Nasa's 2013 solar flare warning: how much do we need to worry?

[김홍성]

2013년이 되면 뭔가 안좋을거라고 NASA형님들이 그랬다는군요.

오늘부터 살빼는거 포기하고 그냥 좋아하는 목살+쏘주 먹으로 갈랍니다.

http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/culture/tomchivers/100008500/nasas-2013-solar-flare-warning-how-much-do-we-need-to-worry/

Tom Chivers

Tom Chivers is Telegraph.co.uk's Strategic Events Editor. He is a science nerd and pedant, and thinks cinema reached its pinnacle with Fight Club and music with Faith No More. He writes on science, culture and anything that crosses his mind. He is on Twitter at twitter.com/tomchivers.

 

 

Nasa's 2013 solar flare warning: how much do we need to worry?

 

By Tom ChiversLast updated: June 16th, 2010

Comment on thisComment on this article

 

So, do we really need to worry about a huge solar storm burning out the electrical systems of half the world in 2013? Masochists that we are here at the Telegraph, we love to shoot down our own stories, and I was cracking my knuckles for this one. It’s got all the ingredients – white-coated authority, grave warnings of impending doom, exciting sciencey nuclear nemesis in space. NASA! Solar flares! Planes falling out of the sky! Etc.

But I read the piece, and spoke to the reporter, and – while always remembering that I am no more an astrophysicist than I am a black belt in tae kwon do – it sounded pretty solid. Dr Richard Fisher, the director of Nasa’s Heliophysics division, is very clear in the quotes, and our reporter, Andrew Hough, was very careful to check his facts with Dr Fisher before publishing. It sounds like a lot of serious people think that this is a real danger.

Apparently the concern is in 2013, the sun will reach a stage of its cycle when these large events are more likely. This might strike you as a bit strange, as you’ve probably heard (as have I) that the sun has been especially active for the last half-century or so and is expected to die down in the next couple of years – I spoke to Marcus Chown, the physicist and author of We Need to Talk about Kelvin, who said “Solar activity has been abnormally high for the past 50 years, but the extremely feeble start to the latest 11-year cycle suggests this activity is coming to an end and things are going to be quiet on the Sun for quite a few years.” Dr Ruth Bamford, a plasma physicist at the Rutherford-Applet‎on Laboratory, agrees:  “The sun has been particularly quiet for the last few years in a protracted solar minimum. It has just woken up, as it were, and started its usual 11-year cycle a bit later than most.”

So what’s going on? Well, something similar has happened before. In 1859 a huge solar storm burned out telegraph wires across Europe and the United States. Dr Stuart Clark has written a book, The Sun Kings, about when that happened. He says that the “Carrington flare”, as it was known, “smothered two-thirds of the Earth’s skies in a blood-red aurora a night later, and crippled all of global navigation and global communication, such as it was at that time.  Compasses span uselessly and the telegraph network went down as phantom electricity surged through the wire.”

The sun had indeed been running at a record high for the latter half of the 20th century, and has now died down to its lowest level for a century. But Dr Clark warns that “average levels of solar activity has fallen does not mean that the Sun is immune from large flares or even giant ones. Low average levels of activity may even promote the giant flares.

“Perhaps like earthquakes, when there are constant flares/tremors the energy is dissipated evenly over long periods of time. But in periods of quiet, that energy can build up and then suddenly be released in a giant event. This remains speculation, however.”

2013 is when the next peak in the sun’s cycle of activity is expected, and while we cannot predict individual flares, Dr Clark says that the largest flares are often shortly after the peak.

Of course, if a proper “Carrington event” happens again, it has the potential to be far more problematic now than in 1859 when electric communication was barely in its infancy. Dr Clark says “There is absolutely no reason to believe that we are heading for solar armageddon in 2013, but sooner or later we should expect there to be another Carrington event and that is what these scientists [at NASA] are trying to prevent. Legislation in the US has just passed Congress to help harden the grid against solar flares.”

So – it’s a real thing, and we should be concerned. But preventive measures can be taken – satellites can be sent offline during big flares, power grids and communication networks can be shielded against electromagnetic radiation and so on. As Dr Bamford says: “The extreme events like the 1859 Carrington Event  are 1-in-100-year probabilities, about the same probability as a storm of the level of Katrina  hitting New Orleans – and New Orleans did not build their defences to withstand the extreme-but-unlikely magnitude. 100 years isn’t that long.

“But the end of the world it is not. Maybe as disruptive as an ash cloud, but not as protracted I’m sure.” She gives examples of precautions, like a GPS backup system called eLoran, or active mini-magnetosphere shielding for astronauts and satellites that her team have designed.

Of course, if those precautions are taken, and actually work, and no damage is done, then everyone will cry that it was all a big fuss over nothing, like they always do. So the scientists can’t win, really. But that’s just how it is.

Edit: Dr Ruth Bamford got in touch, with a few extended quotes and clarifying her thoughts and her job description. Have changed accordingly.

Tags:astronomy, dr stuart clark, marcus chown, nasa, physics, science, solar flares, space

 

[차칸元炯敦]

독해하다가 먼저 죽을듯.... --;;

[김학현]

I'm so stupid, Don't understand this information...
멍청하면 팔자가 편하다지요, 않 좋은건 모르는게 약... ㅋㅋㅋ

[이용현[운영위원]]

기장님 아무리 무슨일이 생기더라도......어제 탑승하신 이쁘신 승무원 3분은 가입시켜야 합니다. Q400모형에 관심을 가지시더군요.우하하하하

[김홍성]

아 ㅋ 자혜씨랑 민경씨요? ㅋㅋ 조만간 정모에 데리고갈께요 ㅋㅋ

[이용현[운영위원]]

기대 만빵입니다,하하하하하하하하하하. 정모가 힘들다면 사적인 자리로 찾아갈수 있습니다.

[서상일]

꿈깨셔 운영위원님.....

[김수형]

이자혜씨에게 선물 받을려고 아이스 쇼크 까지드렸는데.. 헐~~기장님께 아무 말도 못들었다는..정모때 비행소녀들과~~미팅주선..해주세요~~ㅋㅋ

[주용범™~]

미팅주선 부탁...ㅋㅋ

[김수형]

전 이자혜씨를 주세요~~^^

[박진욱-kittyhawk-]

ㅋㅋㅋ~~ 몇년을 기다리던 레어가 출시되는 것보다 뜨거운 반응이라니... 저도 빠질 수 없군요... 그 줄에 동참해봅니다.

[박진욱-kittyhawk-]

그리고... MBA (Married But Available) 과정 형님들은 동생들에게 양보좀 해주시고... 그리고 학생들은 공부해야하니 제외하고... 20대는 아직 기회가 많으니 제외... 카페의 기준인 34인치 허리 미만도 제외... 아~ 저만 남게 조건을 더 붙여야 되는데...

[田昊珍[운영자]]

아하하 이자혜씨 안나오면 기장님은 스탠바이부터 다시 시작~~

[이용현[운영위원]]

찬성.1

[김수형]

찬성~~2

[주용범™~]

찬성3

[김홍성]

정말 나오면 전 어디까지 올라가나요? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[이용현[운영위원]]

오~~ 이런 긍정적인 대답...기장님 감사합니다. 규정을 바꾸도록 회의 한번 해야겠는걸요.ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[최용환]

찬성4...우리 총각들 미팅 주선....

[신민규]

흠....