Re:Reactive Sulfur Species 2020

[문형철]

Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol

. 2020 Mar 5;40(4):874–884. doi: 10.1161/ATVBAHA.120.314084

Reactive Sulfur Species

A New Redox Player in Cardiovascular Pathophysiology

Gopi K Kolluru 1, Xinggui Shen 1, Christopher G Kevil 1,✉

• Author information
• Article notes
• Copyright and License information

PMCID: PMC7098439  PMID: 32131614

Abstract

Hydrogen sulfide has emerged as an important gaseous signaling molecule and a regulator of critical biological processes. However, the physiological significance of hydrogen sulfide metabolites such as persulfides, polysulfides, and other reactive sulfur species (RSS) has only recently been appreciated. Emerging evidence suggests that these RSS molecules may have similar or divergent regulatory roles compared with hydrogen sulfide in various biological activities. However, the chemical nature of persulfides and polysulfides is complex and remains poorly understood within cardiovascular and other pathophysiological conditions. Recent reports suggest that RSS can be produced endogenously, with different forms having unique chemical properties and biological implications involving diverse cellular responses such as protein biosynthesis, cell-cell barrier functions, and mitochondrial bioenergetics.

Enzymes of the transsulfuration pathway, CBS (cystathionine beta-synthase) and CSE (cystathionine gamma-lyase), may also produce RSS metabolites besides hydrogen sulfide. Moreover, CARSs (cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase) are also able to generate protein persulfides via cysteine persulfide (CysSSH) incorporation into nascently formed polypeptides suggesting a new biologically relevant amino acid. This brief review discusses the biochemical nature and potential roles of RSS, associated oxidative stress redox signaling, and future research opportunities in cardiovascular disease.

초록

황화수소는 

중요한 기체 신호 전달 분자이자 

중요한 생물학적 과정의 조절자로 부상했습니다.

 그러나, 

과황화수소, 폴리황화수소, 기타 반응성 황화합물(RSS)과 같은 

황화수소 대사 산물의 생리학적 중요성은 

최근에야 인식되기 시작했습니다. 

persulfides, polysulfides, and other reactive sulfur species (RSS)

최근의 증거에 따르면, 

이러한 RSS 분자는 

다양한 생물학적 활동에서 황화수소와 유사한 또는 다른 조절 역할을 할 수 있다고 합니다. 

그러나, 

과황화물과 폴리황화물의 화학적 특성은 복잡하며, 

심혈관 및 기타 병리 생리학적 조건에서 제대로 이해되지 않고 있습니다. 

최근의 연구에 따르면, 

RSS는 내생적으로 생성될 수 있으며, 

다양한 형태가 독특한 화학적 특성을 지니고, 

단백질 생합성, 세포 간 장벽 기능, 미토콘드리아 생체 에너지와 같은 

다양한 세포 반응을 수반하는 생물학적 영향을 미칩니다. 

트랜스설퍼레이션 경로의 효소인 

CBS(시스타티오닌 베타-신타제)와 CSE(시스타티오닌 감마-리아제)도 

황화수소 외에 RSS 대사 산물을 생성할 수 있습니다. 

Enzymes of the transsulfuration pathway, CBS (cystathionine beta-synthase) and CSE (cystathionine gamma-lyase), may also produce RSS metabolites besides hydrogen sulfide

또한, 

CARS(cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase)는 

새로 형성된 폴리펩티드에 시스테인 퍼설파이드(CysSSH)를 통합하여 

생물학적으로 관련된 새로운 아미노산을 생성할 수 있습니다. 

이 짧은 리뷰에서는 

RSS의 생화학적인 특성과 잠재적인 역할, 관련 산화 스트레스 레독스 신호, 

그리고 심혈관 질환에 대한 향후 연구 기회를 논의합니다.

Keywords: cardiovascular diseases, gases, ischemia, sulfur, vascular remodeling

---

Highlights.

•  
•  
•  
•  

Nearly 2 decades later, hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is now established as a crucial signaling molecule and a key regulator of biological functions. While much has been revealed regarding the importance of H2S, its molecular signaling, synthesis, and metabolism pathways are still much unclear.1–5 As a byproduct of the transsulfuration pathway, H2S is known for its pathophysiological roles in various tissues and organs, including the regulation of neuronal and vascular systems, cardioprotection, protection from ischemic insult and wound repair, and insulin release. However, the chemical nature of H2S is purported to translate to many biological and biochemical associations reported in the literature. It is likely an oversimplification to conclude that this single molecule in its primary biochemical state alone mediates all the reported signaling and biological effects. Thus, it is prudent to consider the hypothesis that the presence of other chemical intermediates or derivatives of sulfide may mediate many biological functions. Indeed, it is now appreciated that a wide range of sulfide metabolites may be produced via the transsulfuration enzymes CBS (cystathionine beta-synthase) and CSE (cystathionine gamma-lyase) besides H2S. These metabolites including persulfides (RSSH), polysulfides (RSS(n)H), and other oxidized sulfide species represent a group of reactive molecules called reactive sulfur species (RSS) and have been identified as signaling agents themselves associated with many biological activities.6 Therefore, H2S represents only a portion of sulfur-containing molecules that contribute to bioavailable RSS with other molecules contained in acid-labile sulfide (eg, iron-sulfur clusters, not a focus of this review) and bound sulfane sulfur (BSS; eg, persulfides, polysulfides, and others; Figure 1A).

