Mike Portnoy's top 10 albums

[entropia]

출처 : http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/feature.html/ref=amb_link_39872565_1/026-3753586-6943607?ie=UTF8&docId=1000072213&pf_rd_m=A3P5ROKL5A1OLE&pf_rd_s=center-3&pf_rd_r=14890HJFJ4SFGXF5T75R&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=140129891&pf_rd_i=13831911

THE BEATLES - "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" (1967)
THE WHO - "Tommy" (1969)
DAVID BOWIE - "Ziggy Stardust" (1972)
ELTON JOHN - "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road" (1973)
PINK FLOYD - "The Wall" (1979)
THE BEASTIE BOYS - "Paul's Boutique" (1989)
MR. BUNGLE - "Mr. Bungle" (1991)
JELLYFISH - "Spilt Milk" (1993)
RADIOHEAD - "OK Computer" (1997)
MUSE - "Absolution" (2003)

얼마전에 Amazon에서 인터뷰한..

포트노이의 톱10앨범이라고 합니다..

Rush나 Yes 같은 프로그레시브밴드가 적은것과

Muse나 Radiohead를 좋아하는건 알고있었지만, 그렇다고 톱10까지일줄은.. 의외네요..;;

아래는 본문

Artists' Choice: Mike Portnoy from Dream Theater

Progressive metal legends Dream Theater make their much-anticipated return this year with their new album Systematic Chaos. Systematic Chaos takes rock and metal to epic extremes: The Pantera-esque "The Dark Eternal Night" portrays the battle between a heroic protagonist and a demonic antagonist, while the "The Ministry of Lost Souls" and "In the Presence of Enemies" are reminiscent of Pink Floyd's "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" and Rush's "La Villa Strangiato," respectively. To celebrate the release, we asked drummer Mike Portnoy for his ten favourite albums...

It breaks down into two halves; one is 5 classic albums, and then 5 modern albums.

Going chronologically, the first one would be Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967) by The Beatles. It was released 3 months after I was; I was born in April 67 and the album came out in July 67, so it's a nice landmark for an album that has been around for my entire lifetime. It's an album that broke every rule and created a million new ones, everything from the conceptual zeal to the album artwork, the gatefold sleeve, and the production, everything about it was completely groundbreaking. The Beatles are my number one favourite all time band, so having to pick one single album from them is always rough, it could change from day to day; I could easily of very easily picked Revolver or Abbey Road or Rubber Soul, but it seems like Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band is the one that if you held a gun to my head.

The next one going chronologically is The Who's Tommy (1969). This came out when I was two years old and I was listening to it at two years old, I was a huge music fan from the day I was born. I remember my dad introducing me to Tommy and at first I was more interested in the quirky songs like "Tommy's Holiday Camp" or some of the sound effects on "Smash The Mirror", but as I got older I started to understand how incredibly groundbreaking it was as the first rock opera. And then as I got even older I started to really appreciate Keith Moon and he became my first drum hero. But this album is very much like the soundtrack to my childhood; I saw The Who play Tommy in its entirety in 1989 at the Radio City Music Hall and I had a real emotional response to it; once they kicked in to "Overture" it sent chills down my spine and it was like my childhood being revisited, it was just a weird emotional reaction I had. And then last year I had the chance to actually play the entire Tommy with my The Who tribute band Amazing Journey, it was fun to do the album as a drummer.

Next would be David Bowie's Ziggy Stardust (1972). Once again also a concept album – looking at my list a lot of these albums are concept albums or big epic sprawling records. But anyway, Ziggy Stardust was just one of those albums where every song was an absolute classic; you have the hits like "Ziggy Stardust" and "Suffragette City", everybody knows those songs, but the album opener "Five Years" and the album closer "Rock'n'Roll Suicide", those are totally emotional theatrical songs, and it was crossing theatrics with glam with pop rock, it was a great balance of all those. These songs have been revisited on The Life Aquatic soundtrack with a Portuguese acoustic guitar, and it's a pretty cool listen if you're a fan of this album.

Number four would be Elton John's Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (1973). Like Ziggy Stardust, it's just an incredible collection of pop songs but with a big theatrical overtone to it. Elton John was in his heyday and it was all about glam and bigger presentations, and this is one of those albums where every single track is an absolute perfect song. And like Ziggy Stardust, it's got its handful of hits like "Bennie And The Jets" and "Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting", but it also has a great amount of overlooked classic songs like "Grey Seal" or "The Ballad of Danny Bailey" – those are great overlooked songs. And like Ziggy Stardust it has an incredible opener and an incredible closer. The opener of "Funeral For A Friend/Love Lies Bleeding" is absolutely classic, kind of prog meets pop, and Dream Theater even covered that song in the past. And then it closes with "Harmony", which is this majestic, beautiful track. So, a perfect album.

