트로트와 엔카에 대하여....

<p style="text-align: left;">어제<br>전자바이올리스트 조아람의 <br>오사카시구레를 들어보니...<br>한국의 트로트와 너무<br>분위기가 비슷해서<br>관련된 자료를 찾아 봤습니다.<br><br>물론<br>옮긴 내용이 <br>특정 개인의 의견이기도 해서<br>적확하다고....<br>말할 수 있을지는?<br>모르겠습니다.<br><br>어떤 글이든<br>판단은 본인 몫입니다.<br><br>제 개인적인 견해는....<br>사람들 사는 기본적인 틀이나<br>인간 본연의 고유 감성은 <br>서로 간에 영향을 주기도하고<br>받기도 하기 때문에....<br><br>정통성<br>원조<br>이런 단어를 두고....<br>100퍼센트 한쪽으로 치우친<br>주장은 있을 수 없다....입니다.<br><br>김연자 등<br>한국의 트로트 가수가<br>일본으로 진출하여<br>많은 성과를 거두었다는....<br>사실을 기억해보면....<br>우리의 정서가<br>일본인들의 감성과<br>크게 다르지 않다는 것입니다.<br><br>한국과 일본은 <br>아주 오래 전 부터<br>많은 영향을 서로 주고 받았기 때문에...<br><br>정서적으로도 비슷한 면이<br>분명 많이 존재한다.는 생각입니다.<br><br>그래서<br>엔카와 트로트는<br>어느 장르가....<br>원조이냐?<br>아류냐?<br>이런 논쟁은....<br>계란이 먼저냐?<br>닭이 먼저냐?<br>식의 소모적인 논쟁이....<br>아닐까? 싶습니다.<br><br> </p><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/ce2b4dae22a199fa260743c8cac0c0093e9c3dd8" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/ce2b4dae22a199fa260743c8cac0c0093e9c3dd8" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1700"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/0c27a05b896ec441be4a5ba6bb26f2043c8c54d0" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/0c27a05b896ec441be4a5ba6bb26f2043c8c54d0" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1591"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/163b8c67b6b87d9dade59035daa6b37662ed537a" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/163b8c67b6b87d9dade59035daa6b37662ed537a" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1561"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/f2a6207154fcc727dda12ec30f8cbd0851ab1cb7" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/f2a6207154fcc727dda12ec30f8cbd0851ab1cb7" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="865"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/feb6bbc5848fedc5be28777cb17b5fefe1fda83f" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/feb6bbc5848fedc5be28777cb17b5fefe1fda83f" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1439"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/87a369cd6e3ba68a87ce37c247930267bbacfb48" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/87a369cd6e3ba68a87ce37c247930267bbacfb48" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1364"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/e148c420e307450d9e668227246edcb514f12969" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/e148c420e307450d9e668227246edcb514f12969" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1779"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/3eb33b9a8d217ae172e5688e7eddde527233c0d7" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/3eb33b9a8d217ae172e5688e7eddde527233c0d7" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1680"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/f2dacd158c224aa868e251fb155502c3dd9e6dba" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/f2dacd158c224aa868e251fb155502c3dd9e6dba" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1837"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/1bd06b8a2b43b51ce1facd96c5fe010dc4db6293" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/1bd06b8a2b43b51ce1facd96c5fe010dc4db6293" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1729"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/2d2ac98abe1d56f7e8e73d73413bebdfe07ff96c" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/2d2ac98abe1d56f7e8e73d73413bebdfe07ff96c" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1866"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/c200047c5c5213e57c3f6e379755a0f91b534693" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/c200047c5c5213e57c3f6e379755a0f91b534693" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1760"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/d9b772887457854b3932509bad7a24fd40b43b35" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/d9b772887457854b3932509bad7a24fd40b43b35" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1772"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/3f161d44c9716268c3a0e8ae450c3b7f139c4e6f" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/3f161d44c9716268c3a0e8ae450c3b7f139c4e6f" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1713"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/298bfe52c78414c1d91854069d32468f47e1e936" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/298bfe52c78414c1d91854069d32468f47e1e936" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1151"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/b20e934019407c9f9c717f07eb886c0b5ef94d91" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/b20e934019407c9f9c717f07eb886c0b5ef94d91" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="551"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/b4ac3a3c6ba1a26f55149861552314b7423efae4" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/b4ac3a3c6ba1a26f55149861552314b7423efae4" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1229"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/238e836b7afdd3277df23da5d59af919e010441c" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/238e836b7afdd3277df23da5d59af919e010441c" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1397"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/26426768675ef58f2989f0f1b38c3eef3a7f9d13" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/26426768675ef58f2989f0f1b38c3eef3a7f9d13" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="368"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/e86a0cfeb4ee060e795756827be124dc2803d92b" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/e86a0cfeb4ee060e795756827be124dc2803d92b" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1491"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/6f35fc28800af42bac3c91476caa0442f92b9687" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/6f35fc28800af42bac3c91476caa0442f92b9687" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1437"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/cdd72ff60706631e6edc0528f21112de2dfdd14f" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/cdd72ff60706631e6edc0528f21112de2dfdd14f" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1814"></div><div class="figure-img" data-ke-type="image" data-ke-style="alignCenter" data-ke-mobilestyle="widthOrigin"><img src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/b8f16b840ad37cc78471503fb0e58449ba4f0f27" class="txc-image" data-img-src="https://t1.daumcdn.net/cafeattach/1ZIjD/b8f16b840ad37cc78471503fb0e58449ba4f0f27" data-origin-width="1080" data-origin-height="1866"></div><p style="text-align: left;"></p>