하이라이트.

• 황화물의 생화학적 성질과 그 대사 산물에는 폴리황화물/반응성 유황 종이 포함됩니다.
• 반응성 유황 종의 합성과 대사는 다양한 효소 경로를 통해 발생할 수 있습니다.
• 반응성 유황 종/폴리황화물은 심혈관 병태 생리학에 관여합니다.
• 심혈관 질환과 관련된 CSE(시스타티오닌 감마-리아제; 또는 CTH)의 유전적 다형성.

거의 20년이 지난 지금, 황화수소(H2S)는

중요한 신호 전달 분자이자 생물학적 기능의 핵심 조절자로 자리 잡았습니다.

H2S의 중요성에 관한 많은 연구가 이루어졌지만,

H2S의 분자 신호, 합성, 대사 경로는 아직 명확하지 않습니다.1-5

트랜스설퍼레이션 경로의 부산물인 H2S는

신경 및 혈관계 조절, 심장 보호, 허혈성 손상으로부터의 보호, 상처 회복, 인슐린 분비 등

다양한 조직과 기관에서 생리병리학적 역할을 하는 것으로 알려져 있습니다.

그러나 H2S의 화학적 특성은 문헌에 보고된 많은 생물학적 및 생화학적 연관성을 의미하는 것으로 알려져 있습니다.

이 단일 분자가 1차 생화학 상태에 있는 것만으로 보고된

모든 신호 전달과 생물학적 효과를 매개한다고 결론을 내리는 것은 지나치게 단순화한 것입니다.

따라서

황화물의 다른 화학적 중간체 또는 유도체의 존재가

많은 생물학적 기능을 매개할 수 있다는 가설을 고려하는 것이 현명합니다.

실제로,

현재 H2S 외에

CBS(cystathionine beta-synthase)와 CSE(cystathionine gamma-lyase)라는

트랜스설퍼레이션 효소를 통해

광범위한 황화물 대사 산물이 생성될 수 있다는 사실이 인정되고 있습니다.

이 대사 산물에는

과황화수소(RSSH), 폴리황화수소(RSS(n)H), 기타 산화된 황화수소 종을 포함한

반응성 황화 종(RSS)이라는 반응성 분자 그룹이 있으며,

이들은 많은 생물학적 활동과 관련된 신호 전달 물질로 확인되었습니다. 6

따라서,

H2S는 생체 이용 가능한 RSS에 기여하는 황 함유 분자의 일부만을 나타내며,

산에 불안정한 황화물(예: 이 검토의 초점이 아닌 철-황 클러스터)과 결합된

황화황(BSS; 예: 과황화물, 폴리황화물 등; 그림 1A)에 포함된

다른 분자와 함께 생체 이용 가능한 RSS에 기여합니다.

Figure 1.

이 그림은 반응성 황(reactive sulfur) 종의 다양한 형태와 상호전환 과정을 도식화한 것입니다. 

크게 (A) 생화학적 형태와 (B) 단백질 및 저분자 티올(thiol) 간 상호작용 두 부분으로 나누어 살펴볼 수 있습니다. 

A. Biochemical Forms of Reactive Sulfur
그림 (A)에서 제시하는 반응성 황은 크게 ‘자유 황화수소(Free H₂S)’와 ‘결합 황(sulfane sulfur forms)’으로 구분됩니다. 

또한, 철황 클러스터(iron sulfur cluster)나 산성 조건에서 유리되는 황산화물(acid labile sulfide) 등도 언급됩니다.

Acid-labile sulfide is sulfur that can break down into hydrogen sulfide gas (H2S) and sulfide ions (S2-) when it's exposed to acid. It's found in metalloproteins, which are made up of metal and sulfur clusters. 

산에 노출되면 황화수소 기체(H2S)와 황화 이온(S2-)으로 분해될 수 있는 산에 불안정한 황화물이 있습니다. 금속과 황 클러스터로 구성된 금속단백질에서 발견됩니다. 

Free H₂S

전형적인 기체 신호전달 분자(gasotransmitter)인 황화수소(H₂S)는 ‘유리된(Free)’ 상태에서 세포 내에서 여러 생리적 기능(혈관 확장, 항산화, 신경보호 등)을 수행합니다.m그러나 생체 내에서 완전히 자유 상태로만 존재하기보다는 단백질 잔기나 금속 보조인자 등과 결합해 있거나, 다른 황화물 종으로 전환되는 등 동적 평형이 일어납니다.

Acid Labile Sulfide

산성 조건에서 유리(acid labile)될 수 있는 황 종을 의미합니다. 예를 들어, 미토콘드리아에서 발견되는 철-황 클러스터(Fe-S cluster)는 산성 조건 하에서 H₂S로 방출되기도 하며, 호흡효소나 여러 산화환원 효소 기능에 필수적인 역할을 합니다.