Pink Floyd, The Wall (1979). Pink Floyd, like The Beatles, are one of my favourite bands of all time, and like The Beatles, it's hard to really pick one, but if you held a gun to my head I think The Wall would be the one just because I'm a sucker for 'more is more' and over the top production and The Wall's surely that – a double album and a concept album, it was just a huge mammoth piece of music, which eventually translated to an incredible film as well. At this point Roger Waters had taken over the band and was running the show, but this album was obviously an extension of his genius; if you listen to the new My Chemcial Romance album you can hear that it's all directly ripping everything off from The Wall, so it is still felt thirty years later.

The next 5 are more modern classic albums for me, and the next being The Beastie Boys, Paul's Boutique (1989), and I think this was an absolutely groundbreaking album for its time, and it took the whole idea of sampling basically as far as it can go; shortly after this album there were lawsuits, and all the laws and copyrights changed in the music industry. But Paul's Boutique is an example of taking that art form as far as it can go, and they were sampling everything from Zeppelin and The Beatles to The Ramones and Public Enemy and everything in between. The production on this album is a sonic onslaught of sounds and beats and loops and samples and a lot of prog or metal purists never really gave rap or hip-hop music its full appreciation but I think this album if you listen to it, there's no denying that it's a sonic masterpiece. Another album from this time that was a huge influence on me was Public Enemy's Fear of a Black Planet, so those two albums were a big influence on me from a production standpoint.

Next will be the first self titled Mr Bungle album (1991). The first time I heard it, it scared the crap out of me, it was like a sonic nightmare; it was like if you took the movie Eraserhead and made an album out of that mood, this is what it would be. It was taking every form of music from metal to ska to punk to prog and put it all together and it was this big hodgepodge of riffs and styles and Mike Patton was the ultimate chameleon to voice it all. And also the production and the collaboration with John Zorn was pretty amazing because he added a whole other element of avant-garde to this album. If Frank Zappa had made a metal album, this is what it would have been.

Next would be Jellyfish and Spilt Milk (1993). When I heard this album it blew my mind because I never realised they had so much quality and talent in the band; my first introduction to Jellyfish was seeing some of the videos from their first album and I just wrote them off as a Saturday afternoon cartoon band, and I never realised they had so much musical substance until I heard this album Spilt Milk, and it blew my mind because it is the ultimate album's album kind of like Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band or The Beach Boys' Pet Sounds or Queen's A Night at the Opera, it was combining all of that incredible sonic ear candy form albums like that, and it also had and incredible amount of 70s retro tributes, touching on Supertramp and 10CC and things like that. To this day I still think it's a sonic masterpiece, and this was their second and last album, they broke up after this and it's a big loss to of only had two albums from this great underrated band.

Next up is an album that is universally hailed as an all time great, Radiohead's OK Computer (1997). I think this is one of those times where, like Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, the hype really does live up to its name; this album is completely groundbreaking and is one of those albums where every single song is an absolute masterpiece. "Paranoid Android" and "Exit Music" as two examples are just absolutely perfect spine-chilling pieces of music; and then of course the hits like "Karma Police" and "No Surprises", "Lucky", I mean those are all incredible songs for the sake of just songwriting. The broke so much ground with this album, and I feel they never really made the follow up to this album, at least what I as a fan always wanted to hear, after this album they got so experimental, went off in the deep end, that they never really followed up this album I hoped they would, more songwriting and guitar-orientated music. But this album is one of the greats of all time.

Last but not least would be Muse's Absolution (2003) album. This album reminds me a lot of OK Computer, it's one of those albums where every song is strong, every song is a little bit of a sonic masterpiece on its own; the production is groundbreaking. This is the album that I kind of wish that Radiohead would of followed up OK Computer with. Muse have obviously now become this huge band, but when I first heard this album I'd never heard of them, no one around me was listening to them, they weren't very popular, very much an underground band. It's got amazing anthems like "Time Is Running Out" and "Hysteria", those are huge songs, but then something like "Song For Absolution" is totally heart-wrenching, perfect songwriting; and something like "Stockholm Syndrome" shows that they are not all about Radiohead and Queen influences, something like "Stockholm Syndrome" could have been a Megadeth song; it's that variety of styles that makes the album so classic for me.

이글을 보고 포트노이가 MP.COM에 바로 이런글을 올렸습니다.

저 톱10 리스트외에 좋아하는 앨범들이라고 합니다..

A follow-up to that Amazon list:
This is indeed my "master top 10 list" if I really needed to narrow it down to just 10.
These are 10 albums that in my book are just PERFECT from start to finish....
It doesn't neccessarily reflect my top 10 bands or artists....just what I consider to be 10 perfect and groundbreaking (and favorite) albums...
 
