS. In addition, whether the knowledge acquired in rodents can be extended to humans is a key question. There are many challenges in breaking down the barriers between preclinical animal researchers and clinical investigators studying human subjects. However, cross-species comparisons must be performed to test this hypothesis.

Identification of specific functional neurons in the neural circuits involved in visceral pain

Usually, different neuronal populations are mixed within the same brain region, but they regulate pain perception and/or emotional aspects of visceral pain by projecting to different downstream targets. Qiufu Ma’s team showed that spinal vesicular glutamate transporter 3 lineage neurons are specifically required to drive affective pain77. However, whether there are specific neurons in the central nervous system that mediate somatic pain or visceral pain and whether there are specific neurons that mediate pain perception and emotion will be interesting topics of future research. The use of single-cell RNA sequencing profiling and projection specificity to catalog neuronal cell types will promote the development of this research. As more types of neurons are identified, in the future, we can conduct parallel studies on each type to determine how different neurons integrate internal and external cues to regulate visceral pain while providing more accurate targets for the treatment of visceral pain.

How complex neural circuits collaborate to control visceral pain

The brain nuclei do not exist in isolation but rather form complex and fine neural networks with each other. Visceral pain is a vast, complicated, and fascinating topic. In addition to the neural circuits involved in visceral pain mentioned in this review, there are many other mysteries about communication between neurons in different brain regions and local microcircuits in nuclei that need to be further elucidated. More importantly, the neural circuits do not work in isolation, and researchers need to further elucidate how complex neural circuits collaborate to control visceral pain. Functional ultrasound imaging may represent an unprecedented opportunity to detect pain and emotional processes in the whole brain in real time while awake and combine these data with in-depth anatomical information on neural circuit mechanisms in animal models202.

Conclusion

In summary, substantial research has been conducted on the neural circuits involved in visceral pain. In this review, we describe the neural circuits that regulate visceral pain to deepen our understanding of visceral pain. With the development of additional high-tech tools and the combined application of various neuroscience technologies, great progress will be made in visceral pain research.

Reporting summary

Further information on research design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this article.

References

1.  
2.  
3.  
4.  
5.  
6.  
7.  
8.  
9.  
10.  
11.  
12.  
13.  
14.  
15.  
16.