Bound Sulfane Sulfur (결합 술판 황)

Persulfide(RSS⁻, RSSH): 유리 황화수소(H₂S)가 단백질 티올(-SH) 그룹 또는 저분자 티올과 반응하여 ‘RSSH(단백질 퍼설파이드)’ 같은 구조를 형성할 수 있음.

Polysulfide(RSnR, n≥2): 황 사슬 길이가 여러 개인 폴리설파이드 형태로, H₂S의 산화나 persulfide 간의 축합 등으로 생성됨.

Thiosulfate(S₂O₃²⁻)·Thiosulfonate(ROS₂⁻)·Elemental Sulfur(S⁰) 등: 황화수소가 산화되거나 다른 황 화합물 간 상호변환을 통해 생성되는 복합적 형태로, 산화환원 반응에서 중요한 중간체가 되기도 함.

이들 술판(sulfane) 황은 전자전달, 산화·환원 반응, 단백질 기능 조절(특히 티올 잔기 변형) 등에 관여합니다.

B. Protein Thiols and Small Molecular Weight Thiols
그림 (B)에서는 단백질 티올(-SH) 및 저분자 티올(예: 글루타티온(GSH))이 H₂S와 결합해 다양한 형태를 이룰 수 있음을 보여줍니다. 티올은 -SH기(thiol group)가 있는 분자를 통칭하며, 황(S) 원자가 환원상태로 존재하여 산화·환원 반응에 민감하게 작용하는 특징을 지닙니다.

Protein Thiols (단백질-황 결합)

P-SH(티올) ↔ P-SSR(디설파이드): 단백질 내 Cys(시스테인) 잔기끼리 혹은 GSH 등 다른 티올과 반응하여 디설파이드 결합(-S-S-)을 이룰 수 있음.

P-SSH(퍼설파이드), P-SNO(질소 산화물과 결합된 S-니트로실화) 등: H₂S, NO 등과 반응하여 단백질 잔기의 황에 화학적 변형을 일으키는 경우가 많음. 이를 ‘포스트 번역 수정(post-translational modification, PTM)’의 한 형태로 간주할 수 있으며, 단백질 기능 조절에 중요한 역할을 함.

Small Molecular Weight Thiols (저분자 티올)

GSH(글루타티온), Cys(시스테인) 등: 이들 저분자 티올 역시 H₂S나 ROS 등과 반응해 RSSH(퍼설파이드), R-S-S-R’(다양한 디설파이드) 구조를 형성함.

산화-환원 균형: GSH/GSSG(환원형/산화형 글루타티온) 비율이 세포 내 산화환원 상태를 나타내듯이, 티올/디설파이드 전환, 티올/퍼설파이드 전환 역시 반응성 황 종의 동적 평형 및 세포 항상성(homeostasis)에 관여합니다.

생리적·병리적 의의
신호전달 및 조절

H₂S는 NO, CO와 함께 기체 신호전달 분자로 대우받으며, 혈관계·신경계 등에서 조절자로 작용합니다.

반응성 황 종(RSS, polysulfides 등)은 단백질의 시스테인 잔기를 변형하여 효소 활성, 이온 채널 개폐, 전사인자 결합능 등을 바꿀 수 있습니다.

항산화·항염증 기능

황 화합물은 자유 라디칼과 반응해 ROS 농도를 조절하거나, 면역세포 신호전달 경로를 억제해 항염증 작용을 나타냅니다.

GSH, 티올-디설파이드 기전 역시 세포 손상 방지에 중요한 역할을 하며, 술판 황(sulfane sulfur)도 간접적·직접적으로 산화환원 균형을 조절할 수 있습니다.

대사 및 질환과의 연관

과도한 산화나 염증 상태에서, H₂S 생성 경로나 RSS 형성이 이상 과다/부족해질 경우 심혈관계 질환, 대사성 질환, 신경퇴행성 질환 등과 연관이 높아질 수 있음.

이를 역으로 이용해, RSS를 증가시키거나 특정 형태로 안정화시키는 약물 개발이 질환 치료 타깃이 될 가능성이 연구되고 있습니다.

결론
이 그림은 생체 내 H₂S와 관련 황 종들이 어떻게 서로 변환되고, 단백질·저분자 티올과 반응하여 ‘퍼설파이드, 디설파이드, 폴리설파이드’ 등 다양한 중간체 및 결합 형태를 형성하는지 요약적으로 보여줍니다. 이러한 반응성 황 종은 산화환원 반응, 신호전달, 효소 활성 조절, 항산화·항염증 방어 기전 등 광범위한 생물학적 기능을 수행하며, 각 형태 간 전환 및 평형이 세포 생리와 병리에서 핵심적 역할을 담당합니다.

Biochemical nature and species of reactive sulfur species (RSS). A, Various biochemical forms of reactive sulfur including free hydrogen sulfide (H2S), acid-labile sulfide (eg, iron-sulfur clusters), and bound sulfane sulfur. B, Various sulfide species associated with different biochemical sulfur-containing molecules. Three categories of sulfur-containing molecules involve protein thiols, H2S itself, and small-molecular-weight thiols (R designates molecules such as GSH or cysteine).

