|
MONTREAL
- A group of Canadian clinicians say they think the incidence of
postpartum depression could be reduced by a simple remedy - sleep.
A
few years ago, Dr. Meir Steiner noticed that mothers who had previously
battled the mood disorder were telling him they feared another bout due
to the fatigue they were experiencing during their subsequent pregnancy.
The
Ontario doctor already knew that fatigue is practically universal among
women in the first days after giving birth. Since sleep is also known
to play a role in mood disorders, he had a eureka moment.
"What
these women were describing was jet lag. We called them the jet-lagged
moms," said the founding director of the Women's Health Concerns Clinic
in Hamilton, Ont.
They were exhausted even before labour because they were nervous, uncomfortable and rarely slept through the night.
"The
whole system - particularly the hormonal system - is totally
desynchronized," Steiner said. "(The mother) needs to resynchronize.
Her rhythms are all off."
He thought it might help if he could reset her circadian clock.
"The idea is to try and prevent sleep deprivation, which seems to be the biggest enemy for those at risk," Steiner said.
With
the help of his colleagues, Steiner launched an informal program that
allowed women at high risk for postpartum depression - those with
personal or family history of depression or who showed symptoms during
pregnancy - to stay in the hospital for up to five days after giving
birth.
They were given a private hospital room at no extra cost
and the infant was kept in the nursery overnight. Women who choose to
breastfeed were encouraged to pump milk or use formula for nighttime
feedings or ask to be woken only when necessary to feed.
Steiner also encouraged new mothers to continue the restful regimen at home as much as possible.
"The feedback was overwhelming," Steiner said, adding while he knew it was working, he needed statistics to back up his theory.
In
2005, his team applied for a study grant from the Ontario Mental Health
Foundation to begin gathering empirical evidence. The program has since
been picked up by six other hospitals in Ontario.
Canadian statistics show 10 to 20 per cent of women experience postpartum depression.
The
sense of malaise will generally hit within two weeks to six months
after birth. Symptoms include excessive crying, feelings of guilt and
inadequacy, anorexia, insomnia and social withdrawal.
Children
of mothers with untreated postpartum depression are also more likely to
suffer from behavioural problems and their emotional and social
development is thought to be delayed.
Recent studies are lending credence to Steiner's theory that there's a link between sleep and postpartum depression.
Research
published in the journal "Sleep" suggests the babies of women who
suffered from depression during and after pregnancy also had disturbed
sleep patterns.
Another study published in the "Journal of
Obstetric, Gynecologic and Neonatal Nursing" links the quality of a
mother's sleep to postpartum depression.
Still, critics have
some concerns with Steiner's work. Among the most serious are fears the
baby won't bond if the mother is absent during the night.
According
to national guidelines set by Canada's public health service, mothers
and infants are to be cared for as a unit and should not be separated
unless absolutely necessary.
It's a concern Steiner brushes off.
"Nothing will happen," he said, adding mothers in his program have actually had better results when it came to breastfeeding.
Ariel
Dalfen, a staff psychologist at Mount Sinai Hospital in Toronto which
has participated in the study for several years, agrees.
"It's not like the woman's never with the baby," she said. "It's a few hours of crucial sleep."
Proponents of the program say cost is the bigger hurdle.
Dalfen admits she's being pushed by hospital administrators to cut or scale back the project because of the price tag.
"We're justifying it by the medical outcome," she said. "It's like a small investment in the mom's well-being."
Steiner argues it'll actually save money in the long run.
"It
will probably cost the system more if we didn't do that and we have
women who then need to be treated for postpartum depression," he said.
"What does it do to the baby when the mom is depressed for four to six months? You weigh the costs and benefits."
According
to the Canadian Institute for Health Information, the average cost for
a single day of inpatient care at a Canadian hospital is $951.
Pregnancy and childbirth account for the highest volume of stays but
represent just five per cent of the total cost for inpatient care.