Of course, there are so many more favorites I could list beyond my top 10:
(and somebody can feel free to post this in the Blabbermouth thread!)
--- Rush - Permanant Waves
--- Yes - Close To The Edge
--- Metallica - Master Of Puppets
--- Iron Maiden - Piece Of Mind
--- Led Zeppelin - Physical Graffiti
--- Marillion - Misplaced Childhood
--- Slayer - Reign In Blood
--- Pantera - Vulgar Display Of Power
--- S.O.D. - Speak English Or Die
--- Alice In Chains - Dirt
--- The Flaming Lips - At War With The Mystics
--- King Crimson - Red
--- Frank Zappa - Joe's Garage
--- Genesis - The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway
 
Really, I can go on all day....so I'm gonna stop now!
MP

참고로

예전 취향은 이랬던 포트노이입니다..

What are Mike's favorite CD's of all time?

---

MP: In no particular order
1. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - The Beatles
2. Abbey Road - The Beatles
3. Tommy - The Who
4. Pet Sounds - The Beach Boys
5. Dark Side of the Moon - Pink Floyd
6. The Wall - Pink Floyd
7. Physical Grafitti - Led Zeppelin
8. Goodbye Yellowbrick Road - Elton John
9. Close to the Edge - Yes
10. Master of Puppets - Metallica
11. Misplaced Childhood - Marillion
12. Permanent Waves - Rush
13. Paul's Botique - Beastie Boys
14. OK Computer - Radiohead
15. Mr. Bungle - Mr. Bungle
16. Jellyfish - Spilt Milk
17. The Light - Spock's Beard
18. Vulgar Disply of Power - Pantera
19. Achtung Baby - U2
20. Ritual de lo Habitual - Jane's Addiction

왠지.. 맨위의 톱10앨범을 보자니..

포트노이도 나이가 들어서 인가... 약간 취향이 변한것같기도..

[멍멍이깡]

8집 나오기 전에도 뮤즈3집이 한번 탑10에 들었었죠. 그리고 발매된 8집을 들었더니 곧바로 뮤즈향이 나길래 적잖이 당황했었습니다-_-;

[생과일쥬스]

포트노이답네요..^^ 그냥 편안히 들을 수 있는 음악을 선정한 것 같네요

[매튜 짱]

라됴헤드의 명작은 역시 오케컴터네요.

[꿈선율]

여전히 포트노이는 너무나도 Radio Head와 Muse를 좋아하는거 같아요. ㅋㅋㅋ

[클라우드]

6집부터인가? 생각했었는데 ... 랴됴를 지금까지도 좋아하네요 ㅋㅋ

[메탈리어카]

최근에와선 뮤즈냄새가 난다하는구석이 많았는데 그때문이로군요!

[iNFinite DREAM]

오케이컴터는 그렇다치고 역시 뮤즈 앱솔루션; ㅋㅋㅋ

[ⓓⓡⓔⓐⓜ]

이번앨범 어떤곡도 뮤즈의냄새가 나던데..스톡홀름신드롬과 아주 비슷한 부분이 있더라구요 ㅋㅋ

[케빈-리]

페트루치나 조단루데스의 톱10앨범 인터뷰는 없나요?

[Anti-Prince]

페트루치꺼는 어디서 본 것 같아요..

[특급]

Elton John~~ 전 사실 엘튼존 듣다 FFF/LLB 커버에 홀려서 DT로 넘어온 팬이라 반갑네요

[￠eriel＊Pain Of Salvation]

뮤즈는.. 아무리 들어도 Showbiz가 최곤데..

[매튜 짱]

뮤즈에는 명곡이 많죠 ㅎㅎ 근육박물관 최고

[꿈선율]

개인적으로 Dark Tranquillity도 좋아했으면 좋겠어요. 포트노이의 압력으로 라브리에가 꾸에엑~! 할지도 모르잖아요! ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[매튜 짱]

오... 주여 ,제발 그것만은 ... ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[entropia]

아놔..ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 상상해버렸어요..

[옥타브]

오~ 엘튼존 중학교때 많이 들었었는데~ 10년이 훨씬 지난 요즘 갑자기 엘튼존이 듣고 싶어 듣고 있는데 포트노이가 좋아하고 있었다니... ㅋㅋ

[Geddy]

앨튼존 "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road" 이 레코드는 아마 앨튼존 최고 명작이 아닐까 합니다 저도 무지 좋아하는거구요...생각해보니 "A Change of Season" 에 담겨있는 메들리중 "Funeral For A Friend" 이 곡이 "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road" 에 들어있죠~