Please see www.ahajournals.org/atvb/atvb-focus for all articles published in this series.

RSS: a New Cousin to Reactive Oxygen Species and Reactive Nitrogen Species

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species can contribute to redox signaling, mediating changes in pathophysiological responses at cellular and tissue level. Reactive nitrogen species include various NO-derived compounds that play a crucial role in the regulation of many pathophysiological conditions via posttranslational modifications and interactions with ROS.7,8 This includes regulation of cell injury and death and pathological events including neurological and cardiovascular pathologies and metabolic and inflammatory diseases. However, the role of RSS beyond cellular antioxidant systems only recently has gained attention but remains ambiguous. Sulfide metabolites comprising RSS may exist in different chemical forms (Figure 1A). Our group and others have shown that sulfide may be available in biochemical pools including free sulfide, acid-labile sulfide, and BSS.9,10 Moreover, RSSs encompass sulfur-containing reactive biomolecules from small molecules to proteins (Figure 1B).11,12 Sulfane sulfurs are small-molecular-weight thiols or protein thiols bound with sulfur atoms having an oxidation state 0 or −1. Representative RSSs include H2S, protein thiols (PSH), small-molecular-weight thiols (RSH), hydrogen persulfide/polysulfide (H2Sn; n≥2), small-molecular-weight thiol persulfide (RSSH), protein persulfide (PS-SH), various polysulfides (RSS(n)H, RSS(n)R, and H2Sn; n>1), sulfenic acids (RSOH), nitrosothiols (RSNO), and various sulfide bridge forms (PS-SR, RS-S-SR, and RS-Sn-SH).12,13 Most RSSs are known to be unstable and reactive. This is reflected by the fact that the sulfur atom (S) can accept or donate electrons and exist in a wide range of oxidation states between −2 and +6, which plays an import role in many biochemical and chemical biological processes.12,14 Evidence indicates that polysulfides, rather than H2S itself, mediate protein sulfuration (aka sulfhydration) of reduced protein thiol (RSH) target proteins resulting in the formation of protein persulfide (RSSH) as the sulfur in both H2S and reduced thiol (RSH) have the same valency state and cannot react with one another.15–17 On the other hand, H2S can lead to the formation of polysulfide via reaction with sulfenic acid (RSOH) or RSNO resulting in the formation of the persulfide (RSSH) moiety. These 2 pathways alone hint at the significant degree of chemical complexity associated with RSS while highlighting their ability to react with both ROS and reactive nitrogen species metabolites.

Several functional similarities exist between ROS and RSS that are beginning to reveal a rich and previously unappreciated biochemical relationship. It has even been proposed that there could be a misinterpretation of RSS-mediated functions equated to that of ROS and vice versa, as reviewed elsewhere.18 The presence of both RSS and redox reaction mechanisms dates back to the origin of life over 4 billion years ago. For nearly the first 2 billion years of our planetary history, the environment was dominated by ferruginous- and then euxinic (H2S)-rich oceans.19 During this time, the evolution of early eukaryotic cells and ancient biochemical enzyme reaction pathways came into being followed by the Great Oxidation Event. The free radical and redox biology fields have long proposed that existing oxidant-antioxidant relationships came about in response to the Great Oxidation Event as a way for organismal adaptation and survival. While this may be true, it is also clear that RSSs were present before an abundance of oxygen and recent evidence reveals that ancient enzymes involved in antioxidant actions, such as catalase and superoxide dismutase, are also potent oxidoreductases for RSS.20,21 As such, RSSs likely serve as important biological redox mediators through participation in nucleophilic-electrophilic reactions, with thiols (RSH) being nucleophilic, disulfides (RSSR; aka oxidized thiol) being electrophilic, and persulfides (RSSH) being either electrophilic or nucleophilic upon deprotonation (RSS−). Their significant abundance further suggests the biological importance of these molecules with RSS (eg, persulfide/polysulfide) having been reported in the low-to-mid micromolar range, depending on the tissue and cell type studied.5,22 Unfortunately, our understanding of these RSS metabolites and how they contribute to cardiovascular pathophysiology remains essentially unknown, thereby requiring much more study.

Chemical Nature of Thiol, Sulfide, and RSS

Chemically, all acid-base and redox reactions can be determined in terms of electrophiles and nucleophiles. Electrophiles are neutral or charged atoms that are electron deficient. While nucleophiles are electron rich that will react to decrease their electron density, they can be neutral or charged and tend to have negative charges. However, there are neutral molecules that are both electrophiles and nucleophiles. Chemically, H2S has reductive and nucleophilic properties that contribute to its physiological actions. Importantly, as indicated above, persulfides can exhibit a dual nature, as a nucleophile and an electrophile. While persulfides can have enhanced nucleophilicity with the corresponding thiol, the inner and outer sulfurs can both act as electrophiles.

