연구 결과가 이해하기 어려우면 Félix Guattari처럼 지적사기꾼(Intellectual Imposter)으로 불릴 수도 있습니다

[석수]

자기 자신도 잘 모르고 글을 쓰게 되면 남들이 이해하기 어렵게 됩니다

진리는 통연하게 명백한 법이기 때문입니다

그래서 난해한 글을 쓴 사람은 지적사기꾼으로 불릴 수 있습니다


The word "imposter" (and its more common variant "impostor") comes from the Old French imposteur, which in turn comes from the Late Latin impostor. Both ultimately derive from the Latin verb imponere, meaning "to impose upon" or "to deceive". Essentially, the etymology points to someone who "imposes" a false identity on others.

Latin origin: The root is imponere, a combination of in- ("in, on, upon") and ponere ("to put, place").

Latin noun: The past participle impositus ("placed upon") evolved into the agent noun impostor, meaning "one who imposes".

French influence: The word entered English from the 16th-century French imposteur.

English usage: The word was first used in English in the 1580s to mean "swindler, cheat," and later evolved to its current meaning of someone who pretends to be someone else to deceive others.


https://youtu.be/csjQY2ttL40?si=1pX77XXymZQXvfWi

아는 것을 안다고 하고
모르는 것을 모른다고 하는 것이 진짜 아는 것인데
자기 자신도 잘 모르는 것을 아는 것처럼 써놓으면
다른 사람들이 당연히 이해하기 어렵기 때문에
과타리처럼 그런 지적 허세에 찬 사람들을 두고 지적 사기꾼이라 부르는 것입니다



we explore the claim that Félix Guattari is an "intellectual imposter", as asserted by Sokal, Bricmont and Dawkins in 1998.

What did he do with his life?

Why was his work so hard to understand, especially back in 1998?

Was he really an "intellectual imposter" with "strong ambitions to succeed in academia"?


우리는 1998년 소칼, 브리몬트, 도킨스가 주장한 펠릭스 과타리가 "지적 사기꾼"이라는 주장을 탐구합니다.

그는 자신의 삶에서 무엇을 했나요?

특히 1998년 당시 그의 연구는 왜 그렇게 이해하기 어려웠을까요?

그는 정말 "학계에서 성공하려는 강한 야망"을 가진 "지적 사기꾼"이었나요?




impostor
noun [ C ] (also imposter)


a person who pretends to be someone else in order to deceive others:

He felt like an impostor among all those intelligent people, as if he had no right to be there.





impostor

noun [ C ] (also imposter)

a person who pretends to be someone else in order to deceive others:

He felt like an impostor among all those intelligent people, as if he had no right to be there.



impostor

noun [ C ] (also imposter)
us /ɪmˈpɑs·tər/

a person who pretends to be someone else in order to deceive others


impostor 용례들


He proposed the establishment of bureaucratic review committees to distinguish between the worthy students and the many impostors that allegedly filled the medreses.



If backing down or reneging on a policy promise is costly, then such pronouncements help separate resolved states from the many impostors.



The political account of enthusiasm, another nonmedical interpretation given to the phenomenon of prophecy and enthusiasm, viewed the enthusiasts as impostors and even conspirators.


To her father, her verbal precocity implies that she must be an impostor.


But the idea of qualitative superiority cannot be any of the impostors.



These impostors can all be accommodated by standard hedonism, which regards pleasure - the sole intrinsic value - as a single kind of feeling whatever its sources or objects.



It is clearly recognised that fraud must be eradicated and impostors punished.


The important thing is that individual touch should be kept with the men, so that they should not help men who are impostors.


If so, then we are nothing but a bunch of impostors, applying different standards to different countries.



Would he be sufficiently protected if the vendor or the purporting vendor were in fact an impostor?


It would have been said, in varying tones of indignation, that he was little better than a hollow impostor and meant to go no further.



The celebrity panelists question the three contestants; the impostors are allowed to lie but the central character is sworn to tell the truth.



She then handed over the money to an accomplice of the impostor.


In the beginning of this poem the fox is anything but a successful impostor, being generally outwitted by far weaker animals.



This disorder is defined as a delusion that a close relative or friend has been replaced by an impostor.