Thiols (RSH) play critical roles in regulating redox signaling, cellular functions, and in improving protein structure and stability.16 Thiols are also the redox currency of the major intracellular redox buffer, glutathione, and a cadre of redox enzymes, such as peroxiredoxins, Trx (thioredoxins), Trx reductases, glutaredoxins, and glutathione reductases, are used to maintain this balance. Renewed interests have recently led the research community to study thiol chemistry and biological implications including (1) thiol role to generate H2S, which is now an established regulator of biological functions, and (2) identification of various thiol/sulfide compounds that may have potential biological significance. Importantly, thiols can regulate cellular processes through protein modifications, including S-sulfhydration/sulfuration (PS-SH), S-glutathionylation (PS-SG), and cysteinylation (PS-S-Cys).11,23

RSS Formation in Biology

H2S exists at physiological pH and 37°C in various forms of gas H2S (≈20%), H2S ion (HS−, ≈80%), and sulfide ion (S2−, <0.1%). H2S is predominantly produced by CBS in the nervous system and CSE in the vascular system using homocysteine, cystathionine, or L-cysteine as substrates (Figure 2).24–26 Importantly, CBS and CSE can also use cystine (CysSSCys) as a substrate forming cysteine persulfide (CysSSH), which is biologically relevant.22 Per- and polysulfides are not only formed enzymatically but can also be carried by proteins such as plasma albumin, which has the ability to bind `and transport sulfane sulfur.27 There are several biologically relevant oxidants that can support oxidation of H2S. H2S can be oxidized by 1- or 2-electron oxidant pathway with varied rate constants described in Figure 2. For 2-electron oxidation, the bimolecular rate constant between hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) and sulfide is 0.73 M−1 s−1. For the 1-electron oxidation, the sulfhydryl radical (HS·) can be produced, following a series of radical chain reactions that results in persulfide formation. Additionally, MST (3-mercaptosulfotransferase) has the ability to generate per/polysulfides apart from H2S.28 MST obtains sulfur from 3-mercaptopyruvate to produce MST polysulfide, which can be reduced by Trx to release H2Sn, such as H2S, H2S2, H2S3, and others. MST can transfer the sulfur atom from 3-mercaptopyruvate to its catalytic site (Cys248) to form MST persulfide (MST-SSH) or form H2S3.29,30 Moreover, SQR can catalyze the oxidation of H2S to sulfane sulfur, with this sulfane sulfur metabolized to sulfite leading to the formation of thiosulfate or glutathione persulfide.31,32 GSSH may also react with glutathione disulfide (GSSG) to produce the glutathione trisulfide (GSSSG) or GSSSSG. Importantly, all of these oxidized glutathione species can be reduced by glutathione reductase to form glutathione per/polysulfide.33–35

Figure 2.

Open in a new tab

Formation and metabolism of reactive sulfur species. Transsulfuration enzymes CBS (cystathionine beta-synthase) and CSE (cystathionine gamma-lyase) use substrates homocysteine, cystathionine, or cysteine to generate hydrogen sulfide (H2S). H2S may subsequently react with reactive oxygen species (eg, superoxide) resulting in sulfide radical formation leading to persulfide formation. Rate constants (M−1 s−1) are shown for each reaction indicating that H2S reacts more quickly with superoxide vs hydrogen peroxide. CARS (cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase) enzyme activity also contributes to cysteine persulfide formation that may be translationally incorporated into nascent polypeptide formation. PP indicates pyrophosphate; and tRNA, transfer RNA.

Recently, the CARS (cysteinyl-tRNA synthetases) group of enzymes have been identified to generate per/polysulfides and RSS, which can regulate different protein functions. Cysteine persulfide and polysulfide are produced in cells and are abundant in low-molecular-weight proteins and protein fractions. However, the physiological functions of cysteine persulfides/polysulfides produced in cells remain poorly understood. Results from Akaike et al have established CARS (CARS-1 and 2) as novel enzymes that can synthesize persulfides. CARS catalyzes the transfer of sulfur from one cysteine to another cysteine forming a cysteine persulfide and polysulfide.15 CARS2 being the mitochondrial isoform of CARS predominantly produces RSS that contributes to mitochondrial function.15,36 However, how these reactive sulfur molecules are formed, or what role they play within cells and tissues, has not been well defined. Additionally, the bioavailable concentrations of different RSS metabolites including per/polysulfides, their intracellular localization, and chemical reactivity with other molecules remain unknown under healthy versus pathological cardiovascular conditions.

Among nonenzymatic reactions, H2S can form persulfide and polysulfide through various reactions involving ROS such as superoxide (Figures 1B and 2). Superoxide can oxidize H2S resulting in thiyl radical formation that can react with hydrosulfide (HS−) anion to generate perthiyl radical leading to further polysulfide formation. H2S in its gaseous form does not readily react with oxygen but under aqueous conditions can be oxidized to hydrogen thioperoxide (HSOH), sulfurous acid (H2SO3), thiosulfuric acid (H2S2O3), and other small oxoacids of sulfur including sulfenic (HSOH), sulfoxylic (HS[O]OH), and thiosulfoxylic acids (H2S2O2).37 HSSH can react with other sulfane sulfur to produce hydrogen polysulfide (HSSnSH; n>1). As mentioned earlier, sulfenic acid (RSOH) and S-nitrosothiols (RSNO) can also react with H2S forming persulfide.38 Lastly, some metal centers can oxidize H2S to form sulfhydryl radical (HS·), which can react with free thiols, ultimately generating persulfide and polysulfide.39,40

Bioavailability and Biological Significance of RSS

RSS can be formed as byproduct of major thiols or as a result of oxidation of sulfite or sulfate molecules. Per/polysulfides have been identified in mammalian and other biological systems with possible involvement in various cellular functions. Intracellular cysteine persulfide and polysulfide exist in abundance in both low-molecular-weight proteins and protein fractions. Recent works focused on detection techniques have determined the levels of per/polysulfides levels in biological systems.12,15,16,36,41–43 Various assays including monobromobimane LC-MS/MS, polarographic electrode, and chemiluminescence/fluorescent probes have revealed per/polysulfides of cell culture and tissue lysates to range from low micromolar to nano/picomolar concentrations (Table).

Table.

RSS Measurement and Bioavailability

Open in a new tab

BSS pools predominantly include per- and polysulfides, which can subsequently release H2S under reducing conditions. The clinical relevance of sulfide pools, including BSS, has recently been demonstrated by our group showing that plasma H2S metabolite bioavailability can be a predictive indicator for cardiovascular disease (CVD).44 In this study, we have reported that the BSS levels were significantly reduced in subjects with CVD compared with those without disease. This underscores the importance of cellular redox state for regulating H2S bioavailability and also suggests a role for BSS in cardiovascular health.

Studies on exogenous H2S delivery have suggested that oxidized sulfur species, including sulfane sulfur, may mediate physiological functions that were thought to be solely H2S driven.18,58 Although H2S is a short-lived molecule, numerous studies demonstrated its prolonged biological effects in mammalian systems. Apart from the exogenous formation of inorganic polysulfides in a solution of NaHS, the existence of endogenous inorganic polysulfides has also been demonstrated.59–61

Atherosclerosis is a chronic progressive disease manifesting in clinical CVD. Atherosclerosis is a complex process involving endothelial dysfunction and vascular inflammation, among others. Interrelation between H2S and atherosclerotic progression has recently been appreciated.62–64 Wang et al63 demonstrated that CSE/H2S pathway was disturbed in the vasculature of apoE (apolipoprotein E)−/− mice. A significant decrease in H2S bioavailability was observed in the plasma and aorta of apoE−/− mice but a higher CSE expression‎ in aorta. However, exogenous NaHS therapy inhibits proatherogenic and inflammatory effects in apoE−/− via IkB degradation and thus NF-κB (nuclear factor-kappa B) signaling pathway. Further, Mani et al62 have demonstrated that decreased endogenous H2S bioavailability leads to early development of atherosclerosis. They observed that CSE-knockout mice fed with high-fat diet have increased proatherogenic symptoms including elevated cholesterol-rich lipoproteins, aortic lesions, enhanced aortic intimal proliferation, and proinflammatory signaling. Additionally, CSE/apoE double-knockout mice have further exacerbated atherosclerosis development than single-gene knockouts.65 CSE deficiency can increase neointima formation in ligated carotid arteries, which was attenuated by sulfide therapy. The proatherogenic effects were significantly reduced either by exogenous sulfide treatment or global CSE overexpression‎.62,66 These studies indicate that CSE/sulfide metabolite signaling regulates atherogenesis via inflammatory signaling.62–64 Elevated homocysteinemia can also lead to impairment in macrophage CSE/polysulfide production that eventually causes vascular inflammation in mice mediated by elevated proinflammatory cytokines TNF-α (tumor necrosis factor-α) and IL-1β (interleukin-1β).67 Additionally, homocysteinemia can also elevate DNA hypermethylation eventually repressing CSE transcription.

Work from our group has identified a unique relationship between shear flow pattern-specific CSE expression‎ and endothelial cell phenotype.68 In this study, Yuan et al reported that laminar shear significantly reduced CSE protein expression‎ and polysulfide production, whereas disturbed flow regions show elevated CSE in endothelial cells. Concurrently, in vivo model showed higher CSE expression‎ where aortic curvature is lesser compared with the greater curvature. Change in CSE expression‎ under disturbed flow protects against inward vascular remodeling. Additionally, CSE−/− mice showed reduced inward remodeling where it remains dilated under reduced shear indicating compromised regulation in vascular remodeling after partial carotid ligation. These observations indicate that CSE protects proatherogenic condition by promoting flow-mediated vascular remodeling and reduced endothelial activation (Figure 3A). Lack of CSE also limits disturbed flow-induced proinflammatory signaling including ICAM-1 (intercellular adhesion molecule-1) and VCAM-1 (vascular cell adhesion molecule-1) gene expressions and monocyte infiltration mediated by NF-κB.68 Recently, work from Bibli et al69 confirmed our observations revealing that expression‎ of CSE was higher in the lesser curvature and arterial bifurcations. CSE critically maintains low arterial CD62E levels to minimize monocyte adhesion at sites of low or disturbed flow to minimize monocyte-mediated inflammation. Exogenous polysulfide through SG1002 or CSE overexpression‎ restored sulfhydration of HuR (human antigen R) and reduced CD62E (E-selectin) protein expression‎ to attenuate monocyte adherence (Figure 3B). However, in inflammatory conditions, this protective mechanism was lost due to phosphorylation (on Ser377) and inactivation of CSE.69 These studies suggest that defective CSE/polysulfide signaling can lead to accelerated development of endothelial dysfunction and atherosclerosis, which can be rectified via CSE/polysulfide therapy. Furthermore, Bibli et al65 reported a paradigm in which endothelial CSE may prevent atherosclerosis development and redox regulation via a loss of Prx6 (peroxiredoxin 6) sulfhydration. Interestingly, the polysulfide donor SG1002 could restore Prx6 sulfhydration in CSE-deficient ECs attributing the beneficial effects of polysulfide to attenuate atherosclerosis development. However, much uncertainty remains regarding the distinct roles of CSE and other sulfur species in shear stress and vascular remodeling that warrants additional studies to better understand specific mechanistic pathways.

Figure 3.

Open in a new tab

CSE (cystathionine gamma-lyase)/polysulfide modulates vascular remodeling responses. A, CSE expression‎ and sulfane sulfur production are enhanced by disturbed flow in conduit vessels. Enhanced CSE increases macrophage recruitment in areas of disturbed flow that induces flow-mediated vascular remodeling. CSE knockout conditions have reduced polysulfide following partial carotid artery ligation, leading to defective inward remodeling, and a dilated vascular phenotype due to elevated NO bioavailability in CSE knockout carotid arteries. B, CSE-derived polysulfide inactivates HuR (human antigen R) via S-sulfhydration and attenuates CD62E expression‎ that consequently regulates vascular inflammation and atherogenesis. Defective CSE/polysulfide leads to activation of HuR and subsequent CD62E stability that induces EC dysfunction and atherogenesis. C, CSE-derived sulfur species increase endothelial solute permeability via regulation of endothelial junction proteins claudin 5 and VE-cadherin and enhanced actin stress fiber formation. CD62E indicates E-selectin; EC, endothelial cells; IL-1β, interleukin-1β; and VE-Cadherin, vascular endothelial cadherin.

We have previously demonstrated that endogenous BSS regulates endothelial barrier functions.61 Our data revealed that endothelial solute permeability is critically regulated via exogenous and endogenous sulfide bioavailability with a dominant role of polysulfides. Polysulfides induced endothelial junction disorganization leading to increased vascular permeability.61 Additionally, we found that CSE regulates endothelial barrier integrity through regulation of endogenous polysulfide production. Genetic deficiency of CSE in endothelial cells significantly reduced the BSS pool compared with wild-type cells, which was associated with decreased basal endothelial permeability (ie, tighter barrier function).61 In comparison with exogenous sulfide donors such as NaHS, the polysulfides including Na2S2, Na2S3, and Na2S4 elicited a much stronger increase in endothelial solute permeability and loss of endothelial barrier function (Figure 3C). In another study, the Pluth Laboratory reported that the polysulfide diallyl trisulfide and synthetic polysulfides regulate cell proliferation of a murine brain endothelial cell line.64 Their work demonstrated trisulfide and tetrasulfide release H2S via thiol-mediated reduction in the presence of cysteine or reduced glutathione associated with bEnd.3 cell viability.64 These studies highlight that rather than just H2S, per- and polysulfides are equally capable of regulating various endothelial cell functions.

Works from the Akaike Laboratory have shown that the enzyme CARS, which generates cysteine persulfides, can regulate cellular functions including mitochondria function and bioenergetics.36,43,70 Activation of TRPA1 in rat astrocytes has been induced by polysulfide donors more effectively than exogenous H2S donors.71,72 Similarly, induction of Keap1/Nrf2 (Kelch-like ECH-associated protein 1/nuclear factor erythroid 2-related factor 2) activation has been observed in neuronal cells by polysulfide donors.71–73 Moreover, garlic-derived polysulfides have long been well known to possess antitumor effects.74 However, further study is needed to elucidate the antitumor mechanisms of inorganic polysulfides and to differentiate their role from exogenous H2S. Lastly, recent work from Zhang et al75 has observed that cellular polysulfides may play a role in the regulation of inflammatory signaling and can be a potential target for inflammatory disorders. This group demonstrated that polysulfides desensitize macrophages to TLR4 (Toll-like receptor 4) and negatively regulate TLR4-mediated proinflammatory signaling. However, these observations require further study in CVD and inflammatory model systems.

Lefer et al have provided insights into cardioprotective role of sulfide and polysulfide in various models of CVD and cardiovascular injury. Exogenous H2S delivery or endogenous CSE overexpression‎ and H2S modulation has been therapeutically beneficial for ischemic heart failure.76–79 Modulation of endogenous H2S through cardiac-specific CSE overexpression‎ has cardioprotective effects.77 In a mouse model of myocardial ischemia-reperfusion, exogenous H2S delivery during reperfusion inhibited myocardial inflammation, reduced infarct size, and preserved left ventricular function. There was a significant reduction in myocardial injury and cytoprotection in the model of myocardial ischemia-reperfusion in mice with cardiac-specific CSE overexpression‎. Exogenous donor diallyl trisulfide rescued from myocardial injury in a murine model of myocardial ischemia/reperfusion.78 Diallyl trisulfide therapy not only reduced myocardial infarct size but also improved myocardial contractile function, preserving mitochondria function. These events were mediated via extended endogenous H2S release, increased eNOS activity, and NO metabolites.78 Similarly, Goodchild and et al79 demonstrated cardio- and vasoprotective effects of sulfide prodrug, SG1002, in a porcine model of peripheral arterial disease (PAD). Sulfide prodrug preserved vessel density and improved endothelial-dependent coronary artery vasorelaxation in critical limb ischemia model via H2S/NO metabolite signaling. These observations are in conjunction with our clinical study that reported a significant decrease in the levels of total, acid-labile, and bound sulfane sulfide in plasma samples of subjects of vascular disease including CVD and PAD.44 This implicates the association of polysulfide to CVD, which needs extensive studies.

Genetic polymorphisms of CSE/CTH may also be implicated in various disease conditions including CVD.80 As discussed earlier, we observed variations in H2S metabolite levels in CVD.44 Interestingly, we found polymorphisms in CSE/CTH gene were associated with the risk of CVD. A significant increase in CSE (CTH) 1364 G-T allele frequency was observed in patients with CVD compared with controls. These findings were concurrent with reduced plasma H2S/BSS bioavailability changes in CVD.44 However, future clinical studies are needed to identify the significance and relevance of polysulfide as a biomarker of any pathology as different ethnic populations may not be similarly influenced by genetic polymorphisms.81 A case-controlled GWAS in Greek population has investigated previously documented 9 SNPs82 and compared composite genetic risk scores associated with CHD that would impact high-risk alleles.83 Changes in genetic risk scores have only modestly improved CHD risk prediction; however, there was a lack of distinction between ischemia and hemorrhagic stroke for their relevance into CHD-specific risk alleles. Moreover, few of the CHD-associated SNPs that were identified previously were not found in Greek populations. These observations suggest that ethnic differences could play a substantial role in CVD-associated genetic variations, which warrants further studies based on ethnic populations.

Conclusions

While H2S is considered a signaling molecule and regulator of many biological functions, it is clear that RSSs have similar properties. Moreover, specific chemical forms that are associated with biological functions remain inconclusive, as do specific stimuli mediating their formation and tissue and cellular distribution. Understanding bioavailable levels of endogenous persulfide/polysulfide will shed important light into developing strategies for various cardiovascular pathological conditions. Other pertinent questions also remain such as What biological chemistry conditions trigger the enzymatic release of per/polysulfide? What factors mediate their release and balance with H2S bioavailability? How does the redox status of cellular microenvironments influence the generation and bioavailability of per/polysulfide? What is the differential role and importance of per/polysulfide formation through redox reactions versus enzymatic synthesis (eg, CARS)? Additionally, genomics and metabolomics approaches may also reveal new mechanisms of per/polysulfide formation and metabolism impacting cellular signaling and function. In summary, it is imperative to understand the pathophysiological importance of RSS per- and polysulfides, which will provide new insight into sulfide biology while identifying novel therapeutic strategies for CVD.

Sources of Funding

This work was supported by an Institutional Development Award from the National Institutes of General Medical Sciences of the National Institutes of Health under grant No. P20GM121307 to C.G. Kevil.

Disclosures

C.G. Kevil and X. Shen have provisional patents regarding measurement and use of sulfides. C.G. Kevil is a cofounder of Innolyzer, LLC. The other author reports no conflicts.

Footnotes

Nonstandard Abbreviations and AcronymsapoE

apolipoprotein E

BSS

bound sulfane sulfur

CARS

cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase

CBS

cystathionine beta-synthase

CSE/CTH

cystathionine gamma-lyase

CVD

cardiovascular disease

H2S

hydrogen sulfide

HuR

human antigen R

ICAM-1

intercellular adhesion molecule-1

IL-1β

interleukin-1β

MST

3-mercaptosulfotransferase

NF-κB

nuclear factor-kappa B

Prx6

peroxiredoxin 6

ROS

reactive oxygen species

RSS

reactive sulfur species

TLR4

Toll-like receptor 4

TNF-α

tumor necrosis factor-α

Trx

thioredoxin

VCAM-1

vascular cell adhesion molecule-1

For Sources of Funding and Disclosures, see page 882.

References

• 1.Kabil O, Banerjee R. Enzymology of H2S biogenesis, decay and signaling. Antioxid Redox Signal. 2014;20:770–782. doi: 10.1089/ars.2013.5339. doi: 10.1089/ars.2013.5339. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
• 2.Kolluru GK, Shen X, Bir SC, Kevil CG. Hydrogen sulfide chemical biology: pathophysiological roles and detection. Nitric Oxide. 2013;35:5–20. doi: 10.1016/j.niox.2013.07.002. doi: 10.1016/j.niox.2013.07.002. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]